I have been carrying a P228 9mm as a back up and primary when not in uniform for about 16 years. I have about 40K rounds out of it over those 16 years. I have had the gun refinished with NP3 on the blue steel components which I have worn through twice now. (what would you look like after 10K or more holsterings over a 16 year period in Texas Humidity or after 8 to 10 yours on a balistic vest working an accident on I20 .
My gun issues are none.
My other issues are me at times not being smart about maintenance. i.e. recoil spring change, mag spring change, shooting "no quality" ammo and a squib load appeared and some things like that. I changes recoil, mag, trigger bar, and return springs before needed.
I learned the hard way.:banghead: how to remove a bullet from a barrel and how to buy a new barrel because I was "DuH" on the process.
Would I buy again. Yup.
Would I trade off. NOPE.
Would I upgrade to a similar with more features, No, but I did change my primary which was a 16 years P226 9mm to a full stainless P226 9mm with light rail as I work evenings and the light is handy.
Is the P228 a great service piece. Yes.
Has the gun been there when I needed it. Without any question or reservation. Yes.
Best bit of advice. Do not "cheap @$$" yourself when, purchasing, servicing and maintaining for protection. There is a reason for a discount and your undying gratitude has nothing to do with it.
What you do for practice is a totally different story.
Does this mean the P228 is the best out there. NO. but the model works for me and fits my needs.
I just hope I have helped in your decision process.