Suggestions for a hunting/target .22 revolver

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Apr 2, 2010
Messages
339
Location
East Greenville PA
I'm looking for suggestions on a new or used .22 revolver that will be used for hunting, target shooting, and for teaching my kids to shoot. I think a 4" barrel would probably be best for the task and I would like to stay under $800. Thoughts?
 
Loved my Taurus 990 Tracker for these very purposes. Selling it is the worst gun related decision I have ever made.
 
For an older revolver, I'd vote for a S&W Model 17 or a S&W Model 18. M17's are most available with a 6" barrel, M18's were mostly made with 4" barrel.

For a current production revolver, the S&W Model 617 would be a good choice.

If the kids are younger and their hands are still small, the Ruger SP101 or one of the old S&W J-frame 22/32 kit guns might fill the bill.

Finally, a Ruger Single-Six or Single-Ten would be excellent choices as well, particularly if you partial to single actions.
 
I bought my daughter a S&W Model 63, which she shoots well but she prefers the Ruger 22/45 Target model because it is lighter.
 
Johnny - another possibility is the Ruger Single Six revolver. It is only a 6-shot single action revolver, but it has the second cylider for .22 Magnum. This is almost like having two guns.

I have one with a 6 3/4" barrel that I have used while hunting small game. It's great for popping rabbits and squirrels that are too close for a shotgun or too covered up.
 
I learned on a Single Six when I was a kid. I loved that thing, but gave it to my BiL as a gift shortly before he passed away.

I currently have two double action 22 revolvers, but my daughter (aged 11) doesn't love them. The double ation triggers are stiff for her, and cocking the hammer back for single action also takes more effort than she prefers.

I ran across an old Single Six a month or so back.The finish was in bad shape, but I got it for cheap. My daughter likes it a lot. The hammer is easy for her to cock, and the grip is a good size for her. It is also extremely accurate.

I would recommend them to anyone who wants a good 22 revolver.
 
Which revolver would you say has the best accuracy? Also weight is definitely important since I will use it for hunting from time to time. I am leaning towards a used s&w or a single six. I saw,a model 34 s&w on gunbroker, does anybody know much about that model?
 
S&W Model 18 comes with a 4" barrel and it one of the greatest of the Smith's to teach with.
Well within your price range for a fine example. Any of the Model 18's will have the hammer block and is safe to carry with a round under the hammer. The hammer is held back from the firing pin by the recoil slide and the hammer block is between the hammer and the firing pin unless the trigger is pulled. The Model 34 is the J-frame, which is smaller and lighter than the K-frame of the Model 18. 4" barreled Model 34's are usually more expensive due to rarity than the Model 18's.
Stu
 
I am not 100% sure of the exact details, but IIRC, Ruger started making single-action revolvers that were safe to carry with six rounds in the early 1970's. I believe they have been called "New Model" Blackhawk or Single Six or what have you ever since then.

Again I am spotty on details, but I think that the Smith and Wessons have been drop safe since World War II or soon afterwards.

So you should be fine unless you buy something that is quite old. My original Single Six brought home many a squirrel when I carried around in the woods and fields as a teenager.
 
Good hunting and target revolver

I've got an H&R 999 sportsman that is as accurate as anything else I've got. It has an mazing trigger in single action! The sights are actually made for target shooting, are adjustable, and the 6" barrel gives it a nice long sight radius. Nine shots in the cylinder is handy, as is the auto ejecting cylinder.

DSC08306.jpg

I've hit a .30-06 brass casing from ~10 yards away with it before, so it should be just fine for squirrels. Now, whether I can do my part is another story...

30ought6.jpg
 
Howdy

For a 22 target revolver, you just can't do any better than a Smith and Wesson K22. The early ones were called K22 Outdoorsman. K stood for the frame size, the midsized frame designed for 38 caliber revolvers, and 22 was the caliber. This one was made in 1932. Don't let its well worn appearance and incorrect Magna Grips fool you, it has the sweetest trigger of any 22 caliber revolver I own and it is the most accurate. Six inch barrels were standard with this model. The only difficulty with these early K22s is the screws to adjust the rear sight are tiny and you need a tiny screwdriver to adjust them.

k22%201932%2002_zpsicxozbkp.jpg




This photo shows a K22 Masterpiece Postwar (pre Model 17) at the top and a K22 Combat Masterpiece (pre Model 18) at the bottom. Changes from the earlier Outdoorsman model include a narrow rib running down the barrels, modern short throw hammers, and the modern Micrometer rear sight, easy to adjust with a standard small screw driver. The Combat Masterpiece only came with a four inch barrel. This K22 was made in 1950, the Combat version was made in 1954. These guns are right around the top of your budget, I paid a little bit over $800 for each one because they are in almost perfect condition. You might be able to find one for less if you hunt.

pre%2017%20and%20pr%2018%2001_zpsnmpiojqc.jpg




In 1957 Smith and Wesson changed over to a numbering system for all their models. The K22 Masterpiece became the Model 17, the K22 Combat Masterpiece became the Model 18. I bought this Model 17-3 brand-spanky new in 1975 for $125, but that was 1975. If you hunt around you may find one for around $500, you will probably have to pay more. This one has the Three Screw frame (one screw is hidden under the grip), and a heavy, non-tapered barrel with a wide rib.

Model_17-3%2002_zpsiu3tfov5.jpg




This is a Model 617. In Smith and Wesson land, a model number starting with a 6 means the gun is made of Stainless Steel. This one has a six inch barrel with a full underlug which makes it heavier than a revolver without the full length underlug. The cylinder holds ten rounds, not six. I believe it was made around 2008, sorry, I don't remember what I paid for it. Personally, I don't care too much for this gun. I don't like full lug barrels, I think they are ugly, and the rubber grips that it came with are ugly too. I only bought it because I was competing in a steel plate match that required 8 aimed shots in 15 seconds, something I could not do with a six shooter.

model617-6_zps562f28e0.jpg


As previously stated, all Smith and Wesson revolvers made after World War Two are completely safe to carry fully loaded with a live round under the hammer.


***************




Ruger Single Sixes are great revolvers but obviously they do not offer you as much versatility as a double action revolver. But many of us shoot our double action revolvers single action style most of the time, so it may be a moot point, depending on how you shoot.

This Single Six came with two cylinders, one for 22 short, long, and long rifle, the other for 22 Magnum Rimfire. I never use the magnum cylinder, magnum rimfire rounds are expensive and very loud.

Notice there are three screws in the frame of this Single Six. This is the older model that does not have a transfer bar inside. This model IS NOT safe to fully load with six rounds, the chamber under the hammer MUST be kept empty in case the gun is dropped and lands on the hammer spur.

singlesixwmr01modified_zps8a8ae652.jpg




Ruger ceased production of all their 'pre-transfer bar' single action revolvers in 1973 when they introduced the New Models which have a transfer bar inside. For easy identification of the older models look to see if the frame has three screws. All New Model Ruger single action revolvers have two pins, instead of three screws, like this 45 caliber Blackhawk from 1975.

turnlineBlackhawkSNmodified_zpse91b1bf1.jpg
 
Ruger Single Ten. Single action, 10 shots, way under the $800 limit. That leaves lots of $$ for ammo. Great plinker, blazingly accurate, and beautiful also.

100_2717_zps3cbff748.jpg
 
Taurus Tracker with 6.5" barrel. 9 shots and can be converted to .22 Magnum. They also come in a 4" barrel and cost less than $600.
 
The Model 63 is a stainless steel 8-shot J-frame with 3" barrel. That might be good for small hands. The Model 617 is a stainless steel 10-shot with a 4" barrel and full underlug. It has a more muzzle-heavy balance and is built on a medium frame. These can be bought new for under $700. The older Model 18 might be the best option, with a great trigger, great balance and excellent accuracy. A fine example of the M18 could be bought for $800 or a shooter-grade specimen for $500 - $600.
 
my single ten is loads of fun n i love it.
but, at 25 yards, it won't group like my 22/45.
how much accuracy do you want?
the 22/45 will give a 1'' group at 25 yards. the single ten, closer to 3''.
 
I have a Ruger single six and a Dan Wesson 22 with a 6" and 8" barrel. With decent SV ammo, my Ruger single six will group in the 1" to 1.5" range @ 50 yards. The Dan Wesson will get 1" or just under that with good ammo @ 50 yards. I am very happy with both of them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top