Spiller and Burr Mystery

Status
Not open for further replies.
I had a similar deal with a .31 pocket Remington,from Traditions.Looked down the barrel...it wasn't rifled! To their credit they made it right immediately,but I'm wishing now I'd kept it,I'd definately be the only one with a .31 cal. ''shot pistol''!
 
I just put this on another thread, but it bears repeating. I ordered once, a .31 Wells Fargo from EMF and got a pistol with SIX chambers. Now, considering that the pocket .31's are all 5 shots, I thought this to be a tad odd. :what::rolleyes:

I never got around to taking it apart, or looking to see if it was rifled, or if the cylinder indexed. I just called and sent this one back for a credit immediately. :fire:

The Doc is out now. :cool:
 
Interesting

I understand wanting to be Histerically correct and all , but that would have been and awfully interesting piece to still have , if it actually indexed correctly too that is :D ..........Dang Italians sometimes :cool: Mostly they get stuff right , but wow , what an odd way to screw up that one .

Jaeger
 
DrLaw said:
I just put this on another thread, but it bears repeating. I ordered once, a .31 Wells Fargo from EMF and got a pistol with SIX chambers. Now, considering that the pocket .31's are all 5 shots, I thought this to be a tad odd.


Weird! Don't they "proof" fire the revolvers before leaving the factory? If so ... I wonder how this 6 shot got past. Maybe it did index right ....
 
They actually

Proof at the Proof house , the revovlers are sent to the Proof house from the factory , cylnders are proofed , stamped, the barrels are proofed, stamped ,
and so on .
If they relied on the guns actually working , not many woudl actually get here :what:

Jaeger
 
Jaeger... So you've actually talked to someone face to face that was from Uberti and Pietta? That would be an interesting story if you ever get time to write it down.
I hesitated in posting the Palmetto story after proofreading it as it sounds so over the top I thought no one would believe me. Tell you what, if I was a wallhanger collector, I'd have kept the thing. It does show me, however, that Palmetto may, at one time, have made nice firearms. It's also kind of sad to watch DGW go downhill. Ya'gotta' love that catalog.
I did keep the Palmetto catalog that was in the box. If no one minds, I'll list the contents here. May be of use to someone.

-Wesson rifle .45
-1861 Whitney .36
-1855 New Model sidehammer .31/.36
-1862 New Model Police .36
-1862 Pocket Navy .36
-1849 Old Model pocket .31
-1849 Baby Dragoon .31
-1849 Wells Fargo .31
-Army 1860 .44
-Navy 1861 .36
-Dragoon 1848 .44
-1858 Remington New Model .36/.44
-1847 Whitneyville Walker .44
-1863 Remington New Model pocket .31
-1851 Colt pattern .44
-1851 Reb Confederate .36
-1851 Sheriff's .36
-1851 Reb Nord .36
-1856 Philadelphia Deringer .41
-Abilene Derringer .41
-Lafayette flint boxlock .41
-McNab percussion boxlock
- Percussion powder tester
-Konig Leopold 12 gauge
-Salzburg 12 gauge
-1777 Charleville .69
-1799 North & Cheney
-Kentucky flint and percussion .45

Various barrel lengths, stainless steel etc. plus not a few flasks, measures, molds, nipple wrenches, cappers and locks (flint) both right and left handed.
 
No , not face to face

phone to phone for both , and too many E-Mails to list on top of that .
I used to care more , now I have reduced myself to accepting that I don't matter . Pitty sad too :D ....I understand supply and demand very well , and that is pretty much there excuse to me on both issues of CCH and trigger pulls .
It isn't like it used to be Allison , where you could call up Navy Arms and get Val Folgert to actualy answer the phone and speak with him about stuff , orders , advice , congratulate him on makeing such a nice product for you and your voice went somewhere . Even if nothing happened to change a companies product , back in the day at least you could voice it and it would be heard . Not anymore . Even calling the reps and owners back then of the Firearms they sell , like Val with Navy Arms and such , you knew the idea you just told them would not just get hung up after they hung up the phone , they would pass it on to the Italian Bosses .
Now Jason of Tradtions that Ratdoggy has good repore with is nice and all, but he is customer service Rep , has little input to making QC issues go away . That is mostly what were stuck with now though . They don't want people calling them am sure . I haven't seen anywhere on Piettas or Ubertis Websites in years that your feedback was essential to thier livelyhoods , hee hee hee hee . :D
On CASS many years ago , the guy from Pietta used to frequent the site and listen in to ideas . Whether anything ever changed I think it did, their QC has gone WAY UP . But that tis about as much participation I have ever seen form an actual owner or importer besides Val Folgert. He cared ! But, he's
dead now , rest his sport loving BP soul .
So anywayz , I do think both companeis have come a long way , Palmetto killed themselves though , Euroarms puts out some nice stuff too , I have some, its very nice, but some have it and its crap . It's a crap shoot, and it pays to be able to tinker on these guns reguardless . Look at the prices, they are dirt cheap compaired to an American Colt . I think you get what you pay for and more with Italian replicas . Will they get any better ? Keep shooting them , promoting BP revolver sports and they just might, supply and demand man , that's what drives this Pony . :D
When I had the oportunity to buy Vals old personal Tyron from a very good freind of Vals , I jumped on it with both feet and hands . To me that rifle stands for everything this sport and its firearms and importers are all about .
Everytime I look at that rifle , I know those were the days , and these are not . Pitty sad too . I ordered my very first Colt Uberti Flat Top Target Model "P" from Val over the phone . Those were the days indeed . I spent over half and hour talking with that man and he had all the time in the world for me .
That tis why I think if someone were to open COLT Black Powder back up into production that knew how to run it and didn't have a crappy nasty east coast attitude and still produce beautiful firearms as most were done till they went under , they would have Market Share exclusivley ,eventually :D .
I would pay the money for a good American gun . And yes, they would have to drop any Importing parts crap form Italy too like they were doing . There is enough of a demand from Cowboy Action Shooting and us little guys too to warrent another firearms maker of BP Revolvers for sure now in my mind at least. I would be the leading customer I say :D .

Cheers, Good Day , Das Jaeger
 
CVA cares

I had some back and forth with the head of CVA not too long ago via e-mail. I was both surprised and pleased to have actually gotten the head honcho on the subject I was inquiring about.

Makes me think that CVA is one of those old-timey firms that does care about the customer and potential customers enough that the top dog's tail wags for you. :p

That tells me a lot about a company, and it tells me good stuff! :)

The Doc is out now. :cool:
 
Palmetto could have done good, but...

I did keep the Palmetto catalog that was in the box. If no one minds, I'll list the contents here. May be of use to someone.

With that line-up, there isn't a single reason that the company should fail but for crappy workmanship, materials, etc... Of course, that is what Palmetto did, turn out stuff that was not worth it. The Whitney filled a niche, but you can't fill a niche with sand and expect it to stand up. It's a shame that they did that.

The Doc is out now. :cool:
 
crappy nasty east coast attitude
That filtered down from that crappy nasty Sam Colt from CT.;)

I had a small .31 brass framed FIE that was probably made by Palmetto that wasn't too bad at all, but what can go wrong with a gun that shoots O shot over 10 grs of black powder...
I wish someone would come out with a good Whitney repro, maybe a Root.
 
Pohill

Oh hey PoHill , did you sence my frustration with dealing with Colt Black Powder Company there :D ........I do find that to be true in life today with Geography as a whole to be honest . West Coast , Southeast coast , South West , Mid West , South Central appears to be normal , but East Coast Proper appears to be attitude central in my experience . :D:neener:

I agree the Root and the Whitney , I would buy both and wanted to , but not Palmetooos , nope . I think the Whitney would sell very well too . For Cass and such I can't think of a much better gun in .36 .
As much as I like my Navy .36's in Remington brand , they are HEAVY compaired to a Whitney .

I regress though , it appears to not going to be happening anytime soon reguardless , unless Uebrti or Pietta jump on board. It would be very easy for Pietta to do a Steel frame Spiller and Burr though, they have the tooling already ? They may be hope just yet :D
Now how nice would that be , a Spiller and Burr with CCH like Pietta does on the frame :D.......Mmmmmmmm , and how about an engraved Old Silver version too , yup , now were talkin .

Das Jaeger
 
I've been all around this great big world and I've seen all kinds of...
Wait, isn't that a Beach Boys song?
East, West, North, South...people are people. Some suck.
I gotta say, take out the politics from MA and the northeast, and it's pretty country. Lots of history, ocean, mountains, deep forests...
Here's a pic of my Whitney going BANG:
CopyofWhitneyFlame2.gif
 
The thing most puzzling to me about the Palmetto gun was the extreme difference in quality between the various parts. On the one hand, you have the frame, trigger guard,hammer, grips, overall fit, CCH etc. that are beyond reproach. On the other hand
you have the cylinder, pin and barrel that looked good except for certain points in the manufacturing process that are very recognizable to anyone who's ever worked in a machine shop which I've done ever since Moses signed my personal copy of the Old Testament (First Edition). What this tells me is that there's a factory in Italy dusty, sitting empty and, if the equipment and jigs are still there, could make someone very wealthy if they knew what they were looking at. The gun's problems were easy fixes. Get 'em done before lunch. It costs exactly the same to do it right as it does to do it wrong except in the long run. Wish I was 20 years old again.
 
It's an original. Here it is napping in a Colt case.
IMG_0004-2.gif

Next to a Spiller & Burr repro
CopyofIMG_0173-1.gif

Spiller & Burr repro cylinder on left, Whitney on right
IMG_0165-1.gif
 
''I had a small .31 brass framed FIE that was probably made by Palmetto that wasn't too bad at all, but what can go wrong with a gun that shoots O shot over 10 grs of black powder...
I wish someone would come out with a good Whitney repro, maybe a Root....''

Palmetto made a Root in two barrel lengths.I always wanted one,but if the QC was bad,maybe I'm glad I never got one.
 
Irony on that one

is they also made the Root Revolving rifle that is still in stock at Dixie for
$1,750.oo , yes thats right , DOLLARS ! :what: Say What !
Now wonder they are still in stock years later . :D

Jaeger
 
The pistol being so reliable might be due to your skill with Black Powder weapons. My first black powder gun was a Spiller & Burr kit I brought back around 1971 for $18.00. I was a machinist apprentice at the time so I felt confident I could assemble and finish the gun.

It worked flawless but I had a few miss fires and cap jams for a time. As I became more proficient with black powder (and acquired more black powder revolvers) the problems became less and less.

Now, like you guys, I seldom encounter a problem.
 
That's true

it is some technic for sure in handling the guns and knowing the guns and ammo propelelnts , LUBES .
I would say out of 97% of all the BP revolvers I own , I have only gotten a coupel crappy ones and NONE that I would call crappy guns that I kept . And I have a coupel a few . They run just fine for me . Except for the CCH on Uberti . That runs down my toilet :banghead:

Jeager
 
Das Jaeger

Can't part with the Whitney just yet, it was a gift from my CW re-inactor son. I think the guy he got it from thought you could fan it like he saw on TV?? Anyway it's in a good gun shop right now having some good guts put in. Hope to have it back shortly. Thanx for the offer, if anything changes I'll holler at ya.
wurfless
 
Wurfless

Thanks for consideration at least , I understand totally , my cold dead hands wouldn't let go of that gun either :D
Good luck , am glad you saw fit to upgrade the thing too , the upgrades will not be hard for a skilled gunsmith to do either . May be expensive , but it will be worth it :D

Das Jaeger
 
A Spiller & Burr without safety notches on the cylinder...how did that happen? I thought all the Piettas had those...mine does!
Mine is an older model I picked up about 8-9 years ago from a guy who wanted to get into BP shooting, but just didn't have the time, so he sold it to me...new in the box for $75!!!!!!
I love the looks and feel of it...firing roundballs with 12-15 grains of real BP gives it a loud CRACK rather than a boom!
Can you really go to 20 grains safely??
 
My S&B doesn't have the notches; I obtained it in the early 1990s.
At the time IIRC only the Colt 1860 had the safety pins and the other Colt Pietta made did not have pins. The Remmie Piettas had did have them.
In the past few years IMHO Pietta has improved the quality of their guns, and perhaps one of the steps they've made is the use of notches in the S&B guns as well as safety pins in all their Colt repro guns.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top