Polymer and composites were initially used in WWII for a variety of things, including bomber parts. The items that first got notice were nylons. They got noticed a lot.
First polymer rifle was the Nylon 66 in 1962. The AR15 and M16 were introduced in the late 60's and there are no complaints about the composite furniture on them. First handgun was the HK VP70, 1970. The Glock was introduced in 1983. The US Army is now issuing the SIG M17 composite handgun today.
We've had plastic guns about 35 years before plastic intake manifolds. Mark Holtzberg was offering composite pistons with aluminum crowns for Mini's in the early 70's. Plastic parts on engines are now commonplace, altho some owners and mechanics can point to certain items on specific models as a continuing hassle.
Different plastics, polymers, and composites, different strengths and heat tolerances, same as metals. Don't forget that at one time all stainless pistols using the same alloy on the frame and slide had galling issues. Material selection goes far beyond simple concepts.