I haven't visited this thread in a while. No lack of interest, just extremely busy at work (read, eating my lunch) and my limited gun time has been pulled elsewhere for a while.
However, I have a 686 specific question, and where better to ask it than here?
My question is about a comparison between 3" and 4" 686s.
For those of you who own one, or preferably both, what's the max range that you can consistently keep all rnds on, say, a 12" pie plate (or some other reasonable minute of quadruped or biped metric)?
If you site range data, please specify which barrel: 3" or 4".
I'm asking because I'm considering replacing my 4" 686 with a 3". I originally bought a 4" so that I could, in a pinch, hunt deer with it, even though it's mainly an SD gun for wilderness camps. When I was researching this revolver, I told people that I may occasionally hunt with it, so they said, understandably, "If you're going to hunt with it, don't go with less than a 4" barrel."
But now, I'm re-evaluating the main purpose of my 686. I'm understanding that far and away, it's main purpose is going to be SD, with use as a hunting weapon ONLY in an emergency (which is to say, rarely or hopefully never).
I LOVE the 686. It has found a permanent place in my tool kit. But I'm finding the 4" to be just a little too unwieldy for me, a bit barrel heavy, and just too long to comfortably handle for me. (I'm a relatively smaller person; tall and thin.) So, I'm starting to consider a 3" to replace it, but am unsure how much accuracy I'm going to give up when I lose that extra inch.
Sadly, I've been so busy at work that I've shot my beautiful 686 far too infrequently to even have a good sense of what its realistic range is for keeping all rnds on said 12" pie plate. Hence my question about the comparison.
Yes, I fully understand that such results are STRONGLY influenced by the shooter, and only partly a function of barrel length. But I'm only looking for approximations here, and those who have shot both (with the same skill level) will be able to offer the best estimates.
I haven't made any decisions yet, and am open to arguments pro or con about the transition. I won't make a decision for at least a month (finances is driving that more than anything).
Thanks for data and opinions. Reading with interest.
Nem