I don't believe that this gun is better for HD for most people than a standard 18" gun with a stock. I don't view general home defense as the role for these guns. That isn't to say one couldn't use one for such. For those who don't want to spend a lot, a standard pump can be had for about $200 less. You stated that some may not "even shot (sic) it very much." Based on my experience shooting SBSs (which is an approximation of this gun) I don't know that it would be better for folks that don't shoot much. It also certainly is not an egalitarian weapon and unless a person possesses a certain amount of strength to proficiently uses the push pull technique best suited to these guns.
I'll tell you what though. We could debate it on here for weeks and you could take cute little shots at me the whole time but I don't know that would be very interesting or help either of us be more informed. How about this, we each buy one this weekend (they are pretty dang cheap), shoot a couple hundred rounds to acquaint ourselves with them, we decide on a number of drills that we believe would be representative of things relevant to HD. We shoot those drills on shot timer with the shock wave. We then shoot them with some other shotguns (I have at least 5 that might be interesting to compare). That should give some actual interesting data and then we both could actually have something to base what we are saying on.
My hypothesis is that splits will be universally shorter with the stocked weapons and prove easier to use for most people.
Oh wait, your state overlords will not let you own one so I guess your experience will continue to remain non existent. Although, I suppose you could get a stamp and we could do it in 9 months (that's how long my last stamp took) In the alternative, you could buy an 18" gun and run a bird heads grip and it would give you an idea.
What do you say? It would be fun and would only cost $600 or so for the gun and ammo to do it.
I'll tell you what though. We could debate it on here for weeks and you could take cute little shots at me the whole time but I don't know that would be very interesting or help either of us be more informed. How about this, we each buy one this weekend (they are pretty dang cheap), shoot a couple hundred rounds to acquaint ourselves with them, we decide on a number of drills that we believe would be representative of things relevant to HD. We shoot those drills on shot timer with the shock wave. We then shoot them with some other shotguns (I have at least 5 that might be interesting to compare). That should give some actual interesting data and then we both could actually have something to base what we are saying on.
My hypothesis is that splits will be universally shorter with the stocked weapons and prove easier to use for most people.
Oh wait, your state overlords will not let you own one so I guess your experience will continue to remain non existent. Although, I suppose you could get a stamp and we could do it in 9 months (that's how long my last stamp took) In the alternative, you could buy an 18" gun and run a bird heads grip and it would give you an idea.
What do you say? It would be fun and would only cost $600 or so for the gun and ammo to do it.