lanternlad1
Member
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2007
- Messages
- 770
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/ky9rw/seriously_america_whats_the_big_deal_with_guns/
This question was asked by an Englishman. There were many different answers, mostly based in ignorance and one even quoting Michael Moore in "Bowling for Columbine". The site this question was posed on in owned by Conde Nast, and is frequented by many in the political world as a way to keep tabs on the pulse of what the "little people think". Feel free to give them your opinion.
This was mine:
To answer your question, OP, we have guns in this country because we are entitled to them per the Second Amendment of the US Constitution. The rationale of the Founding Fathers was that sooner or later, there might be reason for the general populace to take up arms against the government, and therefore access to those arms would be necessary. Guns are tools, nothing else. Tools with a specific purpose, yes, but still only tools.
There are still places in America where people live but there are no police, fire, or emergency services of any kind. Here we have threats not only from two legged animals, but four legged ones. Bears, mountain lions, and coyotes are real threats here, and if they can't find food in the wild, they come into town looking for it. It happens. A lot. Here, guns really do save lives. The United States is the third largest country in the world land mass wise behind Canada and Russia. If you look at an American map, look for the State of Wisconsin. That, acreage-wise, is the approximate size of the UK, just so you can see the difference. The United States has approx. 310 million citizens according to the last census, scattered all over the country. The UK has 60 million citizens stuffed into a country the size of Wisconsin. Canada has 35 million citizens, 90% (literally) of whom, live in cities on the border of the US. We have more people in California than Canada does in its entire country.
Asking why the citizens of the US don't behave in the same manner as citizens of other countries is a silly argument. Its one thing to ask why, because you don't understand, totally another thing to start a discussion to further an agenda. For someone to despise an inanimate object because they don't understand it is the very basis of ignorance, and to disdain those who own said object because you don't understand why they own it is the very basis of discrimination.
I just don't get it, you live in a country where barely a month goes by without some loon running around a school shopping mall playing counterstrike for real, it appears you can own sub machine guns, 50 cals, legally? Why are you all obsessed with them?
This question was asked by an Englishman. There were many different answers, mostly based in ignorance and one even quoting Michael Moore in "Bowling for Columbine". The site this question was posed on in owned by Conde Nast, and is frequented by many in the political world as a way to keep tabs on the pulse of what the "little people think". Feel free to give them your opinion.
This was mine:
To answer your question, OP, we have guns in this country because we are entitled to them per the Second Amendment of the US Constitution. The rationale of the Founding Fathers was that sooner or later, there might be reason for the general populace to take up arms against the government, and therefore access to those arms would be necessary. Guns are tools, nothing else. Tools with a specific purpose, yes, but still only tools.
There are still places in America where people live but there are no police, fire, or emergency services of any kind. Here we have threats not only from two legged animals, but four legged ones. Bears, mountain lions, and coyotes are real threats here, and if they can't find food in the wild, they come into town looking for it. It happens. A lot. Here, guns really do save lives. The United States is the third largest country in the world land mass wise behind Canada and Russia. If you look at an American map, look for the State of Wisconsin. That, acreage-wise, is the approximate size of the UK, just so you can see the difference. The United States has approx. 310 million citizens according to the last census, scattered all over the country. The UK has 60 million citizens stuffed into a country the size of Wisconsin. Canada has 35 million citizens, 90% (literally) of whom, live in cities on the border of the US. We have more people in California than Canada does in its entire country.
Asking why the citizens of the US don't behave in the same manner as citizens of other countries is a silly argument. Its one thing to ask why, because you don't understand, totally another thing to start a discussion to further an agenda. For someone to despise an inanimate object because they don't understand it is the very basis of ignorance, and to disdain those who own said object because you don't understand why they own it is the very basis of discrimination.