it looks like it's all been said by now, but as I'm in kind of the same boat as you, let me throw-in here...
given the recession and my need for immediate protection I landed on, or atleast "settled for" Taurus, so lets just skip the company comparrisons. Now, at first I thought I had it down to 3 top choices:
* the judge
* .357 snub
* .38 special
now, like many others I was originally caught-up in the "Judge Hype" but impracticality spoke some sense into me, given the
large size and high ammo cost.
then, I considered the .357 advatages which, as you asked, are higher power and more control by comparison when firing .38s -
however, and I may just be plain wrong here, but as far as I've seen Taurus only makes a 5 shot .357 snub nose and if I was only getting 5 then I'd much rather say "screw it" and just get that
Judge anyway, which I had already decided was not gonna happen...
which brings me to my final option and the choice I made, the
Taurus 856, .38 Special, snub nosed 6-Gun simply because the .38 may pack a weaker punch, but it's still no dang .22 Pea Shooter! You can sure as shootin' take an attacker down with a .38, no
problem, and as a strict wheel-gun man myself, I'd always rather have just 1 more round over a slightly larger round; unless you're getting mugged by a real beast of a psychopath, you shoot the bad
guy and the fight is over, even if it doean't ice him as hard as a .357 or a .45 does!
also remember, mate; concealability is key and most snub nosed revolvers, especially that 856, will fit perfectly inside your sporran
- best CCW hiding place ever, ya know!