Ode to a Single Shot

Status
Not open for further replies.

MacTech

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
774
Location
Sector ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
H&R Topper Deluxe Classic (TDC), how do I love thee, let me count the ways...

1; Thou art simple in lines, form, and mechanism, and in that simplicity, lies beauty

2; Thou art as reliable as the day is long, as reliable as rock, as the tide, as the orbit of the celestial bodies in the sky, whenever I reach for thee, I know that thou will be there, thou wilst never let me down

3; Thy lines and curves fit me as if thou was crafted solely for me, even though I am not your first owner, thee point naturally, thou are an extension of my arms, when I shoulder thou, we are as one, man and machine, united in the fight against the encroachment of the Evil Orange Frisbees

4; Thou are a rejection of the latest Übertactical craze infesting the shotgun world, a return to the roots of scattergunning, one barrel, one shot, simplicity defined

(okay, getting tired of this whole "Olde Schoole" language thingy here, switching to conventional voice)

I really do love my pair of TDC's, a 12 and a 20 gauge, right now, the 20 is getting far more use, mainly because it's just more comfortable to shoot, it soaks up recoil, thanks in part to my recoil-absorber in the stock, the heavy barrel (the TDC 20G barrel is a 12-gauge blank bored out to 20G, the barrel walls are twice as thick as the standard H&R 20G barrel), and the nice, dense walnut furniture.

Using my largely unscientific testing procedure of "hang the gun off my Zebco DeLiar 229 fish scale", the TDC 20 tips the scale at 8 lbs, the 12 tips the scale at a pound less, 7 lbs, so coincidentally, the 12 kicks a bit harder, whatever shells I shoot in the 12, a similar shell in this particular TDC 20 has noticeably less recoil, be it a WinLite 7/8 oz shell, or a full power 2 3/4 buckshot shell, my TDC 20 just soaks up the recoil, heck, it even made shooting Federal #3 Buck 20 pellet 2 3/4" shells a non-issue, recoil? what recoil? and I even have the stock big squishy H&R recoil pad on the 20, not a nice, fancy Limbsaver, the TDC 20 just doesn't *need* one

I'm actually considering trying a 3" Magnum slug in the TDC 20, to see what the felt recoil will be like, I have a feeling that it's gonna' be no problem

a Fed #4 Buck 2 3/4" in the 12G TDC gives a firm, insistent shove to the shoulder, almost twice the felt recoil, the TDC 12 definitely has a bit of "bite" to it...

Both the TDC 12 and 20 are great guns, and I did end up with the 12 first, but you know, if I had gotten the 20 first, I would have never purchased the 12, the 20 does everything the 12 does, and does it with a more comfortable, manageable recoil

If you get a chance to pick up a TDC in 20 gauge, *JUMP* at the chance, it's a *great* gun, this is one of the few guns in my collection that will *NEVER* be sold, I may eventually sell/trade off my Mossberg 500, heck, I may eventually trade/sell my TDC 12G, but the TDC 20G is here to *STAY*, and not many guns in my collection can say that...

I *LOVE* the TDC series, and I especially love the truly sweet TDC 20G...

Of course, to be fair, there is one minor downside to the TDC 20G, and that's weight, the combination of the heavy "bull" barrel (makes the Mossberg 590A1 barrel walls look thin by comparison) and my recoil absorber in the stock make it a little less fun to carry around for woods-walking, oh and the barrel finish could be better, the bluing is okay, but the barrel itself has a kind of "ringy" texture to it, you'd think on a "working man's" gun like this that H&R would have parkerized the barrel, I think a Parked TDC would look really nice, solid and utilitarian

Before I got this 20, I'd go to my local range intermittently, when I felt like it, usually 2-3 times a week, usually hitting the rifle and handgun range, spending an hour or so punchin' paper, and then head home...

Since getting the TDC 20G, I've gone *every* week, and spent a good 3-4 hours there, shooting both Evil Orange Frisbees, and the shooting the fecal matter with my fellow shooters between matches, and staying around after I'm done to help clean up and shut down the range when everyone finishes

it's a great group of shooters at my range, today we got to talking about reloading shotshells, as I'm a newb with shotshell reloading (but not with reloading metallic cartridges), in fact, one of the guys is going to bring one of his spare presses next weekend, give me a quick lesson, and then let me borrow the press until the next week :D

He also gave me one of his handloads, 7/8 oz of shot, and a minimum charge of ?green dot? powder IIRC, it dusted the EOF quite handily, and had essentially *no* recoil, and a nice, quiet muzzle report, a truly great load
 
Last edited:
This was amusing. On a serious note, a single shot 12 gauge is on the long list of toys to acquire.
 
My NEF Handi-rifle in 30-06 was the hit of moose hunting camp in Ont a few years ago. All the above qualities....quick to load/unload, simple, short, rugged.
One of the guys bought on for himself when he got home.

Sounds like you may be hooked on the EOF's. It's great that you help at the club. Some dont realize that target need to be hauled, hulls picked up, grass mowed, traps loaded, etc, etc. Lots of work to be done for everyone to enjoy shooting. This has been the death of many clubs.

One of the secrets of successful trapshooters is recoil control. Your brain eventually won't allow pain....and will refuse to pull the trigger thus rewarding you with a flinch. Green dot/ounce shot is great load. I used it from 27yds sometimes.
 
I absolutely love the H&R/NEF single shots. Don't have a rifle (yet) but own a nice little passle of their shotguns in various forms.
 
if I had gotten the 20 first, I would have never purchased the 12,

The most telling line in your entire post. And it was a good post too.

I have also got the SS shotgun bug lately. I also have the 410 bug. I have always had the 20ga bug. The 20 is my favorite SG round. I have an H&R Tamer 20 that I put a full sized buttstock on. It came with one of the Snake Charmer style stocks and was way too short for me to use.

My gun only weighs 5.25 pounds and is a pleasure to carry. It does have a little recoil but not too bad. My buddy called it my "Toy" shotgun because its only 37" or so long. After I shot circles around him and he was using a 12ga model 1100 he sorta shutup. I have never outshot him before. He is a helluva shotgun shot. But not good enough that day.

I found a NEF 410 for $85 OTD. Weighs about 7.5 pounds and is a blast to shoot. I also have a Stevens 20 and an FIE 12ga that weighs 5.5 pounds. It now has a thick recoil pad on it.

Looking at all the semi autos and pumps on the new gun rack they look huge compared to the sleek, thin single shots. Yep, I'm hooked.
 
Once upon a time, Gun Digest had an article describing the editor's use of single shot shotguns for an entire year. He said he gave up very little on game shots and gained a good deal in ease of carry and simple operation. His usual gun was a Stevens with the choke reduced and the stock cut to fit with a recoil pad.

He said he talked to a gunmaker about the possibility of a medium-high grade single; hammerless, light and handy, with a vent rib and maybe a little engraving. They concluded there might be a market for as many as 50 of them, all told. Not worth setting up for.
 
Apparently I'm one of the 50 who would like to see a shotgun like this made.

But with that say. I have 2 Stevens Model 220A in 20 gauge, and 1 Model 220 in 12 gauge. The 2 twenties will be for the grand kids if they show an interest, till then their grandpa's to play with. The Model 220 had it barrel cut down were the choke was cut out of it. So it's getting cut down to 20" inches, having a screwed in rifle choke and rifle sight put on it for deer hunting. Should be a lot easier as well as lighter to handle in the field.
 
Singles are shotguns for minimalists. Nothing can be removed from it and still have a working arm.

I like them lots. Come squirrel season I may have to take one for a walk through some hardwoods.
 
Kind of an extreme case, but one of our club members said a 34" BT99 would take a squirrel out of a tall, tall, tree. Well, it IS a single shot, isn't it?
 
Turning my CVA into a 20 ga single shot for many of the same reasons. Simple to load/unload, lighter than my mossy 500, less recoil than my mossy 500, etc.
 
My H&T Topper was made in 1947.
Too bad I broke it shooting 3 inch slugs out of it this summer :(
 
I friend of mine just got his 20G Topper back from his uncle who "took it for safe keeping" when he was 6(he is now 16). It really is a lot of fun to shoot!
 
Dave McCracken said
Singles are shotguns for minimalists. Nothing can be removed from it and still have a working arm.

Which brings to mind the dictum - "Get rid of anything that isn't useful, beautiful, or joyful".

A single-shot shotgun fulfills all three requirements.
 
I picked up an H&R Pardner youth model 20ga on Friday after work for $89. Took it out today. Haven't had that much fun in quite a while. This is going to be Mrs. Caution's 'bump in the night gun', loaded with No.3 buck. I think it will work out nicely.
 
Over the past few weeks since my OP, I had been hitting the range every Sunday with my 20G TDC for anywhere from 1-3 rounds of trap, each time, I was overthinking things, lifting my head as I pulled the trigger, stopping the swing as I pulled the trigger, little stuff, that when compounded together added up to a frustrating inability to break 16 hits

I *KNEW* it was my fault, it was clearly the "nut behind the trigger", yet I couldn't shake the possibility that the gun had something to do with it, choke too loose, throwing too tight of a pattern, heck, I even began to suspect the barrel wasn't straight....

Last Sunday, I decided to take my 12G TDC, set up the same way as the 20G, Mod choke, recoil absorber in the stock, barrel bead and rib laid out the same

The results were the same, 14 on the first round, 15 on the second, it clearly wasn't the gun

On the final game, something began to change, I began to get more consistent hits, and broke 17, what I did differently, was to keep my cheek welded to the stock (before, I was lifting my head as I pulled the trigger), I was moving the shotgun and my head as a single unit (before, I was following the target more with my head than the gun), but most importantly...

I had the brass bead almost obscured by the barrel rib (before, I had the entire bead sitting on *top* of the rib)

Today, I went back to the range, with the 20G again, I kept a good cheek weld, moved the gun and my head as a single entity, kept the gun moving as I shot, and kept the bead almost obscured by the rib (just the top curve of the bead was visible)....

And I shot 22! :D

the three I missed, I *KNEW* I was rushing the shot, and on each miss, had inadvertently reverted to one or more of my bad habits, rushing the shot, overthinking, chasing the bird, lifting my head as I shot...

Sadly, my supply of small green pieces of paper had run out, and only had enough for the one game, but I was quite happy with my results

I'll go back next week with more small green pieces of paper, and both the 12 and 20G TDCs and see how I perform with the 20G's bigger brother

My co-shooters really noticed the difference today as well, "Boy, MacTech, you really shot that 20G well", "looks like you shoot the 20G better than the 12G, i'd stay with the 20 if I were you"

I'm finally getting the hang of this trapshooting thing, and the TDC 20G is a big help, it's a great gun
 
I have several shotguns that include 2 singles in 12 ga, several doubles, and a pump (need an auto Iknow)....

Of them all, my favorite to grab and go walking with is BY FAR my Stevens 94 12 ga with a parkerized barrel... it weighs next to nothing, is quick to the shoulder and I shoot it well....The damn thing isnt worth 100 dollars on a good day, but it will never be sold.
 
I'm amazed by how quick to the shoulder the 22" barrel on the youth is. Mrs. Caution is away for the weekend, so I was launching my evil orange frisbees with my left hand while holding the H&R with the hammer back, muzzle down in the right. The furthest a target made it was about 15 meters.

This would make a fine gun for Vermont ruffed grouse. You rarely need to swing on them, as they just barrel away from you in a straight line, but are generally gone in thick foliage within 15 meters, if you ever see them at all.
 
There are many hunting situations where one quick clear shot is all you're going to get, and firing several extra rounds at a rapidly disappearing game animal just wastes ammo and risks wounding. You have to discipline yourself to make that first one count. In those cases, why carry around a more expensive heavier gun with the capability of multiple shots that you're very unlikely to ever need?

Upland hunting for grouse, rabbits, and squirrels in fairly thick cover is the ideal scenario for the single shot. The short length and light weight brings it quickly to shoulder and makes it a pleasure to carry on long hikes. It also has the advantage of instant visible evidence of being in "safe" mode when being broken open, which is especially important when hunting in groups or with beginners.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top