The Blame for the Casualties of the Gulf War of 2003

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nando Aqui

Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2002
Messages
529
Location
Missouri
I have two sons in the military. One is a helicopter pilot, has been in the Middle East for months, and his life has been on the line since before the war started. The other is awaiting to be sent over.

I put the blame for all the casualties of this war, Operation Iraqi Freedom, both military and civilian, squarely on France, Germany, Russia, the war protestors, and the Vatican.

If it wasn’t obvious to anyone before the war started that Saddam Hussein, his sons, and his regime of terror had to be removed, it should be crystal clear now. The atrocities that these people have committed through the years, and what they are now doing to their own people are beyond what anyone, even military planners, could ever have imagined.

Mowing down with machine gun fire and mortars the Iraqi people who want to flee for safety, forcing children to confront the allied invasion, and using tactics of deceit and treachery are but the last few examples that illustrate their brutal, sadistic behavior. The public executions that their Fedayeen militia have been conducting on their own people to prevent them from revolting against Saddam and aiding the allies further shows their disregard for human life.

To then see war protestors with signs insinuating that President Bush, and not Saddam Hussein is the devil and the one that is at fault in this conflict is absolute idiocy. And after Iraq has ignored U.N. resolutions for 12 years, and the ‘last chance’ resolution for over six months, to say that the United States, Britain, and the coalition are the ones who are at breach is pure nonsense.

I can’t think of anything that would have given Saddam Hussein greater reassurance and motivation not to abide by the resolutions, but instead to blatantly defy the U.N. than the millions of people who he watched on television taking his side. Oh, he saw them alright.

I can’t think of why Saddam Hussein would have had even a second doubt that he would likely be left alone to continue building his empire of terror than to see countries such as France, Germany, and Russia take his side. Even if Saddam knew that the reason for these countries to behave as such was for economical advantage and perhaps to hide previous and on-going illegal trade with Iraq, he most surely must have felt rather comfortable with them on his side.

I can’t think of anything that could have given Saddam more assurance of appearing to be righteous, even when he knows that he is anything but that, than to have the Vatican condemn any military action against him and to deem the war as immoral.

I say that if the millions of people claiming to be against war, that if the few countries that claimed to have wanted a diplomatic resolution, plus the Vatican, had instead insisted that Saddam abandon his regime of terror and allow his people to be free and to enjoy the wealth of their country, there might have been a better chance that the war could have been averted.

Even if Saddam had not stepped aside, I say that if France, Germany, and Russia would have united with the rest of the coalition early on, Turkey would have allowed use of their land as had been expected, and the war would have started sooner. Had this happened, Saddam would have not had time to deploy the Fedayeen country-wide (something he is known to have done relatively recently) and the war would have been over much sooner and with fewer casualties.

Yes, it is their fault that we are where we are. I know that Saddam will be removed, liberty brought to the people of Iraq, and a bastion for terrorists will be eradicated. But it could have been less costly if those countries and the protestors had been on the right side. Shame on them!

Alex
 
Alex,

First, thank you for raising fine sons. They are a credit to you and your country.

Second, the blame is Saddam's.

Third, perhaps an argument could be made against France and Russia causing us to delay until the sandstorm season and giving Saddam more time to prepare.

But the protesters and the Vatican? They are irrelevant to the execution and outcome of this conflict. :)

As for the Vatican, it pains me to see my Pope (I'm Roman Catholic) forget the concept of just war. Of his protests, I have not seen "This war is unjust" but "War is unjust." I simply cannot imagine him standing up in Warsaw as a young man and saying, "This invasion of Normandy is wrong. War is wrong."

Maybe I missed the part where he distinguished between just war and unjust war.
 
Oh, I agree with you 200%! No question that the culprit is Saddam - that is well understood.

But after the decision has been reached that he has to go, one way or another, the protesters and the Pope sure haven't helped.

I too am catholic, and it really hurts to see this happen. It brings back the stories about of Nazis in WWII and the blind eye of Pius XII, to say the least.

We know who the protest organizers are, mostly socialist groups that hate what the USA stands for. But it is very frustrating to see these sort take advantage of what they can do in this country to side with the country in which they would be hung by their fingernails if they tried to do the same.

At least I know that the overwhelming majority (everyone perhaps?) here at THR is very clear on the righteousness of what Bush, Blair, et al are doing. So it gives me comfort to hear from you guys.

Alex
 
France, Russia, China and Germany are acting out of selfish economic interests, mainly their oil and arms business with Iraq. When you look at the sad state of the economies in France and Germany in particular it's not hard to understand how desperate they would be to maintain what they had. Russia is still a basketcase.
France pressured Turkey by threatening to veto their entrance to the EU if they cooperated with the US. Chirac actually lobbied countries to go against us!
Then there is the red connection. Germany has a foreign minister named Fischer. It is alleged that he was associated witht the Bader Mindhoff gang, the Red brigades and the PLO. Schroeders government is near collapse. All these countries sold as much armament as they could to Iraq. Russia appears to be selling it still.
Unfortunately for us the choices in Iraq may not be Saddam or democracy. It may be yet another despot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top