Walther PPQ VS Smith M&P VS Sig 2022

[kendp]

I have the S&W M&P Pro .40. It is probably the best pistol I have fired. I bought it primarily for the 4 lb trigger pull, the 5" barrel and the mag release. I am 65 and have a little arthritis in my thumb. Tried some of the other pistols (specially the Glock) and couldn't release the mag. The M&P is extremely accurate, easy on the hands, less kick-back, and very reliable. The only concern I have is when you slam the new mag home during a speed reload, it releases the slide and chambers a round, even if your not ready for it. I have a custom Colt Commander 1991A1 .45 that is a real tack driver. Not sure which one I like shooting best.

 

[ScarLata]

Because the trigger and grip I prefer the PPQ.

 

[DAdams]

I have the FS and compact MP I prefer my Walther P99AS.
I have held the SIG but it didn't make my ergo cut.
I do like the feel of the smaller HK.

 

[sheephearder]

I prefer the Walther and Sig over the S&W. I have a Sig 2022 in 40 and a P99QA in 9MM and had a M&P 40c and friends with M&P full size in 9 and 40.

Recently I down sized when we moved to Los Vegas and kept the Walther and Sig as well as a Glock 21. This is a personal preference but for me the M&P is not a gun that will stay in my collection.

 

[don quixote]

One thing about the Walther Style... don't slap the mag in while the gun is in a holster.... not good for the release...