I don't think a 500FP load is going to be a lighter range load! You have the 40SW confused for something else, maybe!
1200fps is pretty darn hot. Mind your OAL and work up carefully. Small changes can make big differences, here.
I worked up to 7.6 gr AutoComp behind a Berry's 155gr FP, and it works pretty good for me. That's a couple tenths off max, and probably pretty close to your target level of energy. I've shot over 500 of these through my G27 with decent accuracy, but recoil is stout.
When I subbed Rainer's 155gr FP, I didn't work up again. I seated to the same OAL. I figured I was a bit under max, anyway. Well, the slightly longer bullet made the ammo nearly unshootable in my G27. Recoil was so great, it broke my shooting grip on every shot. I couldn't keep the shots on a paper plate at 15 yards, and I unintentionally locked the slide back once or twice per mag.
For a really light target load, I've found 5.15gr HP38 behind a Berry's 155gr FP feels like a 9mm. But then again, it's sort of like paying 25% more for bullets just to shoot a 9mm.