The 25/06
is sorta wasteful of powder but I don't know how many people would think that so important - maybe a few, maybe a lot.
I'm more inclined to think it's reputation has been hurt by the bullets
commonly recommended for it.... another victim of Gunzine Lore.
Always when the scribes address the .25/06 they rush like lemmings to the 117-gr. and (later) the 120gr. Perhaps they do that to emphasize that the .25/06 offers a lot more than the .250 Savage or the .257 Roberts (or the .243/6mms) and also that maybe it can crowd into coveted .257 Weatherby territory.
Predictably - many new owners of the .25/06 probably shunned the excellent 87-gr. and 100-gr. bullets and decided they would use the 117/120 pills for deer - after all - more is always better - right ? I'd be willing to bet the .25 caliber 87-grainers are miserably slow-movers in the bullet/ammo world.
But maybe that approach fixed something that wasn't broken. Even the .250 Savage can toss the 87-grainer at 3000fps - that's how it got the "3000" in its' name - and it was a major favorite because doing so proved very lethal to deer. The .257 Roberts will do a smidgeon or two better and it, too, has a well-deserved reputation for great results in the deer parlors.
Of course no gun scribbler could ever wax praiseful of the use of the 87-grainer in the .25/06 because hunters would have just (rightfully) asked "
WHY" - the .250 Savage and the Quarter-Bob aren't broken - who needs more thunder ?" And today with the eloquent .243 available to everyone - trying to justify the .25/06 with just deer hunting is a lost cause for sure.
So the .25/06 (and its' heavier-weight bullets) must be heralded as a "bigger-than-deer" caliber. Unfortunately - as others have pointed out - the .25/06 has to do all its' upward stretching in the shadows of the 7mm/08, the .270, the .260, the Swede and the 7x57 - and that puts it in a one-caliber race for 6th place.
Also as others have mentioned - for all the silly, mindless yapping about the "
one caliber that does it all" - almost no one really wants that. So even though the .25/06 really is a viable "varmints-to-elk" caliber - that simply isn't what most hunters/shooters want.
As good as it is - or can be - it may be the .25/06 will always be a step-child - one of those cartridges that has sort of a "cult" following but never reaches the Kentucky Derby.