ouch my S&W 44 mag hurts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thor is said to have used gloves to harness the power of his hammer. I don't know why more research hasn't been put into grips. Companies should be working with fluid- or air-filled grips for more powerful guns, and wood should be relegated to less-powerful handguns and presentation pieces. The wood grips that came on the 29/629 just grated a user's hand to ribbons.
 
When I shoot a Model 29-629 I would just as soon have the wood grips on it. I don't have a problem with my hand, it's my middle finger that gets punched on the trigger guard my the S&W's so I always wrap something on my middle knuckle if I ever shoot one.

Get a Ruger Redhawk or SRH and it's a pleasure to shoot.
 
Come on people ....
My wife and 17 year old daughter shoot my 629 and love it.
Man-up!

Gonna play, "Can you top this?" :D

Teaching.jpg

My 7 year old daughter shooting my 4" 629. Didn't want to stop! (Of course, that's with .44 Specials. But still...)

Check out Mr. Jerry's videos above, learn proper grip and technique, and enjoy your .44s!

-Sam
 
"Can you top this?"

No, I can't.

My daughter was shooting a .22 at that age. And while I gave her a Model 19 for her 15th Birthday she is still not a big bore fan.

My hat is off to you. Good job Dad!
 
My hat is off to you. Good job Dad!

She's odd, in many ways (LOL!), but she's a miniature recoil junkie. She's always preferred guns that go "boom" to those that go "pop." Funny, her little brother is perfectly happy with .22s. She likes .45s and .44s.

But I think the picture is instructive. How does a 60 lb. girl handle the size and recoil of a .44 revolver? Check out her grip and stance. Textbook form for solid control of a handgun. No "tea-cupping" at my house! :D

-Sam
 
She's odd, in many ways

I understand that statement as my daughter is "odd" too. Guns and knives do not bother her, she loves bones (my back deck looks like someone is putting together a kit for a Smithsonian-like dinosaur display) and she kneed a guy that was being inappropriate. (she told the principal what happened and he told her "good job")

I have coached girls basketball and teach RADS, a women's self defense program. I find that the "odd" ones have the brightest futures.

Once again, good job Dad.
 
Sounds odd. I'm 5' 8", 175lbs, no muscle monster but not super thin. I shoot full loads in my 629 6" with no problem. Just a really big push, but nothing painful. I have the original S&W grips. If you reload, you can drop 240 gr bullets into 22gr of H110 and shouldn't have near the recoil of full power factory ammo.
 
I found that by using duct tape to wrap the wood grips, that I could really tame my nickel 29. The cheese grater portion were added to the grips so they would be more grippable in rain and snow. After using smooth wood grips, however, I think rain most likely would have little effect on a Model 29 being fired with such grips. The checkered patterns are great for shredding one's palms, on the other hand.
 
Glad I came upon this post. I had a M29 classic with 5" barrel with stock Hogue grips. Could only stand to shoot 12 rounds of 210/240 gr full power loads. Moved to a S&W 657 41mag cut down to 5", so much more comfortable to shoot, Could not learn to master the double action trigger for self defense. Use a 1911 in 10mm for outdoor stuff today.

If you can shoot a revolver double action, then the S&W N frame is one heck of a versatile, powerful and portable platform. Hot .44 special level loads and shooting gloves may be needed for extended sessions.

This would have been my ultimate outdoor pistol back in the day. Was looking seriously at it for a bit until this post jogged my memory ;)

The DX is an accurized version and a 5" is rare. Not affiliated with seller in anyway, may be interesting to some. Happy New Year!

http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.aspx?Item=150929496
 
I've often wondered why you can reload to the listed max with various powders in the 44 Mag and still not have near the recoil of factory ammo?

No other caliber I've reloaded is that way.
 
I got rid of my 44mag revolvers, and most of my 357mag ones too. I've shot a lot over the past four decades and can handle the recoil of the 44, 454, and 500, but I started to ask myself why. If I needed the extra range the magnum velocities offer, I might get another 44, or more likely a 41mag. I'll take a 45colt over a 44mag any day. And by 45colt I mean 45colt, not 45colt magnum as people seem to want to make it.

I know there are situations/tasks that merit a magnum, but the magnum trend seems similar to the huge pickup truck trend. When I was a kid you could reach over a the side wall of a pickup bed and grab your gear. Now, you need a step ladder 'cause the trucks are so darn big. For what? I don't get it. People must be fording deep rivers and hauling two tons of iron ore on their way to the mall. I'm glad people have the options available to them these days, whether it's big guns or big trucks, but neither the truck or the gun make the man. When I got rid of the magnums and picked up the lower pressure rounds like the 45colt, 44special, and 45acp my hearing improved, my carpal tunnel went away, and my accuracy improved. Each to his own, but I don't enjoy magnum recoil unless there is a very good reason for using a magnum.
 
i love The 44 mag.... if you have a problem with it... its simple... just switch to something else.

the 44 mg is like everything else in life... not everybody likes it... for those of us who like it... nothing can take its place.. for those of us that hate it... there is nothing worse.. except for a 500 or a 460??????!!!!!

the 44 mag is not for everybody... but those of us who like it .. and the 460 and the 500... there is no other choice.
as they get bigger... i want one! I don't feel like i have to justify it... you know... have a reason to buy it.. (if i had to hve a reason i wouldn't have any guns)
i want it... simply because i like it and want it!
 
Last edited:
It's your nervous system needing to get acclimatized to the blast and recoil. If you don't shoot for a couple of years and you're used to the blast you will still have to get used to it again a year or more later. Your size has nothing to do with it. I've seen kids shoot full power .44 magnums and laugh. Most of my .44 shooting is with a moderate load. Full power loads are too much to be able to shoot for any period of time even when you are accustomed to it.
 
I have a bunch of .44's and .357's and have never once complained about recoil. Now, I have never shot a mag round out of the .44. I load my own so I'm particular about what I load. I have no need of the .44 mags power in anything I do. So the .44 mag gets a load of 15.0 gr of 2400 for about 1000 fps and my .44 Spls get 7.5 gr of Unique for about 900 fps with a 250 gr bullet. Both of these do everything I need.

The .357 mag is another I tend to load down. I can shoot full house loads without it bothering me but once again I don't need that much power.
 
rhartwell: there is a lot of good info on this thread. In my own case I was very experienced with full power .357 loads. Then I started with a heavy gun, a Ruger Redhawk, and heavy is good. Also, the grips were Pachmayer presentations, a full coverage rubber style. Next, I shot a lot of .44 specials until I was really comfortable with the gun. My first magnum ammo was loaded by Remington (iirc) and was called the 'midrange' load. It was a 240 grain bullet loaded to about 1100 fps. That load was very tolerable. Finally I began shooting standard load 240 grain .44 magnums. By that point I was ready, and I was able to shoot them with no problem. (At the risk of irritating the Smith fans, the 29, 629 guns are the hardest kickers in that caliber simply because they are the lightest weight.) I rate the Colt Anaconda as somewhere between the Smith and the Ruger. I almost forgot, someone mentioned a Ruger rolling up in the hand, that would be the single action super blackhawk or blackhawk .44's. Because of the more rounded grip they tend to dissipate some of the recoil in more muzzle rise.

You may find that the most important part of the whole process is conditioning your nervous system not to overreact to the jump and the muzzle blast the attends the firing event. Do be sure to use high quality eye and especially hearing protection.

As several of the guys have mentioned if you take it slow and work your way through carefully you will no doubt find that it can be a very rewarding experience to shoot the mighty .44 mag. Good luck.
 
If you have the right gun, the 44 mag is not bad at all.
Ruger Super Blackhawk Hunter, Bisley.
The gun has the weight and the Bisley grips work well in controling recoil.
If you want shooting gloves, checkout Uncle Mike's.

44-one.jpg
 
The Hogue X-frame monogrip is my choice for recoil control in my 629s. I don't normally use them, however, as I prefer the various wood grips I own - and my milder reloads. Just because it's a .44 Magnum case doesn't mean what's loaded has to be a wrist snapper. My loads are primarily plinkers - and .44 Special level, just in .44 Magnum cases. If you don't reload, consider the .44 Magnum 'Cowboy loads' Georgia Arms, and others, commercially load. They are also generally cheaper, as well as at .44 Special-ish levels.

Stainz
 
...Why not save your hands and wrists and wimp out like me...I have NEVER fired a .44Mag round in a handgun...only .44 Special...one of the most inherantly accurate rounds ever...plenty of punch for defense...probably good for deer and smaller up to 75 yards...let the exspurts tell you about that...much more fun to shoot and reload...
 
Another option is a .41 Mag. Remington makes low recoil ammo for it as well as the .44 Mag. It is considerably more comfortable while still having a pretty good thump to it.
 
...I HAVE fired those...the lead load's like a hot .44 Spl (in a M58 4") ... manageable...and the soft point (1500fps) wasn't any fun at all...I stayed with the lead...I think both the .41Mag and .44Mag are reloaders' calibers if a lot of shooting is to be done....ammo is high...
 
Gosh, I don't understand you guys that say .44 mag is unbearable! You must be doing something wrong.

I have a 4" 629-1 with square wood grips and a Ruger SuperRedhawk with the factory grips. I don't notice a problem. I've even shot near max 300 gr SWC in the SRH (one shot stop for a 7 pt buck). I didn't notice much recoil when I was testing the load, and of course none when the buck was in the sights.

I actually notice more recoil from my wife's .38 special LadySmith, but she likes the pretty wood grips.

Ken
 
To be honest I think it might be a matter of perspective. I know when I start firing the smaller calibers at the range and work up to the 44 mag the recoil seems much more fierce than if I start firing the 44 mag first. The Smith is a bit lighter than my SBH, so my view maybe slightly skewed in comparison. Try the WWB rounds first off on your next trip before you spend money on new grips. Good luck!

-MW
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top