Recoil Operated Shotguns - Tips & Info

Status
Not open for further replies.

mnrivrat

Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
5,373
Location
MN
Over the years of doing firearm repair one see's patterns of failures caused by the same thing occuring over and over.

Such is the case with recoil operated shotguns . So a little background and a couple tips for those who use, but are not all that familiar with, recoil operated shotguns.
Examples of this type of automatic operating system are guns like the Browning Auto 5 , Remington Model 11 , Remington Model 11-48 , Savage 720 .

Every year a number of these guns come in for repair because they failed to eject the empty . It would either remain in the chamber or only be partialy ejected and hanging in the action or the ejection port. Here are some tips to not only prevent this malfunction, but to save wear and tear on your gun , and your shoulder.

You first should understand the mechanics of the recoil operated gun. In order to operate the shooting cycle the gun has a floating barrel that moves rearward during the shooting cycle. When the shell goes off the bolt is locked to the barrel and the pressure of the exploding gases drives both the barrel and the bolt to the rear (recoil) . As the bolt travels farther to the rear it unlocks from the barrel. This sends the barrel back into its home position (under the tension of the recoil spring) as the bolt completes its rearward travel which will eject the empty through the ejection port , and allow a fresh round to be fed upward into the chamber on its return forward stroke powered by the action spring.

Now to the control of this function : In order for this cycle to be smooth, and in control, the mechanism employs a friction control eliment. It does this via a bronze friction piece and friction ring working to act as a brake . This system sits on the front part of the magazine tube, forward of the large recoil spring (under the forearm) . It is acted on by the barrel lug as the barrel travels to the rear during the shooting cycle. Different guns use slightly different set-ups but all recoil operated guns use this friction method of controling the shooting cycle.

Keeping this in mind , if the friction system causes too much braking it will slow the cycle and cause malfuncions by not allowing the barrel & or bolt assy to travel rearward at sufficant speed or force , or length of travel to eject the empty shell and complete the shooting cycle.

The fix for this is typically to clean the inner surface of the bronze friction ring as well as the surface it rides on for braking - which is the outside of the magazine tube. Then apply a couple drops of oil to the magazine tube - spread it over the tube with your hand or rag for a very thin.small amount of lubrication . This will generaly get the gun back into action.

Now more information : Knowing how this system works you must pay attention to not only malfunctions due to excess braking in the friction system, but must also make sure there is enough friction to keep the action from hammering/slamming . Simply put , if there is no braking or not enough braking, you will pound your gun to pre-mature death and your shoulder as well.

To assure proper braking you first must pay attention to the load you are shooting. It is obvious that a heavy field load will apply more pressure to the system than say a dove and quail load. And then of course there are the magnum loads. Guns like the A-5 Browning have been made in 3 inch magnum versions. If you read through your manuel and view your magnum guns, you will notice that the magnum guns have included a second bronze friction piece and friction rings. The second friction piece is there to aid in braking when using magnum loads. You should make sure you understand the proper placement of the friction rings and make sure the concave portion of the friction ring is facing the bronze friction piece. Driving the bronze piece into the tapper of the concave friction ring sqeezes the bronze piece tighter onto the magazine tube causing friction. Instructions for the magnum guns friction system is also generaly posted inside the forearm on a paper label.

The Remington Model 11 was not made to shoot magnum loads . Light loads were meant to be fired with the friction ring stored next to the reciever to the rear of the recoil spring with the concave part of the ring facing rearward. If heavy loads are to be used, then the friction ring is moved to the forward side of the recoil spring between the spring and the bronze friction piece with the concave surface facing the bronze friction ring.. If your buying a Model 11 you should look carefully for damage caused by using magnum loads in the gun. It starts with the distruction of the 1/8 inch thick fiber buffer that is located on the inside rear of the reciver. This is a buffer for the rear of the bolt. When distroyed the bolt will then make contact with the rear of the receiver - metal to metal - and then finish by cracking the bolt typically on the rear left side. ( a crack that can't be seen unless you disassemble the gun) If the fiber buffer is still intact, the bet is that the bolt is OK, if not - proceed with caution on a purchase.

This same problem can be seen on Browning, but they use a different buffer system and are more durable. I have seen them with cracked bolts however, so keep that in mind. A gun that slaps or slams when fired needs to be addressed. Worn friction pieces can cause problems and they should be changed before they wear out. This bronze ring should have a clear and visable split in the ring when in position. If not, there is no clearance for the bronze ring to sqeeze down onto the magazine tube creating needed braking.

Bottom Line : Control the friction, and you control the function. You can control the friction by making sure the bronze friction piece is not worn out , making sure the system is cleaned and very lightly lubed ( too much lube - not enough braking ) ( too little lube - too much braking )
Balance the system to the load you are using and the gun will shoot reliably and with less recoil .
 
Last edited:
How does the operation of the Benelli M1S90 compare to these other shotguns? My understanding is that the Benelli is also recoil operated.
 
How does the operation of the Benelli M1S90 compare to these other shotguns?

Like apples and oranges . A completely different system. Below is the operation discription of the Benelli recoil bolt system which I copied off a different source. (not mine)





The Benelli M1 semi-automatic shotgun based on the proprietary Benelli system, which utilizes the gun recoil and inertia of the moving parts to operate the action. This system was developed by Benelli by the mid-1980s, and is simple and reliable in operation. System utilizes the rotating bolt head with two locking lugs that lock into the barrel extension. The bolt is mounted inside the massive bolt body (bolt carrier), and fixed to it by the locking pin, which allows the bolt head to move slightly forward and back and rotate simultaneously within the bolt body. The massive inertia spring is interposed between the bold body and head, and separate recoil spring is located in the buttstock, pressing the bolt body forward via the link at its rear. When bolt is in the battery, the locking lugs of the bolt head are engaged with the barrel and locked it. Inertia spring, pressing on the both bolt body and head, holds the head in the forward position relative to the body. When gun is fired, it recoils and moves back slightly against shoulder of the shooter. Due to the inertia of the bolt body, it resists the initial recoil movement, so the bolt head, locked rigidly with the barrel and the rest of the gun, moves back relative to the bolt body, compressing the inertia spring and rotating itself to unlock due to the head locking pin being encaged in the cam slot in the bolt body. As soon as the rotation of the head is enough to unlock the bolt head from the barrel, the residual pressure of the barrel pushes the bolt head back, and this, in turn, pushes the bolt body against the recoil spring, overcoming the bolt body inertia and commencing the reloading cycle (ejection of the spent case and feeding and chambering of the fresh round). As soon as the bolt group returns into the battery, the pressure of the compressed inertia spring pushes the bolt body slightly back against the bolt head, causing the bolt head to rotate and lock into the barrel. Now, gun is ready for the next shot.
 
That's making an assumption...

The Remington Model 11 was not made to shoot magnum loads . Light loads were meant to be fired with the friction ring stored next to the reciever to the rear of the recoil spring with the concave part of the ring facing rearward. If heavy loads are to be used, then the friction ring is moved to the forward side of the recoil spring between the spring and the bronze friction piece with the concave surface facing the bronze friction ring.. If your buying a Model 11 you should look carefully for damage caused by using magnum loads in the gun. It starts with the distruction of the 1/8 inch thick fiber buffer that is located on the inside rear of the reciver. This is a buffer for the rear of the bolt. When distroyed the bolt will then make contact with the rear of the receiver - metal to metal - and then finish by cracking the bolt typically on the rear left side. ( a crack that can't be seen unless you disassemble the gun) If the fiber buffer is still intact, the bet is that the bolt is OK, if not - proceed with caution on a purchase.

That the shotgun even came with that fiber buffer in the back of the receiver. My low-number Model 11 has neither the buffer nor provisions for mounting one. It appears Remington and Browning thought to add one sometime later in the production lifetime of the guns. :eek:
 
That the shotgun even came with that fiber buffer in the back of the receiver. My low-number Model 11 has neither the buffer nor provisions for mounting one. It appears Remington and Browning thought to add one sometime later in the production lifetime of the guns.

Thanks for your input . I was unaware that early guns were unbuffered as all I have seen were buffered. The retaining rivot for the buffer goes into a small blind hole at the back of the receiver. I have seen guns that lost the buffer and then pounded the rivot into the hole making it almost indistiquishable from the receiver metal - are you certain that this is not the case with your gun, or do you have other information as well regarding this issue ?
 
No rivet, no hole.

Even took a carbide scribe to the area where the fiber buffer should be centered, to feel for an indentation where said rivet should be. Nothing.

Remington Model 11, full pistol grip, 12 gauge, plain barrel, 5-round forend and magazine. Serial #15962x.
 
Thanks Gewehr98

First one I have heard of - if you find other information on this let me know. Do you have any idea when they started using the buffer ? You have me curious now as I had thought they started production with this feature ,and I will have to do some research.
 
mtnrivrat... do you have a similar treatise on the Remington 1100 and Winchester SX2 systems?

I'll prepare one on the basics of the gas operated system and post later today.
 
i agree! HEAR HEAR

And then post something about benelli m1s90s?

i'm kind of a noob with mine and i'd love to hear what experts like you have to say about them - warnings, suggestions, good accessories, bad ones, etc, anything!
 
And then post something about benelli m1s90s?

I was hoping some Benelli fan would hop in here with lots of data ! I guess other than the info I posted in #8 above, my knowledge & experience with the Benelli is limited.

I did work on a couple prior to retiring from gun repair work . That is not much of a sample. One of these had a broken locking head pin which I felt was not something that should happen . I haven't heard of any real problems with them, but I admitt I am sort of out of the loop .

As far as accessorizing them, I think that depends on the idividual and the intended use of the shotgun.

My first impression of this gun was that it is nothing special and not worth the hype and the price --- My local gun shop stopped stocking them for that very reason , but to each his own , and like I admitted - my knowledge of this shotgun is limited.
 
well

i got my m1s90 for 499 so it wasn't much more than a mossberg for me.

kicks so darn hard though. really really really hard. i can't take more than 25 rounds a day.
 
Excellent post! My newly acquired Browning A5 magnum wouldn't eject nothing, not even some 1.5 oz loads I had. It was filthy so last night I tore it down and gave it a cleaning and fired it this morning and it still wouldn't eject.:banghead: I found this post about how the friction rings need to have a light coat of oil on the magazine tube and so I put some Militec on the tube and took it out and fired a few rounds and they all ejected great.

This thread should be made into a sticky for everyone to see when they start having problems with their recoil operated shotguns.
 
DHart said:
TNT... when it comes to semi-auto shotguns "cleanliness is next to Godliness." ;)

I knew it had to be something simple and all it took was a little oil on the magazine tube to turn that A5 into a fully functioning work of art.
 
Replacing M-11 buffer

mnrivrat,

I have an older Police M-11 (circa 1939) and was able to find a replacement buffer and rivet. The one in my gun is still intact, but it's probably not a bad idea to replace it just to be on the safe side. I plan on shooting my gun regularly and will also be replacing all the springs and recoil system parts. I was able to find all replacement Remington springs except for the recoil spring. It is a Browning A-5 recoil spring for a 2.75" chambered gun.

Should the recoil spring be the same as my M-11 or is there a good chance the spring rate is different?

The gun doesn't appear to have been fired much. Is the recoil spring something I should be concerend with changing or are they fairly durable?

How do I go about replacing the buffer and rivet?

Great post, thanks for the information.
 
Last edited:
Hi !

And Thanks !

In regards to the recoil spring : Replacement with the Browning spring will work just fine if you choose to do so . The recoil springs are in fact very durable and I have not changed even one that I can remember ,because of it causing a problem. ( I have changed a few just for maintenance )

If your present buffer does not show signs of deteriorization I would leave that alone also and just check it periodicaly. To change it you need to strip everthing out of the reciever and drill out the old rivot (working from the front of the receiver) with a long shafted drill bit of appropriate size . (measure the shank dia. of the replacement rivot for correct size) .

After drilling you have to pick out the flared portion of the rivot that will still be left inside the hole. The rivot hole is larger at the rear than at the opening . This allows the pin to mushroom into the larger cavity at the rear and hold the buffer in place. You can use a pick or dental tool , but get all of the old rivot out being careful not to expand the front of the rivot hole in the receiver

Once the residue of the old rivot and buffer are removed you can replace the buffer and rivot - use a long shafted punch to re-set the new rivot in place. The rivot is soft enough that moderate strikes will mushroom the rear into the expanded rear of the hole. Go slow until the rivot holds the buffer tight and then stop.
 
Other than being black from oil and crud, the buffer appears ok. I have not had the chance to shoot the gun yet, but I will keep a close eye on the buffer. The replacement doesn't seem beyone my abilities, but I'd rather not try it if I dontt have to.

Thank you for the help.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top