It was a tie until I bought another Gen4 G19 recently. The Gen4 Glocks have lower-volume grip frames, which makes them better for me. My hands are long, but I have medium-length index and middle fingers, and somewhat short ring fingers, pinkies, and thumbs. If not for my employer's list of authorized duty pistols being mostly double-column, I would likely own only, or mostly, single-column pistols.