Tactical/Advanced Pistol Class - FAIL

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jetplane19

Member
Joined
May 27, 2010
Messages
3
Hi All - I just need to vent.

I may be wrong, I may be right. If you can relate as a student, instructor; positive, or negative, that would be great.

I'm a 38yo guy that's been interested in CCW for a year or so. I joined a reputable outdoors club almost a year ago to get more practice - and to avoid the pay-by-the-hour public indoor ranges.

I got my CCW permit about 5 weeks ago, and I was very prepared with the right carry guns that work for me and their respective holsters. Having the gear that already works for me, I'm a believer in spending my money on training instead of more gear. Therefore, I was excited to register for the Tactical Pistol Class offered by my club. The instructor "BOB" is said to be a key instructor for many local LEO depts.

5 hour class
$100

Class-day arrives. I'm very excited. I show up 15 min early to the outdoor range. $100 check in hand, gun, ammo, holster, pen, notebook, etc.

There are 5 guys there already. (I see I was the last to show up). Guys are in a group, looking over each others' firearms. I unpack at the bench, taking it all in. 5 min later, one of the guys walks up to my stuff, picks up my pistol, breaks it down in 1.5 seconds and inspects it. I said, "uh, Hi, I assume you're the instructor?"
"Yep", he said, "and I'm also a certified *@#$% armorer. Looks like yours has no mods. Good. I always look out for that" ...[snap / crackle / pop] ...and my gun is back together again. He then pulls out a few of his own guns to do the snap/crackle/pop & show me how fast he can work the action & tell me some ins & outs about them. ho hum.

The other 4 guys seem to all know each other. I introduce myself all around. Life is OK, I guess. We take turns to haul the targets out of the shed. BOB starts setting things up. A big blue 60gal drum here, a big bucket there, a few chairs over yonder, etc.

By now, it is 1 hour into the 5hr class.

Some Snap Caps are passed out. We load them into our mags and practice some close range left-knee and right-knee misfire / slap / rack / fire drills.
OK, Cool! we're finally getting somewhere!

Next, we swap out some of the Snap Caps for some live ammo.
Standing, every misfire from the Snap Cap results in a slap / rack / fire.
Nice, I've learned how to quickly clear problems in a hurry.

We take a break. 2 hours elapsed.

Next, BOB decides to discuss knives and OC spray. 30 min go by to explain the OC spray only he can get as an LEO and how awful it was to get sprayed with it back in basic training. Who cares? :banghead:

Then a vehicle pulls up to the range. Exit 3 females. Momma bear and two 20something daughters. All have the Pat Benatar look going for them with fancy tight logo clothing and cases of pistols ready to go they just bought a few days ago.

30 min go by as the guys, BOB, and the girls chit chat (OK, so they know each other).

We begin the main drill. Each shooter busting through the course like an IDPA match. OK, neat, never did that before. We did that 3 times each. Fun. 2 hours to go.

Uh Oh, one girl's brand new pink gun is jamming. BOB takes 30 min to work with it.

They all chit chat, I sit there. It is about 1 hour near quitting time. I ask if we are going to do anything else here (?????) BOB replies, "I just have to diagnose this problem." :cuss:

HELLO???? DID THESE PEOPLE PAY TO TAKE THIS CLASS??? NO.

I ask again what's next. BOB asks me, "what would you like to work on?" I said, "dude. This is your class. I'm a total rookie. I DON'T KNOW WHAT I NEED TO WORK ON. I came here to learn. You must have a syllabus or something (?)." He works with me 1 on 1 for 15 min while the others chit chat.

30 min left to go.
One guy opens his trunk and pulls out some sweet tactical rifles as I walk by. His buddy holds it in awe, and muzzle-sweeps the entire group of people. I rolled my eyes.

BOB discusses used minivans and motorcycles with 1 of the guys for 15 min.

15min left to go.
Mr. Tactical says to BOB, "we done? should we get out the automatics?"

BOB replies, "Sure! The RO left the gate open for me to lock up so we can do whatever we want."

They proceeded to blow through some full-auto bursts while I packed up my stuff. As they were all gathering around Pat Benatar who was on her belly to teach her to shoot a machinge-gun prone, I told BOB that I'm outta here.

He said, "OK, well we'll have another one of these sessions next month ____ and ____ and ____"

I gave him the deer-in-headlights look and left.

Looks like I walked right into a good 'ol boy's club. <DARN> They all knew each other, they take that "class" often, as if money grows on trees. I'm pretty sure that BOB and the club RO are buddies, so I didn't mention anything at all. I just chalk it up as a little bit of new info that I learned and that's that.

From now on, I will not take any class that I don't get an honest face-to-face review. I had wasted about $75 of my $100, 4 of 5hr of my time. RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
 
I knew you were in trouble as soon as I saw the price.

Only one way you were taking a course for that price, and it's from the local know-it-all.

You're on the right track spending money on training....but stick to the big name schools, read some reviews before you go and make it worth your time.

I'd cancel the check or talk to the club manager...maybe he doesn't know what's going on in his facility.
 
Please give us a state that you are in so we don't take a class there either.

This will be so funny if this is in OR

The price was a giveaway of what to expect
 
I don't quite see how the price was a give away of what to expect.

Telling someone to only go to a "big name school" school isn't realistic. Should one expect to pay $1000 before travel and lodging expenses to get good training?

It's a good idea to check out the "local" guy, as the OP may have saved himself $100, but I bet there's another "local guy" that might charge less and deliver more.
 
FWIW I stick with courses by trainers/instructors that have documented (and verifiable) experience in the relevant areas. Average fee per class seems to run about $150-$300+ for the "good" courses around here, but any less than $150 and you're getting questionable information, bad tactical advice and possibly being taught dangerous habits. More than $350-$400 or so for a 2 day class and you're getting into mall ninja territory.
 
It has been my experience that most good instructors are charging $200-$250 per day for 2 to 3 day courses with 8-15 students.

In this economy, I've lowered my fees from $70 to $50 per hour for 1:1 instruction (if they come to me) with a minimum of 2 hours. So a 4 hour block is $200 while a big name is about half again more at $300...and that would cover everything from how to hold the gun through the first shot from the holster
 
That's pretty much on point with what I was saying too, 9mm. Florida seems to be coming down in training cost here lately too, along with the rest of the economy.
 
This is the type of thing that makes me feel more than a bit unsure about searching for instruction.

It seems there are only three types of instructors.

There is the guy that knows what he is doing but wants $500 a day and acts like you should allready be a tactical wizard.

There is the guy that "has military experience" and wants $250 a day, he knows more than the average bear, but he believes he is either god or Rambo.

Then there is the guy that wants to charge $75 for the NRA "defense" classes. He spends half the time on rants or tangents that acomplish nothing. Then puts you on a course for an hour.

How do you find a good instructor that doesn't want a small fortune? A lot of people want to learn how to defend their life, or their family's lives. However, many of us can not afford to finance the instructor's new $50,000 SUV.

I ran in to an instructor at a gun shop a while back. The clerk asked him how his business was doing. I listened and then I asked him how much his classes tend to run. He told me his CCH class price and my jaw dropped. I made the comment that it was more than double what I paid.

He asked where I took my class, then said "well I guess that is good enough."

My simple reply was that if I had to pay his price I couldn't have afforded the class and permit fees. His response, "if your life isn't worth a little cash you shouldn't be carrying."

I explained to him that unemployment in my area is officially at 9.7% but is unofficially estimated at 14%. Not everybody can afford to pay those types of prices. I explained that a lot of people like me were working as "independent contractors." That means that when our jobs dried up we didn't get unemployment or severance packages. We still want to keep ourselves and our loved ones alive.

I don't fault a man for making a living. If the market will support you price then good for you. I just wish more instructors realized that self defense isn't only for people that can afford an extra mortgage payment for a weekend of instruction.
 
I just wish more instructors realized that self defense isn't only for people that can afford an extra mortgage payment for a weekend of instruction.

I agree with this 100%

There are a couple instructors here in town that do specials from time to time, but it's very tied in with one of the local "gun forum cliques" here in town, and not everyone gets the "special" pricing. Very much a situation like what the OP described.
 
Jetplane19

Sounds like you got taken for a bit of ride there. But the price of the instructor can't always be the most decisive way of discerning the quality level of the course. A few years back, a friend of mine and I took an advanced CCW course offered by the top firearms instructor of a large metropolitan police department. He also had had one of the department's martial arts instructors come in and show us some basic gun retention and disarming techniques. Overall the course was maybe 1/2 hour classroom time, 1 hour gun retention instruction, and 2 and 1/2 hours range time. The cost per student was $125 each.

I had a great time, learned and practiced some interesting techniques, and got to run a number of shooting drills that would have been impossible to do at any nearby range. All in all, money well spent.
 
The comments on the instructors skills coming from their prices is a little misleading. $200 per day for a named traveling instructor seems to be the norm but there are quality local trainers that are much more affordable.

We have a local trainer who charges $80 for a 4 hour pistol class. After you've taken it for the first time you can retake them for $20.

Before you write him of as a local yokel he has been invited by Tom Givens to teach at the annual Rangemaster Tactical Conference that past couple years. Teaching is by invitation only and he has taught alongside: S'Narc, Marty Hayes, Rob Pincus, Mas Ayoob, and others.

Quality local instruction is available but it is harder to find than the named schools/instructors.
 
Around here, $200/day or thereabouts gets you a top quality professional who has been in multiple gunfights and has extensive experience instructing people on how to fight with a firearm as well as a range facility dedicated to this type of training.

In the $100-125/day range, you get an experienced local instructor with the local SWAT agency or similar entity who may have a gunfight under their belt or may not. Range facilities will probably be more restrictive.

Below that, you tend to get guys who are good at IDPA/IPSC and/or who have taken a bunch of classes at #1 or #2 above and who have decided to hang out a shingle regardless of their teaching skills.

The other training thing I see occasionally that bugs me is where you have a professional, reputable trainer whose name is at the top of the bill; but when you show up for the class, the main instructors are Joe Bob and Jim Bob whose primary qualifications are that they've taken every class the range offers.

Having said that, I can only think of one class I've had in the past 10 years where I simply didn't learn a single thing of use. That was my last CHL renewal class which I took at a new place simply because I waited until the last minute and they were the only ones who could fit me in. There I got lectured on the legal and practical aspects of CHL by a 350lb "security professional" who was only lacking the trauma plates duct taped to his back.

Otherwise, even at the classes that didn't go perfect, I still learned new things and had positive experiences.
 
It pays to do some research. Ask around, surf some websites, even call and talk with the instructor, hey it is your money he wants. If he doesn't have time to talk to you a little about his course, he probably won't be a very good instructor. I recommend Pat Goodale at www.pgpft.com I have taken several of his classes, he offers everything from a real beginners course, which starts out from the very basics of gunhandling, safety, holster and weapons selection, and a basic understanding of self defense laws. He also offers courses geared to the most advanced shooters, LEO, soon to deploy military, and SOF. The basic courses run $150 a day. The timetable is very tight, no wasted time. You will shoot all day, that being 8-9 hours. The courses that require lecture time are just as tightly run, a wealth of information is imparted, no B.S. time included. Pat teaches the whole class, assistant instructors will deal with gun problems, and other issues. His training site is located in Lewisburg, W.V. and he also does classes in Montana. Pat is a true gentleman, as are his instuctors, no macho posturing here. Well worth the time and money.
 
We have a local trainer who charges $80 for a 4 hour pistol class. After you've taken it for the first time you can retake them for $20.

he has been invited by Tom Givens to teach at the annual Rangemaster Tactical Conference that past couple years. Along with S'Narc, Marty Hayes, Rob Pincus, Mas Ayoob, and others.

I know who you're talking about. For the money, he gives a very good block of instruction.

I took a class from a former Chicago PD officer that was $80 for all day. VERY much worth it.

Thinking that you must pay $500 before you get "quality" instruction is stupid. What's that saying about fools and money being soon parted?

But judging from some of these posts, I may have to adjust my rates!
 
I read nothing that was either 'advanced' or 'tactical'.

A local instructor in my area did an Advanced Defensive Handgun class a few years ago in early November. Started at 8 a.m. We shot from various positions (seated at a restaurant table for example). Also moving, one-hand, off-hand, weak hand reloads, shooting from as close as contact out to 50 and 100 yds.

We took a dinner break and came back after dark for a couple of hours of low light.

Time: approx 10-11hrs
Rounds fired: 700-800
Price: $150 with 14 students

I would absolutely take this class again.
 
Jetplane, sorry you had such a lousy experience. I think training is worthwhile, but, as you found out, not all instructors are worthwhile. It's a shame.

Some nationally known instructors travel around. Louis Awerbuck (author of Tactical Reality and More Tactical Reality) has been teaching classes at a local range on a fairly regular basis. A one day basic class runs $150.00, and the two day follow up class runs $300.00.

Often an NRA certified instructor teaching an NRA course is a good bet. The NRA course syllabuses are quite good, so if the instructor does his job right, you should learn something. The Personal Protection Inside the Home and the Personal Protection Outside the Home, together, will give one a good foundation. A local NRA instructor, who is quite good, charges $150.00 for each one day class. You can look for NRA classes near you on this site: http://www.nrainstructors.org/searchcourse.aspx .
 
A close friend qualifies twice a year at the state police academy. Great training IF you are a LEO or rookie trooper. This lady spends hours on weak hand reloads and tactics she would never use. At around 5'2" and 110lbs I seriously doubt if she gets hit with anything but a BB gun she will not be able to draw with her weak hand, fire her 40cal and perform a one hand reload, weak hand. I have kinda taught her a little of what might work for her and in her position she can and does get a state trooper to drive her to a home visit. Her training is not geared to her job as some "combat" training I have witnessed. The usual stance, two hand hold, aimed shooting always using personal experience only never helped wading water, crawling in brush and garbage where you fire with one hand, point shooting and lucky to be able to see the front sight. You can find many instructors that teach survival not only with your handgun but any available weapon carried or improvised.
 
It would have been hard for me not to sarcastically thank Bob for wasting my money. ;) Seriously, how unprofessional. You probably could have got better instruction from joe shmoe gun enthusiast, or your average highroader.

Finding a quality local class is difficult. I haven't been able to, not that I've been looking extremely hard. My most common method for learning is to offer a person who has more experience (different than "I think he knows more") than me to come shoot at my range, that way I can pick up and share skills informally and free (unless I share some ammo).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top