Which handgun to choose?

Status
Not open for further replies.
First off, welcome to THR! We are glad we can be of assistance, but do take everything we say with a grain of salt. You are doing all the right things - trying stuff out for yourself before you buy.

And yes, http://www.corneredcat.com/ is a fantastic resource, for men and women alike.

I'm not sure which gun that I want to get first, the CCW gun or my practice/home protection gun.

As for the cost of the 45 rounds, I'm not too concerned and know that I will end up buying at least two guns anyway.

Actually, I count 3 guns in there :evil: :p ! Perhaps 4, I could go on and on :D .

Cheap practice: Unless you are a millionaire, nothing beats a 22 for cheap, fun practice. Any 22 would be fine: semi auto or revolver (double or single action). I have but one 22, however I enjoy them so much that I'd like to add more. Even though I reload my own, there is something truly care free about shooting ammo that costs only $10 for 550 rounds from Wallie World.

Home protection: For now, your trail gun and home defense gun can do double duty. The autos you have listed will work great for either role, as will a 357 revolver. Later, you can get something a little more specialized for home defense. Size doesn't really matter here, so your options open up a lot. Of course, it should be a gun you are comfortable and confident with. I'm not sure what your housing situation is, but a shotgun of some type is tough to beat for home protection. 12 and 20 gauge are the most common, but there are other options as well. Shotguns, particularly pumps, can be picked up for very reasonable prices used. For example, I recently saw a nice used Mossberg 500 20 ga (18.5" barrel) for $150. Shotguns are far more powerful than any handgun, and though they still must be aimed they are a lot easier to hit a target with.

Trail/Hiking: As I said, for now this can be the same gun as your home protection choice. Weight can be a concern for hiking. Then again, a good quality belt and holster has a way of making the weight of a heavier handgun (such as an all steel 4-6" barrel 357 revolver) disappear.

Concealed carry: Depending on the size and weight of your trail and/or home protection gun, it could also serve you well as a concealed carry piece. Though eventually, most people seem to get a dedicated, small, easy to carry piece to encourage daily carry whenever legal. Packing a monster handgun becomes a chore for many people, so they stop carrying. I pack a 5" 1911 from time-to-time, but I carry my little S&W 642 the vast majority of the time. A small Kel-Tec in 32 ACP or a 38 snubnose revolver that goes with you everywhere beats a big burly 45 or 357 at home every time.

So as I said, that could mean up to 4 different guns. See, once you become a gun nut like us, the number will just keep getting bigger :evil: . Look, it went from 3 to 4 in my own post!!! When I started out, I said I only neeeded two. Refer to my signature line below...
 
Shoot as many more as you can, find the one that fits you then do a search for reliability and other issues. Find the caliber and platform that is for you.
Good luck in your search.
 
Play_Hard said:
In your post you said, "If you like the G21, you might look at the G21SF. It’s a slimmer frame, and has a reversible magazine catch." I did want to try this out to compare, but the shop didn't have this to shoot. When you say "reversible magazine catch" do you mean that as being suitable for both left and right handed shooters? ?
That would be yes, on the Mag catch. Actually, I can’t remember if it ambidextrous, or reversible, but I do know that it can be on the right, or left side of the frame. This article says it’s ambi;

http://www.officer.com/web/online/On-the-Street/Glock-21-SF/21$37241

Play_Hard said:
Also, do you know from experience how this compares to the Glock 21? That is in handling and recoil
Haven’t shot it, but have handled it. It fit my hands better than the G21 (which was a tad big for my hands). You should really check out Glocktalk forums for that answer. There are people there (as well as here) with much more knowledge than myself.
 
Okay, I ended up getting the Glock 21SF. I really had a hard time because I did like the M&P and Springfield. Many of you gave me great feedback regarding the Glock 21. Also, part of my decision came down to the fact that I have read Glocks are very reliable , easy to find accessories for and a very simple gun to clean/take apart.

This will not be the last gun I buy, after many of your suggestions I am looking into a .357 revolver for carry/conceal. I need to go out and shoot my Glock this weekend, I bought 100 rounds, so I am excited.

Thanks to all of you guys who gave me such great suggestions, I really appreciate it!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top