barnbwt
member
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2011
- Messages
- 7,340
Howdy from Texas,
I've been looking for a good trail revolver to take with me for some decent bear protection (I know, .44's are even better for this job) that won't weigh as much as the rest of my pack. Light weight, maximum firepower, and a medium-large frame/barrel size are the features I'm most interested in.
Though these features sort of contradict eachother, I've found two possible candidates so far; The S&W 327 (TR)R8, and the Chiappa Rhino 50DS (I know, I know...)
The concept of an eight shot magnum with a light full size frame is very compelling, plus it's a S&W performace center item with high quality parts. It's pretty much guaranteed (actually it is) to be a rock-solid dependable gun.
However, the six shot Rhino appears capable of delivering faster followup shots with greater accuracy due to its low barrel configuration. But it's internals appear more complicated, and some quality control issues have been raised as Chiappa ramps up production. As much as I like the neo-Mateba Rhino concept (I really do) I'm not sure if the 400 bucks I could save over the 327 is worth the potential for hassles.
I believe both weigh in just above 30 oz unloaded, and both have 5" barrels (a balance between weight and accuracy I really like). Please feel free to weigh in on either of these options or to suggest other similar revolvers.
I've had a chance to inspect a 4" Rhino at a local store, and I didn't personally find any of the trigger/DA issues raised by some reviewers. It seemed a very well made gun with better ergonomics than the Ruger GP100 and S&W 686 I also checked out. That said, the fact it's a new design, with more internal parts, and made by a fast-growing manufacturer makes me pause
Thanks
I've been looking for a good trail revolver to take with me for some decent bear protection (I know, .44's are even better for this job) that won't weigh as much as the rest of my pack. Light weight, maximum firepower, and a medium-large frame/barrel size are the features I'm most interested in.
Though these features sort of contradict eachother, I've found two possible candidates so far; The S&W 327 (TR)R8, and the Chiappa Rhino 50DS (I know, I know...)
The concept of an eight shot magnum with a light full size frame is very compelling, plus it's a S&W performace center item with high quality parts. It's pretty much guaranteed (actually it is) to be a rock-solid dependable gun.
However, the six shot Rhino appears capable of delivering faster followup shots with greater accuracy due to its low barrel configuration. But it's internals appear more complicated, and some quality control issues have been raised as Chiappa ramps up production. As much as I like the neo-Mateba Rhino concept (I really do) I'm not sure if the 400 bucks I could save over the 327 is worth the potential for hassles.
I believe both weigh in just above 30 oz unloaded, and both have 5" barrels (a balance between weight and accuracy I really like). Please feel free to weigh in on either of these options or to suggest other similar revolvers.
I've had a chance to inspect a 4" Rhino at a local store, and I didn't personally find any of the trigger/DA issues raised by some reviewers. It seemed a very well made gun with better ergonomics than the Ruger GP100 and S&W 686 I also checked out. That said, the fact it's a new design, with more internal parts, and made by a fast-growing manufacturer makes me pause
Thanks