Carbon_15
Member
I'm considering buying either an m4 style Ar-15 or an M1 Carbine...but I would be happy to hear all suggestion, I could have over looked something. I already have an AK and SKS so I have that base covered. This new rifle is just going to be a range plinker toy and I have a $1k upper limit. I have owned ar's in the past, but have never shot an M1 Carbine, so give me some details about how it shoots. Does it feel like a pistol caliber carbine?
AR-15 Pros
1. Easy to mount and quick detach optics
2. Cooler looking
3. Modular (from reddot/m4 to 24in bullbarrel/high power scope, to pistol caliber in seconds)
4. lots of accessories
5. accurate and flat shooting
Ar-15 Cons
1. Lots of Accessories
2. Expensive
3. too trendy/popular
4. a pain to clean, lots of nooks and cranys
5. complicated, lots of small parts
Carbine Pros
1. CHEAPER, leaving enough money in the $1k budget for a new handgun and case of ammo
2. lighter
3. not as trendy/ubertactical
4. no aftermarket necessities for me to go overboard on
5. easier to clean
6. the wife wants one
Carbine cons
1. relativly weak caliber
2. not as cool looking
3. no optics
4. not modular, what you see is what you get.
5. I already have lots of rifles with wood and blued steel
AR-15 Pros
1. Easy to mount and quick detach optics
2. Cooler looking
3. Modular (from reddot/m4 to 24in bullbarrel/high power scope, to pistol caliber in seconds)
4. lots of accessories
5. accurate and flat shooting
Ar-15 Cons
1. Lots of Accessories
2. Expensive
3. too trendy/popular
4. a pain to clean, lots of nooks and cranys
5. complicated, lots of small parts
Carbine Pros
1. CHEAPER, leaving enough money in the $1k budget for a new handgun and case of ammo
2. lighter
3. not as trendy/ubertactical
4. no aftermarket necessities for me to go overboard on
5. easier to clean
6. the wife wants one
Carbine cons
1. relativly weak caliber
2. not as cool looking
3. no optics
4. not modular, what you see is what you get.
5. I already have lots of rifles with wood and blued steel
Last edited: