RAT 5 ESEE Review

Status
Not open for further replies.

mp510

Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2006
Messages
3,045
Location
PRKt
I have like Jeff’s designs since the first time I saw them in the BQM catalog, through products made by Ontario. Getting an Ontario RAT-3 shortly before RAT cutlery came to exist, I ultimately ended up pre-ordering an OD Izula from Chestnut Ridge. Waiting for even the opportunity to place a pre-order was, shall I say daunting. Until receiving the ESEE to evaluate, that had been my only experience with RAT Cutlery.

When I opened the box bearing the ESEE, I was very impressed. A thick bladed, heavy, almost brutish knife, the grip fit my hand pretty much perfectly. In the hand, it balanced very well.

I did not take the opportunity to try the glass breaking tip or the bow-drill divot. I can’t comment about those.

The included sheath was very nice. With both retention points snapped, the knife was secured perfectly. I will say that engaging both is difficult, especially when you are wearing the knife. The accessory pocket was perfectly sized for my SOG powerlock multi-tool. I thought the lengthy adjustment strap was unnecessary, because realistically- there is only so large an item that could fit in that pocket….I was very glad for the thigh strap. Without it, I really felt the weight of the knife on my belt. When using it, the weight felt distributed into my thigh muscles, and (though I knew it was there) felt much less burdensome. The Velcro belt loop was also a really nice idea- it made taking the sheath on and off a cinch.

Though I probably would not go out of my way to order a knife like this with serrations, I do like my folders partially serrated (and my RAT 3 is partially serrated). I would almost have liked it more if the serrations were a little more aggressive. The spine of the blade measured in at a little over a quarter inch thick. I knew RAT Cutlery products came with a great edge, but having such a thick blade slice so well was like a surprise. It even carved fuzz sticks just fine. I was shocked at just how thin I was able to get those layers.
For that fine carving, I found it helpful to give the front of the blade a little bit of support from my opposite (weak side) thumb.
11wa90y.jpg
16ia8gm.jpg

I aslo have to say that I was impressed by the blade coating. It was very smoothe and did not wear the same way as coatings used by the lesser knife makers.

I don’t try to do hard prying with knives…especially knives that I don‘t own. However, I know that RAT cutlery products are up to the task- and if by some freak of nature I did break it, Jeff would surely be willing to keep the pass around going ;) I figured that for cutting bait, I would naturally need a cutting board. So, I hacked/ pried this nice chunk of a dead tree.
17z39z.jpg

I didn’t really chop too much wood with ESEE, though it proved its value in what little I did. It did make a clean cut when I chopped off a damaged fishing rod end.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIKdfHwkRaI

Group Picture- Benchmade Pika, Sog Powerlock, Case Mini-Trapper, RAT ESEE.
1fe1oh.jpg


Overall, I thought the ESEE is a knife that I enjoyed using a lot and would be proud to own. In the bigger picture, it is nice piece of American quality in workmanship.
 
I'll add that the RC-5 draws a good spark from a ferro-steel fire starter - from the jimping for the thumb. Mine came a month or so back - $135 inc s/h. The Eagle Industries sheath is limiting their supply for now, as RAT dropped them when they went 'off shore'. RAT will have future deliveries with kydex - but US made, like the original Eagle Industries sheaths were. I like leather - and look forward to perhaps a Sharpshooter sheath, like Bark River uses. Actually, the OEM sheath assembly has grown on me a bit. Sadly, it's belt attachment 'loops' have velcro on both sides - makes it scratchy/sticky on a leather belt - probably hold fast on a woven belt (MOLLE).

IMG_3519.jpg

To show it in scale with a KaBar, Gerber LMFII, and Buck Nighthawk

IMG_3518.jpg

If you want an RC-5 with that sheath, you'd best hurry - and be prepared for both few in selection and some 'creative pricing'. They are, as my Busse owner friend said, 'a poor man's Busse'. Mine has a home.

Stainz

PS Everyone knows the RAT RC-5 is no Busse... when did you ever see a Busse with an included sheath??
 
Stainz said:
PS Everyone knows the RAT RC-5 is no Busse... when did you ever see a Busse with an included sheath??
My Badger Attack III came with the Busse factory supplied nylon sheath.

BAIIIb.gif

My early model straight handled Mean Street came from Busse with an Eagle nylon sheath.

SHMS.gif

Of course since then Busse has stopped supplying sheaths. I agree with their practice of doing so. If you're going to spend the money to get a Busse You're enough of a knife fanatic or at least a serious enough user that you have a specific sheath in mind that you'd like for your knife, it mkaes no sense to send someone a sheath they're just going to discard right away anyway. I really like all of the different style of sheaths that Busse has linked to on their website and I've owned many of them including Armorall Leather, Chuddy Bear, Okuden, Mashed Cat, and Buy Brown. I haven't had an On-Scene Tactical yet, but I'd like to for one of my future purchases. I'm generally a fan of Kydex, Okuden, Mashed Cat, and a local Anchorage store called Northern Knives.

As for RAT Cutlery, I love my RC-4, and I'm really impressed with RAT Cutlery as a company. The only complaint I have is that I'm not overly impressed with the kydex that came with it. I'm going to have the above listed Northern Knives make me one of their kydex sheaths for it next time I'm in Anchorage. I have to say, though, the knives are great. Describing them as a poor man's Busse is correct, but it's almost a disservice to RAT. True, the 1095 isn't quite the steel that Busse's INFI is, but it's quite impressive nonetheless. They manage to do a great job at heat treating, which is as important as any step in making a top quality knife. I carry my RC-4 with pride.
 
Last edited:
Knivesshipfree.com has a Sharpshooter leather sheath for their version of the RC-4. You might try their site for the availability - or at least the picture - of the leather sheath. As far as Busse sheaths, I'll wager many Busse's are part and parcel of collections - and no sheaths are required. I have a few knives in my collection that I wish I had saved the sheath money on - they certainly were not to my liking and/or I really just look at the knives. One day... I'll have a sale!

Stainz
 
What a knife!

I just want to say that IMO the exact same Rat 5 ESEE that the OP posted about is an especially desirable knife. That knife was shipped and shared among 14 people who put it through their paces for the purpose of reviewing it for the Blade Forum. The OP was the last person to have it and I got to play with it and still do.
What a knife! It's super comfortable and still as sharp if not sharper than many brand new knives. It's heavy because it's thick and solid, but when you hold it, it welds to your hand and you don't want to put it down.
I'm very impressed with it to say the least.
As a survival knife, I can't really see what else a person would need.
It's a superior knife with an edge that cuts like a dream and keeps on cutting.
And after being reviewed by 14 people, it's amazing that it's still in 99.9% condition.
It's a knife like this that makes a layperson realize that there's only so much that can be expected from any knife. And I just can't say that this knife lacks anything. The sheath could be a little better, but the ergonomics and functionality of the knife itself is first rate.
The glass breaker pommel is serious too. With the weight of the knife and the comfort of the handle, some serious force can be exerted with that pommel without needing to be a muscle man. Just let the knife do its work for you.
Same with the blade, it cuts through tough stuff as if it was butter! :)
 
Last edited:
To give you a better idea of how hefty this knife is, it weighs just over 1 lb. yet its edge is only 5.25 inches.
 

Attachments

  • P1090020a45%.JPG
    P1090020a45%.JPG
    92 KB · Views: 47
  • P1090018a69%.JPG
    P1090018a69%.JPG
    96.9 KB · Views: 25
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top