Question: what's the best payment method for online private gun sales?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I use ShipMyGun.com for the shipping labels. I have to ship a gun out to my buyer this coming Tuesday at 3 PM. I can't use the normal UPS Store for firearms. Here in Lawton, Ok, I have to use the UPS Hub and that stupid thing is only open 3-7 PM, M-F excluding certain holidays like Presidents Day. If only the UPS Store would accept guns, I could have shipped the man his gun this morning. $49.01 to ship a silly little handgun (about 4 pounds package weight) from SW Oklahoma to Hamburg, New York. The buyer paid for this of course. When I have shipped long guns, they only charged about $25.00. I think UPS and FedEx use the pricey overnight or two-day service for handguns and the long (cheaper) ground rates for long guns. A non-FFL cannot ship handguns from the post office.
What carrier does shipmygun use????
 
You can verify a cashiers check yourself if you want to ship ASAP.

If you can’t visit in person to trace a cashier’s check, independently confirm the phone number of the bank as listed on the check, then call the bank and ask to verify the check. All banks require these pieces of information to verify a cashier’s check:

  • Check number
  • Name of the person who gave you the check
  • Payment amount
Your bank will likely put a pending status on your deposit anyway until they verify.

I want a cashiers check so I can verify before I ship a firearm. It's always safer to sell than to buy. That's why I only buy from dealers if I can't do a FTF. It may cost a bit more but I've never been scammed using a dealer.
 
Last edited:
One issue that concerns me is depositing $ instead of cashing. My bank has now started to list deposits as "INCOME" . Not good.
 
What carrier does shipmygun use????

So, far they have only issued me pre-paid shipping labels for UPS. It depends what kind of gun you are shipping (long gun, handgun), your FFL license status and the city you are in. I believe they try to find the best rates. As a non-FFL, I can't ship a handgun from the post office.
 
USPS money orders are faked quite often. They buy a real money order, wash the amount and print over a larger amount.

Anything can be counterfeited. Thats why a seller should only accept payment in an easily verifiable form of payment. No matter whether its a money order or bank check you should verify the validity before depositing in your account.

Bank checks (also called cashiers checks) are drawn against the banks account.
Certified checks are drawn on the buyers personal account and the bank will put a hold on the amount of the check because they guarantee those funds will be there.
Money orders (no matter who sold them, are guaranteed funds) There is no legal difference between a USPS vs MoneyGram vs WalMart vs 7-11 money order. Ease of cashing depends on which one you bought.
Personal checks are drawn against the buyers personal account and nothing prevents him from depleting that account the day after you deposit his check.

I would not say there is no difference, Postal Money Orders have specific statutes about counterfeiting them, etc. The post office is not the same as a run of the mill private entity.
 
I’ve used PayPal direct friend/family to friend/family to email accounts.
To the OP. How would PayPal retrieve monies once transfer was complete and the monies deposited in your bank account. ? They were private sales however.
Personally IMO if they some how knew it was a gun transaction, beyond cancelling your account, what could they do. Mind you I have no monies deposited and beyond a few favorite Patron accounts I pay monthly nothing much else.
 
I’ve used PayPal direct friend/family to friend/family to email accounts.
To the OP. How would PayPal retrieve monies once transfer was complete and the monies deposited in your bank account. ? They were private sales however.
Personally IMO if they some how knew it was a gun transaction, beyond cancelling your account, what could they do. Mind you I have no monies deposited and beyond a few favorite Patron accounts I pay monthly nothing much else.
If there is no money in your account..all they do is block you from using PP for a long time..8f not forever.

If there is money in your account...they put you through HELL to get it...takes MONTHS, phone calls, emails, threats...and I've heard even then, they find ways of not giving it all back to you...fees and Bullcrap like that.

I know folks personally this has happened to...this even after I told them about how Anti gun PP is...but some learn the hard way.

I never use PP...ever. Their Anti gun/anti 2nd is enough for me to take my business elsewhere.
 
I would not say there is no difference, Postal Money Orders have specific statutes about counterfeiting them, etc.
And checks, no matter whether bank check or personal check have also specific statutes about counterfeiting, fraud, etc.
Again, mail fraud is mail fraud, doesn't matter one bit whether you mailed a personal check, bank check, money order or bubble gum wrappers. As a seller, having an easily verifiable means of determining the validity is important.


The post office is not the same as a run of the mill private entity.
Which has nothing to do with anything. Comparing the customer service of a run of the mill branch bank vs the post office?:rofl: Give me the convenience of walking into a nice smelling bank vs a post office with a line to the door, government employees and a notoriously poor attitude.

Ever try and get a refund on a USPS money order? I have twice. Never again.

*******And its not been mentioned, but if the seller says he's going to send a check/money order in a larger amount than the sale, and asks that you return the difference? He's a scammer.
 
I’ve used PayPal direct friend/family to friend/family to email accounts.
To the OP. How would PayPal retrieve monies once transfer was complete and the monies deposited in your bank account. ? They were private sales however.
Personally IMO if they some how knew it was a gun transaction, beyond cancelling your account, what could they do. Mind you I have no monies deposited and beyond a few favorite Patron accounts I pay monthly nothing much else.
I know several gun dealers who have had their PayPal accounts frozen with several thousand dollars involved. When you sign up for PayPal, Venmo, Square, etc you voluntarily agree to abide by their policies and their means of arbitration. If you violate their terms they can and do keep your $$$$ and you have no recourse.
 
You can cash a USPS money order at the post office. No need to deposit it at your bank and wait for it to clear.
 
Both Venmo and PayPal don't allow firearms transactions. Personal checks are not very secure and they can bounce and you can get hit by your bank for a returned check fee. Debit and credit cards are for dealers, merchants. This leaves money orders. Is there a PayPal-like online payment service that is trustworthy and gun-friendly both? I just received a USPS money order from a gunbroker buyer yesterday. I deposited it at my bank today and it is being held for a couple of days before the total amount of the money order becomes available to me. I read about GunBrokerPay but I don't trust it. It asks for your username and password to your online banking to link a checking account with it. No, I don't want anything to do with it. GunBrokerPay is only good for GunBroker.com anyway.

Money orders are time-consuming and some buyers complain about having to pay with them. People complain about having to wait in line at the post office to buy one. I had to wait 20 minutes in line this afternoon to deposit my buyer's money order because the ATM won't accept money orders for deposit. The bank teller told me that these money orders are printed in such a way that ATM's can't read the dollar amount of them like an ordinary check. I can't deposit MoneyGram money orders at my ATM also. The money order industry doesn't make their paper products ATM-readable. My bank put my money order on hold. I was told the funds might be available in full tomorrow or Tuesday because Monday is a holiday. I have to explain these hang-ups to my gun buyers via email. I won't dare ship a gun out until I have secured the buyer's money in full.

There must be a smart, fast, convenient and secure way to do online gun transactions.
Don’t.....face to face. That is how I have operated for lo these many years....and it works.
 
I use ShipMyGun.com for the shipping labels. I have to ship a gun out to my buyer this coming Tuesday at 3 PM. I can't use the normal UPS Store for firearms. Here in Lawton, Ok, I have to use the UPS Hub and that stupid thing is only open 3-7 PM, M-F excluding certain holidays like Presidents Day. If only the UPS Store would accept guns, I could have shipped the man his gun this morning. $49.01 to ship a silly little handgun (about 4 pounds package weight) from SW Oklahoma to Hamburg, New York. The buyer paid for this of course. When I have shipped long guns, they only charged about $25.00. I think UPS and FedEx use the pricey overnight or two-day service for handguns and the long (cheaper) ground rates for long guns. A non-FFL cannot ship handguns from the post office.

UPS and Fed Ex do offer to pick up items from you.

Sign up for an account.........
 
I log onto my banking app and transfer the money directly from my account to the account of the seller.
If it is a large amount I would prefer to pay cash face to face.
I have paid via cheque in the past. It is a long process, I will tell the seller to wait until the funds have cleared before shipping the item.
I've even paid private sellers in the US with a UK cheque for accessories.
 
UPS and Fed Ex do offer to pick up items from you.

Sign up for an account.........

I don't ship enough guns, or anything else, to worry about that. They probably surcharge for that and there is no telling that I will even be home, not in the shower, not on the pot or not taking a nap when they come to the door. I doubt if that service is for picking up guns. If one runs a gun shop or FFL transfer business, that's different. Most of the things I ship are returns to online vendors. Most of the time they provide a prepaid shipping label for whatever carrier they chose.
 
The problem with a USPS mo is most of the times the PO does not have enough money to cash it!

They might have to special order cash to cash it depending on the amount. You also have to stand in line. I had to stand in line at Navy FCU in Lawton, OK because their particular medieval ATM won't take money orders for deposit. Fort Sill CU in town is so medieval their ATM's won't even take ordinary checks for deposit. I switched to Navy because their ATM's take checks and cash and they don't ding you with as many surcharges as online transferring money out to another bank. Their face-to-face service inside, sucks, however. I only have to see them face-to-face to get a roll of quarters, deposit a money or or get something notarized. One time I brought in $1,100 in 20's to deposit. I wanted to count each and every bill out in front of the teller but the uppity _____ woman wanted to take the whole pile of loot and have her "machine" count it out. This was during COVID mask wearing at its peak two years ago and the uppity _____'s working inside were all anal about things. I do business the old-fashioned way when it comes to handling cash. I like each bill counted out one by one. I'm not sure I trust an ATM for cash deposits to count the bills correctly either UNLESS the machine gives me credit for bills that don't exist, IOW miscounts in MY favor.

Credit unions are often cheaper than banks to avoid fees but the customer service is a bit on the downside. Some people working at credit unions can be downright rude and arrogant to "members", not "customers". Mountain America CU in Boise, ID when I lived there was awesome, however. Always service with a sunny smile even to get something notarized. They were the gold standard for banking.

Lawton, Ok is a military town, Fort Sill. It's a real hillbilly town for 100K population if you ask me. Three Walmarts, one (pricey but very clean inside) Target and not a single bona fide chain supermarket save for the Commissary on post. I'm a Vet and have Commissary privileges.
 
Last edited:
The good thing about going to the PO to cash a MO is if it is a fake the PO can't deduct it from your account.
Some banks are real customer orientated, both banks I had in NJ,and WV had a counting machine for change.
One time I had 168 pounds of change (N,D,Q no pennies) $2,400.00, the second in WV (the jug wasn't full) $1,300.00.
 
...
There must be a smart, fast, convenient and secure way to do online gun transactions.
Of course there is. Credit cards. Either don't do business with sellers that don't take a card or resign yourself to the surcharge. Other than that your personal credit is smart, fast, convenient, secure and protects you from seller default. I don't know why such a big deal needs to be made of it.
 
Why i don't and never will take personal checks. They are an archaic form of payment and i see many businesses that will not accept them anymore. Two major supermarkets here are scanning check writers drivers licenses and have special lines for cash or credit only. My bank charges a fee per check to print them and soon to use them. The time to write a check usually results in grumbling/comments by those in line at the checkout counter too.
 
Of course there is. Credit cards. Either don't do business with sellers that don't take a card or resign yourself to the surcharge. Other than that your personal credit is smart, fast, convenient, secure and protects you from seller default. I don't know why such a big deal needs to be made of it.
Agreed. Credit card is the way to go. I'll pay the 3.5% or whatever and chalk it up to the cost of doing business.
 
Agreed. Credit card is the way to go. I'll pay the 3.5% or whatever and chalk it up to the cost of doing business.

If a seller takes CC's the 3.5 to 6% is usually already added to the items price. Usually the 6%. Why sellers profit from use of other forms of payment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top