MeekandMild
Member
- Joined
- Dec 25, 2002
- Messages
- 1,877
I've been thinking of retiring my Marlin deer rifle, looking for one gun which could be used for critters the size of black bear down to coyote. Its .35 Rem is a really great round, but I wonder about alternatives.
The 30-30 is nearly the same as .35 Rem, just a little bit more powerful out of the muzzle and a little bit weaker at longer ranges. The 30-30 would be a whole lot easier to reload due to having reasonable shoulder geometry.
The .44 magnum could be shot with .44 Special for coyotes, .44 Mag for deer and would be sort of weak for bear. Reloading is easy.
Then come the bigger ones. .444, .450 Marlin and 45-70 Government all exceed a 30-06 in terms of muzzle energy, great for bear, a little bit overkill for deer, too liable to punch through a whole lot of trees to hit unwanted things too far away, and way too much for coyote. OTOH all three would be easier to reload than the .35. Of these three the 45-70 does have a factory "cowboy action" load which is about equal to some factory .44 magnum loads.
So which would be better? Of course we are limiting ourselves entirely to guns available in Marlin lever action for aesthetic reasons. This is for a serious woods hunting gun and not for any collection. I expect it to get rained on, muddy and dirty. If I've got to look at a rifle all day for weeks on end I want it to be a levergun.
The 30-30 is nearly the same as .35 Rem, just a little bit more powerful out of the muzzle and a little bit weaker at longer ranges. The 30-30 would be a whole lot easier to reload due to having reasonable shoulder geometry.
The .44 magnum could be shot with .44 Special for coyotes, .44 Mag for deer and would be sort of weak for bear. Reloading is easy.
Then come the bigger ones. .444, .450 Marlin and 45-70 Government all exceed a 30-06 in terms of muzzle energy, great for bear, a little bit overkill for deer, too liable to punch through a whole lot of trees to hit unwanted things too far away, and way too much for coyote. OTOH all three would be easier to reload than the .35. Of these three the 45-70 does have a factory "cowboy action" load which is about equal to some factory .44 magnum loads.
So which would be better? Of course we are limiting ourselves entirely to guns available in Marlin lever action for aesthetic reasons. This is for a serious woods hunting gun and not for any collection. I expect it to get rained on, muddy and dirty. If I've got to look at a rifle all day for weeks on end I want it to be a levergun.