Why was the bob tail created for a 1911?
Well now there is an idea in fact after you bobtail it then you can shorten the barrel down to 1" then make a 3 round magazine oh and re engineer it out of light weight alloy and put ultra thin grips on it too, then finish the gun off with a nice melt downI've seen lots of bobtail commanders, but has anybody bobtailed a compact 1911?
Id like to see a "before and after" of a bobtail or rounding job.. I take it this is usually done by a specialist/smith?? Is bobtailing so specific that you can buy aftermarket grips already "bobtailed", that will fit, or once you have your gun done you have to have any grips custom made there after?? Just a few questions from a noob.. Thanks!!
__________________
Mick
IMO just because some gun smith could. People can say all they want about printing and ccw and everything else but ultimately thats because they could. I think it makes the gun look silly. again its just IMO. After all it worked fine for almost 100 years with out bobtails right?
Just because JMB didn't do it doesn't make it a bad idea. JMB wasn't particularly concerned with building a handgun to wear under a Tommy Bahama shirt......
Your opinion is incorrect. It wasn't just so a gunsmith could, it was specifically designed to drop the harsh corner off, and if you had any experience carrying one against the other you would notice a HUGE difference in concealability. It's not a matter of opinion, it's a solid fact. I'm much less concerned about the appearance of my carry gun than its function, but hey, we all have our own priorities. As far as working for 100 years, the bobtail has been around a while, has proven to cause 0 issues and it is a simple fact that they conceal better.IMO just because some gun smith could. People can say all they want about printing and ccw and everything else but ultimately thats because they could. I think it makes the gun look silly. again its just IMO. After all it worked fine for almost 100 years with out bobtails right?
False. While there are more concerns with critical tolerances and tensions, you do not automatically run into issues with 3-3.5" 1911s. They can be more finicky, but my 3" Kimber with a round count over 7k has never had a failure of any kind.you start running into reliability issues when you take the barrel or the 1911 platform shorter than 4.25".
The reason this can't be done is that the bobtail is actually based on the officer's MSH. All the bobtail internals are officers parts.has anybody bobtailed a compact 1911?
Quote:
you start running into reliability issues when you take the barrel or the 1911 platform shorter than 4.25".
False. While there are more concerns with critical tolerances and tensions , you do not automatically run into issues with 3-3.5" 1911s. They can be more finicky , but my 3" Kimber with a round count over 7k has never had a failure of any kind.
I was simply pointing out that just because it's a compact you don't automatically run into reliability issues. Almost all compact run just fine. Those that have issues can be tuned into reliability and yes, you are correct, there is more chance in having a critical tolerance slightly off causing an issue than with a gov't length ones. But the unreliability of compacts is greatly overstated.how about: you are more likely to have issues as they are more finicky as to tolerences and tensions
JMB wasn't particularly concerned with building a handgun to wear under a Tommy Bahama shirt......
Hehehe.I could carry a Doberman in one of those shirts and nobody would know.
Hehehe.
Prove it!