John Forsyth,
Why do I bash the 1911, because I wanted to stay alive! Novel concept in shooting today.
Number one requirenment in any combat weapon, reliability.
Don't matter what caliber, how big, how fast, how deadly if it don't go bang!
1911's go bang less than any well known combat pistol that I know of. That simple, personal experienc. I don't need to here about the others, I don't trust many of them either. I have chosen SIG's, and my research and personal experience has shown me that only the double Stack SIG's, are worthy of the record of reliablility. If you talk to a GunSmith that really knows SIGS he will tell you about the Trigger bar spring in the 220 and 225. I know I still own both. In the 225 the Cult SIG there is even a problem with the Magazines, not to the extent with the 1911 but enough that I won't carry it for serious social purposes.
The exception to the above may be the 239, they use a new design on the spring and I agree it should solve the problem, in fact I have modified my 220's&225 to the newly designed spring.
But if you want proven reliability choose 226/228/229 and go bang every time.
My old Gunney had a lot of sayings about small arms, heres a couple:
All weapons break, some just break sooner and more often than others.
'Handguns' are great weapons, until you need a weapon.
This guy thought the 7.62 was a wimp load, if it wasn't 30-06 he didn't think it could haul the load. Didn't really know alot about guns out side of issue weapons, but he knew combat, I believe Siapan and Iwo Jima. and a few others. I listened and I learned. Some talked about theory, some talked about staying alive!
Take your choice! Remember, in the Military if your using your pistol, you are up to your ass in gators! And if you Sh*t fails, you ain't going home to tell war stories and drink beer. So all those stories you heard were only from the guys who won. think about it!
The good news is most guys don't have to resort to the pistol, because never forget what the Gunney said about pistols.
Either way, you asked why some people knock the 1911, I can't answer for them, just for me.
Let me ask you the other side of the coin, why do you put a religious belief in an out dated design that everyone needs custom work to keep it going?
take your choices, for your reasons.
If you should ever need your 1911, I hope and pray, yours shows up.
Fred