No question that they are great guns and reliable operators. There's also no question that they are big and heavy -- even the P1 can be a load, despite its alloy frame. Chopping off a P1's barrel would work, I guess, but there are better alternatives. If you like Walthers, try the new PPS -- a great gun. Or try the PP Sport, which packs plenty of punch as well. Heck, there's nothing wrong with the tried-and-true PPK/S. I carry one every day.