Sig P220 vs Robar Glock 30 (also G22 vs G23)

Status
Not open for further replies.

1KPerDay

Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2006
Messages
20,875
Location
Happy Valley, UT
I recently posted a quick writeup about the G30, G27, G23, and G22... I like the G23/27/30 a lot.

Over the weekend I went shooting again with my brother and he brought his Sig P220. We were plinking at about 30-40 paces at cans and plastic bottles and stuff. I handed my brother the G22 and he emptied the mag, then I handed him the 23 and he did the same. Then I asked him which he liked better and he said the 23. He couldn't really specify why, other than it just felt 'right' to him. I told him I felt the same.

I tried out his P220 again and the first can I settled my sights on jumped 15 feet in the air. And the second... and the 4th, 5th, 6th... I can't believe how easily I was hitting with it. Reminded me of my P226.

I remember the last time I shot his 220 I was comparing it back to back with my combat commander and Para-ord P14-45, and I remembered thinking that the P220 kicked a lot harder. But comparing it back to back with the G30 the recoil seemed similar, but the glock felt kind of clunky. I could feel the magazine moving around against the base of my hand and it seemed I could feel that big heavy slide chunking around. I didn't hit any cans with it, either. I realize that is not a fair test of accuracy, and I really liked the G30 when I shot it a couple of weeks ago. I still like it... but now I'm thinking of trading it for a P220.:D I just wish Sig could find a way to fit 10 or 12 rounds into that grip frame.
 
One of the best things about a 220 is the feel of the single-stack grip. Seven or eight rounds of .45 ACP should be plenty for most self-defense situations (but I'd be the first to concede that no one has ever complained about having too many bullets in a gunfight!)
 
One of the best things about a 220 is the feel of the single-stack grip.
I agree... it feels great. However, I don't think it's much narrower than my P226, if at all. I don't have the specs in front of me. Seems they should be able to fit at least 10 45s in there if they can fit 13-15 .40s depending on the magazine... But maybe the grip frame walls have to be thicker or something. I sure like it in any case.:cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top