i know what you are saying, and i assume you are adressing me in that, and not to worry, i hear that arguement, from, faimly, friends, and people i hardly know, i know your point, understand where you are coming from, but, at least personally it seams to me that my cartridge runs out of poop befor my scopes do, with 2 personal exceptions where i went to higher magnification, a .224TTH which went from 12x to 15x, and my .257 Wby, which went from 4x to 6x, and the increase in magnification definalty made a diffrence, both scopes seem to be very fine optically, and both are weaver K serise scopes, and i know the varibles have advangtages, but disadvantages as well, they are heavier, and as a rule not as bright and not as wide a fov as a fixed power in the same magnification scope, i currently use scopes from 2.5x-15x, nearly all are fixed power, with the exception of a leupold VX-III1.5-5, which so far i have no complaints, but i do quite a bit of shooting and make sure to farmiliarize(?) myself with a rifle befor i hunt with it, and i can honestly say i could have used more magnification for some of the shots i have taken, but i never consider myself underscoped, even with a 2.5x at 250 yards, but let us rember, this is a deer, bear, elk, etc., not a pop can, and i highly doubt i could hit a pop can with one of my 2.5x scopes at 250 yards.
sorry, i can rambel on forever if im not stopped, fortinualty, my typing skils are mediocre, and i will stop at this.
ken