So, I'm looking for a new safe. Problem is, there are 2 very similar safes with similar dimensions and features.
The first one is a Hayman MagnaVault MV-1512:
http://www.haymansafe.com/pages/mv
"Hayman MV-1512 MagnaVault Burglar 2 Hour Fire Rated Safe
Combining the utmost in quality with brute strength security, the MagnaVault MV Series is designed to give you the peace of mind that comes from knowing your valuables are very well protected. The MV safes are built with heavy composite construction, 1 1/4 inch diameter bolts and a massive 4 1/2" thick door loaded up with up to 5 angled hardplates and multiple glass relocking devices to protect premium burglary protection.
Suited for both residential and commercial applications, where valuables need to be protected from burglary and fire.
Features:
Fire Insurance Labratories tested for 2 hours at 1200 degrees, maintaining an internal temperature under 350 degrees.
Massive 4 1/2" thick door.
Body is six sided 2 inch thick composite construction with one recessed mount hole.
1 1/4" diameter chrome plated locking bolt.
5 1/4" hardplates mounted at angles inside the door and body to provide maximum drill attack prevention.
Security of 4 relocking devices to protect the safe from attacks on the lock.
Solid continuous dead bolt for complete locking on hinge side of the door.
Two layers of intumescent door seal that swells at high temperatures to seal the door from fire and smoke.
Painted a tan color with fabric covered door back-cover and shelves.
Large heavy duty ball-bearing hinges for smooth operation."
The second one is the Amsec CSC1413:
http://www.amsecusa.com/Burglary_and_Fire_Protection/CSC_Series_Composite_Safes/
"AMSEC CSC SERIES COMPOSITE SAFES are an affordable solution when you want to protect both documents from fire and valuables from burglary attacks. During extreme testing procedures the CSC SERIES COMPOSITE safes passed a 2-Hour, 350°F factory fire test certification.
Features:
Door:
Overall thickness of 4-5/8" and is constructed with a 2" defense barrier of outer and inner steel plates creating a burglary resistant structure enclosing a unique proprietary, fire resistant material.
Body:
Total protective thickness of 2-7/8" enclosing a unique, high-density fire and burglary resistant composite material.
Durable powder coated adjustable shelves.
(1) each Adjustable Shelves.
Fire Endurance:
2 hour, 350°F factory fire rating. Tested at temperatures up to 1700°F.
Heat expandable intumescent door seal guards contents against severe fires.
Locking Mechanism:
Two to four 1½" diameter solid steel chrome-plated locking bolts.
Two to three 1½" diameter solid steel dead bolts lock deep into body preventing door removal during a forced entry attempt.
U.L. Listed Group II combination lock with chrome-plated spy-proof dial. Optional electronic locks available.
Lock protected by a tempered glass
relock device.
Heavy duty steel hinges provide easy, smooth door operation.
One internal counter-sunk anchor hole and mounting hardware are provided to securely anchor safe.
Attractively accented with a full width facia panel and matching three point handle,
Durable and attractive dark gray textured finish."
Both safes weigh in around 260 lbs. Which safe would be the better buy?
The first one is a Hayman MagnaVault MV-1512:
http://www.haymansafe.com/pages/mv
"Hayman MV-1512 MagnaVault Burglar 2 Hour Fire Rated Safe
Combining the utmost in quality with brute strength security, the MagnaVault MV Series is designed to give you the peace of mind that comes from knowing your valuables are very well protected. The MV safes are built with heavy composite construction, 1 1/4 inch diameter bolts and a massive 4 1/2" thick door loaded up with up to 5 angled hardplates and multiple glass relocking devices to protect premium burglary protection.
Suited for both residential and commercial applications, where valuables need to be protected from burglary and fire.
Features:
Fire Insurance Labratories tested for 2 hours at 1200 degrees, maintaining an internal temperature under 350 degrees.
Massive 4 1/2" thick door.
Body is six sided 2 inch thick composite construction with one recessed mount hole.
1 1/4" diameter chrome plated locking bolt.
5 1/4" hardplates mounted at angles inside the door and body to provide maximum drill attack prevention.
Security of 4 relocking devices to protect the safe from attacks on the lock.
Solid continuous dead bolt for complete locking on hinge side of the door.
Two layers of intumescent door seal that swells at high temperatures to seal the door from fire and smoke.
Painted a tan color with fabric covered door back-cover and shelves.
Large heavy duty ball-bearing hinges for smooth operation."
The second one is the Amsec CSC1413:
http://www.amsecusa.com/Burglary_and_Fire_Protection/CSC_Series_Composite_Safes/
"AMSEC CSC SERIES COMPOSITE SAFES are an affordable solution when you want to protect both documents from fire and valuables from burglary attacks. During extreme testing procedures the CSC SERIES COMPOSITE safes passed a 2-Hour, 350°F factory fire test certification.
Features:
Door:
Overall thickness of 4-5/8" and is constructed with a 2" defense barrier of outer and inner steel plates creating a burglary resistant structure enclosing a unique proprietary, fire resistant material.
Body:
Total protective thickness of 2-7/8" enclosing a unique, high-density fire and burglary resistant composite material.
Durable powder coated adjustable shelves.
(1) each Adjustable Shelves.
Fire Endurance:
2 hour, 350°F factory fire rating. Tested at temperatures up to 1700°F.
Heat expandable intumescent door seal guards contents against severe fires.
Locking Mechanism:
Two to four 1½" diameter solid steel chrome-plated locking bolts.
Two to three 1½" diameter solid steel dead bolts lock deep into body preventing door removal during a forced entry attempt.
U.L. Listed Group II combination lock with chrome-plated spy-proof dial. Optional electronic locks available.
Lock protected by a tempered glass
relock device.
Heavy duty steel hinges provide easy, smooth door operation.
One internal counter-sunk anchor hole and mounting hardware are provided to securely anchor safe.
Attractively accented with a full width facia panel and matching three point handle,
Durable and attractive dark gray textured finish."
Both safes weigh in around 260 lbs. Which safe would be the better buy?
