Tumblers for cleaning brass

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'll add this since I didn't see it mentioned about the HF tumblers: http://www.harborfreight.com/dual-drum-rotary-rock-tumbler-67632.html

This is the rotary rock tumbler with 2 drums. You can use it wet but you can also put some fine walnut media in it & tumble dry & get the same results as a vibratory tumbler. Doesn't hold as much, but you can get a decent amount in a batch & would suit your 200-400 cases just fine depending on caliber.

It is very quiet in operation. It does take longer than a good one, but it's quiet enough to let run overnight in the next room & it won't bother you. I have this and the FA vibratory. One thing I notice about the FA - really torquing down the wing nut (not ape enough to break anything, but good & tight) really quiets it down & improves the cascade action a noticeable amount. I use the FA most since it holds more, but it's nice to have both for the wet option, or to tumble 2 calibers at the same time you wouldn't want in the same batch like 9mm + .380, or to have a spare.

$44 w/ coupon is a pretty low cost option. They also sell the walnut media at HF but you have to pay attention to what 25 lb box you get. They have fine & medium. The fine is great but the medium will get stuck in flash holes like crazy.

Having said all that, If I had it to do all over again knowing what i know now, I'd get one of the larger capacity Lyman units & consider the higher price money well spent. Not only the capacity, but the more 'violent' action inside is a lot faster. When my FA dies some day (still going strong), that's what will replace it.
 
Thanks, CMV, but I've already decided.

The Thumblers UV-10 Tumbler is made in the USA, quiet, high quality, and the company selling them is good people to buy from. Lots of good choices, but this one seems to have been made specifically for me.

http://www.thumlerstumbler.com/vibratory.html
Wow, what a jump... Going from no tumbler to one that $300+. That looks like a good tumbler. If I had known you were willing to spend so much I would have suggested a Dillon CV-750 which doesn't cost what the UV-10 costs.

I don't know anyone with a Thumler's Tumbler but I wish you luck...
 
Does anyone have experience with the Frankford Arsenal vibratory tumblers for $34? Will they clean less than 100 pieces of brass and will it last a while?
 
Does anyone have experience with the Frankford Arsenal vibratory tumblers for $34? Will they clean less than 100 pieces of brass and will it last a while?

Mine has worked ok. They will clean less than 100. It has lasted over a year but I don't use it much anymore.
 
Last edited:
Just a note, a store can list any price they want if the produce isn't in stock. (like Midway)

Yep, but once they accept the order, the price is fixed. Midway is out of stock for the UV-10. I had an interesting discussion with the support people at Thumbler's, who tell me the noise will be what you typically hear from a refrigerator - nothing to worry about. They have already sent their shipment to Midway, so everything will work out fine.

I'm spending next week with a relative, and he's determined to go to Harbour Freight to buy one. I'll come along with him, but won't interfere.
 
I figure with most things, you get what you pay for. Both Thumbler's and Dillon are known for taking good care of their customers.

NO! Value for $$$$$$ spent is the deciding factor.

Friend of mine bought a 6 week old car with less than 500 miles on it for $10.00.
I purchased a NEW Kimber S/S for $400.00
I purchased a NEW unfired Springfield S/S for $300.00.

The price of an item is far from the deciding what the value is.

Wish you good luck with your purchase.
 
Does anyone have experience with the Frankford Arsenal vibratory tumblers for $34? Will they clean less than 100 pieces of brass and will it last a while?

For the cost, it's a good machine. There are better out there but the price is higher.

I have an inverted medium sized kitchen funnel in mine - I didn't like the idea of the bare threaded rod in the center & figured that might scuff up the cases I was trying to make pretty. It works well & the funnel really helped give it better 'cascade action' which improved cleaning times. I leave it in the garage and it's noisier compared to better machines. But it works just fine & has been in service for 3 yrs or so. Gets a lot of use & so far no issues. I also epoxied the wing nut to the flat washer for simplification.
 
+1 on Thumblers. I also have a RCBS Sidewinder. Thumblers and rotary's are quiet but slower than the vib jobs but the brass looks better to me.
 
NO! Value for $$$$$$ spent is the deciding factor.......The price of an item is far from the deciding what the value is.


So, if I could go into Harbour Freight, and buy their tumbler for $10, that is better than spending a lot more money for what people consider a much better tumbler?

If I was buying a new car, and was considering a Mercedes for $50,000 and someone offered me a brand new Chevrolet for $10,000, which should I get?


Value for money spent is important if one is on a budget, but if not, why not buy what people consider "one of the best" or "what they really want"?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't have unlimited $$$; far from it. But over time, I've learned to buy many things by "quality", not by "price".

What's left of my hand tools is mostly SnapOn, Mac, and Craftsman. None of them were cheap, and I still have and use them. My "cheap" tools eventually wore out or broke.

Back to tumblers, my criteria came down to "small", "quiet", and "quality". Given the choice, I would prefer "Made in the USA". Given the choice, I would FAR prefer to buy from a company that completely supports their products (as in RCBS and Dillon). Any time I had a Craftsman or SnapOn tool that had a problem, it was swapped out for a new one at no charge. My "cheap" tools usually broke or wore out.....
 
I started out in an apartment. I was asked a couple times what that noise was. I only ever tumbled out on the back patio. I'd say, "oh, yeah, sorry. That must have been my air compressor. No? Oh, maybe your talking about my belt sander. No? Oh.... that! That's my ROCK tumbler." It was more a curiosity than complaint. I DO use my air compressor and belt sander quite a bit, and they ARE quite loud. But no one ever asked me about THOSE noises, only the noise of the tumbler!

I would strongly recommend you do not tumble cases indoors. In the very least, keep the lid on there tight, and only fill or empty it outside.

I give a +1 on the Berry's tumbler.

If you're intent on keeping all operations indoors, for noise reasons, I would probably try wet tumbling.
 
Last edited:
If I was buying a new car, and was considering a Mercedes for $50,000 and someone offered me a brand new Chevrolet for $10,000, which should I get?

Being as they both rust out in less than 10 years here where I live I sure would buy the Chevy.
 
Maybe you'll read it this time.

NO! Value for $$$$$$ spent is the deciding factor.

Friend of mine bought a 6 week old car with less than 500 miles on it for $10.00.

How's that for value?
 
Maybe a minor gripe but I actually mislead myself to believe the Rebel 17 was made in the USA. Some English chap during a You Tube Review said "from the USA", not necessarily Made in the USA. It isn't - it's Made in China. Ugg....I try to not buy Chinese stuff!!

That said, I used mine very heavily for almost 10 days straight with five pound batches almost every batch. Still works great and still quiet.
 
You drive a Rolls?

Naw, a Rolls Royce is no fun to drive. I used to drive Corvettes, but now I've got an MX-5. I enjoy it more than the Corvettes, for lots of reasons.

Value for money. I won't argue with you, but I'd rather buy what I really want (as long as I can afford it). I'm tired of trying to buy lesser products, to save some money, and a year or two later wishing I had spent a bit more.


Hey, I'd have bought that car too - and turned around and sold it. Making a profit is always good. But enjoying things???? Do you buy guns you want to own, or guns that are cheap? :)


As to noise, I watched the video on the Thumbler, and talked to the people who make them. As they put it, the noise is like what you hear from a refrigerator. Did you watch the video I posted way up at the beginning of this thread?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGGXz_s4Aww
Skip ahead to 3 minutes into the video, with the top on. If I put the thing on something soft, I suspect it will be even quieter.
 
Hey, I'd have bought that car too - and turned around and sold it. Making a profit is always good. But enjoying things???? Do you buy guns you want to own, or guns that are cheap? :)

LOL, Not if you were a Spc 4 in the Army stationed at the Pentagon just married to a gal working at the FBI, and needing it for her to drive back & forth to work.

BTW, I'm a former Corvette owner, no longer have the need to impress anyone. I used mine as a show car in stock class, still have the trophy's. 1972, last year of the chrome bumpers front & REAR.

I buy guns, that is rifles and handguns, no shotguns "personal reasons", mostly target rifles. Collection nearing the 2nd century mark. One is appraised into 5 figures. So ya, I buy what I want, but then my collection makes money, not my Berry tumbler. There is a difference. Corvette was the same, only car I ever owned that did not cost me a penny to own. It was an excellent value.
 
Does anyone have experience with the Frankford Arsenal vibratory tumblers for $34? Will they clean less than 100 pieces of brass and will it last a while?
I haven't used anything else to compare it against but mine seems to work fine. Don't know if it was $34 but it was inexpensive. Mine usually runs 4+ hours a week and it is still going after 2 years.
Never counted cases but I do probably 300 9mm or 200 45 in mine at a time.

Thinking about stepping up to wet tumbling, Those pristine clean primer pockets are pretty.:)
 
......1972, last year of the chrome bumpers front & REAR......

I had a white '72, with the big engine. I probably should have kept it, but that's ancient history now. I can have just as much fun in the MX-5, probably more, at a fraction of the cost.

I'm retired. I don't want to spend more than I should, but I'm no longer in the game of trying to make money. My real goal, is to consistently put 15 or 20 rounds into a 3" group, at 15 yards. I keep getting "closer", but I'm not there yet.....
 
Mike, I share your thoughts on buying quality. I think you will be happy with your choice, and would like to hear your opinion about it after you use it. If noise is an issue, something like a bathmat placed under it will quieten it down.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top