The XDm-10 (A Short Review)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Havok7416

Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2012
Messages
3,642
Location
Kentucky
As many of you are likely already aware, I recently ordered one of the new Springfield XDm-10 4.5" pistols as mentioned in this thread. I placed my order the day after the gun was announced from Sportsman's Outdoors, picking the smaller gun of the two options. The gun arrived at my local FFL in about a week. As mentioned in the linked thread, due to my early order date I ended up with serial number 520 of the 10mm series. More pictures will follow, but for now I just have 2.

Getting the gun out of the box for the first time, the first thing I noticed was how well oiled it was and how tight the foam was cut. The gun seemed to be practically welded into the box. The 4.5" version that I have comes with two 15-round magazines that fit semi-flush to the frame. The 5.25" version apparently comes with three 15-round magazines although I'm not sure why. There are 2 extra backstraps that also come with the gun, but I haven't experimented with them yet.

On my gun there is a red fiber optic front sight and 2 white dots at the rear in a low profile configuration. I would have liked to see green fiber optics for the rear sights, but the sight picture works well enough as made.

The trigger is better than I remember for a stock XD. I used to own an XD9 years ago and I currently own an XD9-5.25, but that was configured as a competition gun by the previous owner, with a heavily modified trigger so I have little to directly compare to there. I would estimate the 10mm trigger pull to be between 5-6lb which is good enough for me that I won't be spending money or time to tweak it.

I finally got the gun to the range Monday morning but I had to put it to the side initially because I promised to help a friend work on his shooting. I finally got the XDm out and intended to do accuracy testing, but unfortunately I failed to communicate this to my friend and he promptly dumped a bunch of rounds into the fresh target. I will go back out soon to redo that part of my test.

Even though I can't yet prove it with pictures, the gun is very accurate and controllable. I brought a hodgepodge of rounds to the range to test with - coated SWC, plated and JHP - just to make sure the gun would truly eat everything. No hiccups or problems of any kind that can be traced back to the gun or ammo. There was however, a rather amusing failure on my end. When I loaded the magazines, I did so by grabbing a handful of bullets at a time in no particular order. This resulted in the first few rounds of the magazine being inadvertantly loaded with my SWC rounds, which are loaded much more lightly than the others. So when I fired the first few shots the gun seemed ridiculously manageable. It wasn't until the 6th or 7th round fired that I finally got to a JHP in the magazine and it was surprising to say the least! When that round was fired (and all subsequent full-power rounds) I noticed that the grip texture dug into my hand a bit. Not enough to do any harm, but I do think it contributed to better control in the end.

One thing I noticed and appreciated as I was loading the magazines was the internal space they had. I have been having some trouble with some of my reloads in 10mm and recently traced the issue back to the completed rounds being too long. They all chamber and fire just fine, but I was unable to fill a magazine full on my other 10mm guns. The XD however had no such problems getting these rounds in the magazine. I will say though that the magazine springs on the XD are some of the stiffest I have run across in a long time. Even using an UpLula mag loader I struggled to get the last few rounds in. I'm sure with time this will correct itself, but in the meantime it will be quite a workout.

I intend to follow up here with more pictures and comments on the gun when I am to get back out to the range.
20181018_221754.jpg 20181018_152931.jpg
 
Curious... how does the recoil feel compared to a .45acp, or to a 9mm?

I really like the xDM series—my son has a 4.5” 9mm that is a great shooter.
 
Don't forget to fill out the info for their promotion. They'll send you 3 more magazines and a range bag. It can be done through their web site and only takes a couple of minutes, so they made it easy.
 
Congrats! The XD isn't my thing, I prefer the Glock, but I am always happy to welcome another 10mm to the fold!

What kind of recoil system do they put in it? Is it a dual recoil spring assembly or a single? Do they put a ridiculously light recoil spring in it like the Glock? The Gen III Glocks came with the same recoil assembly as the .45, so mine only had a 17 lbs spring in it. Slide velocity was so fast that it got snappy and would launch empties 30 feet when I shot full power loads, which was a concern for me, because all I shoot is full power loads. So I ended up putting a stainless rod with a 20# ISMI on it in my G20 and it runs much smoother.

Anyways, congrats, once again. Enjoy!
 
I won a 9mm XDm 4.5 a few weeks ago haven't tried it out yet and really don't know what I'm going to do with it long term.
 
Curious... how does the recoil feel compared to a .45acp, or to a 9mm?

I really like the xDM series—my son has a 4.5” 9mm that is a great shooter.
Recoil is definitely more stout than a .45 or a 9mm. My other XDm as mentioned is the 5.25 version and it has been worked on extensively to include a different recoil spring, so the recoil on that gun is extremely soft. This keeps from a direct comparison, but I do have a S&W 1006 and an IAI Javelina (7" 10mm 1911) and the XD recoils more sharply than both of those. That said, it is still very manageable.

Don't forget to fill out the info for their promotion. They'll send you 3 more magazines and a range bag. It can be done through their web site and only takes a couple of minutes, so they made it easy.
Already done. According to the website it will take 6-8 weeks to receive the gear. I did this awhile back when I bought a Springfield 1911 (4 free mags, a holster and mag carrier) and it also took about 6 weeks if I remember right.

Congrats! The XD isn't my thing, I prefer the Glock, but I am always happy to welcome another 10mm to the fold!

What kind of recoil system do they put in it? Is it a dual recoil spring assembly or a single? Do they put a ridiculously light recoil spring in it like the Glock? The Gen III Glocks came with the same recoil assembly as the .45, so mine only had a 17 lbs spring in it. Slide velocity was so fast that it got snappy and would launch empties 30 feet when I shot full power loads, which was a concern for me, because all I shoot is full power loads. So I ended up putting a stainless rod with a 20# ISMI on it in my G20 and it runs much smoother.

Anyways, congrats, once again. Enjoy!
The recoil spring assembly is single and non-captive. I went ahead and called Springfield to ask what the weight of the spring is. They told me they "don't have a poundage on the spring at this time". Further, they do not have any extra springs to buy (not that I was looking for one). This was pretty shocking to me as I thought they must have engineered that in there somewhere, but I guess not. The gun does put empties in flight, but since I was shooting at an indoor range they ended up bouncing around the stall. According to my friend, they were hitting the right wall at about head height, then richocheting over to the left wall and bouncing from there back to the floor behind me. Based on that I would say this gun would throw empties pretty far without a barrier to knock them down. The silver lining to me is the low angle of ejection - my 1006 and Javelina both toss brass on a high angle arc to the right that typically clears the barriers at indoor ranges and ends up several lanes away if they are found at all.
20181025_144114.jpg 20181025_144126.jpg 20181025_144129.jpg 20181025_144155.jpg 20181025_144203.jpg
 
Recoil is definitely more stout than a .45 or a 9mm. My other XDm as mentioned is the 5.25 version and it has been worked on extensively to include a different recoil spring, so the recoil on that gun is extremely soft. This keeps from a direct comparison, but I do have a S&W 1006 and an IAI Javelina (7" 10mm 1911) and the XD recoils more sharply than both of those. That said, it is still very manageable.


Already done. According to the website it will take 6-8 weeks to receive the gear. I did this awhile back when I bought a Springfield 1911 (4 free mags, a holster and mag carrier) and it also took about 6 weeks if I remember right.


The recoil spring assembly is single and non-captive. I went ahead and called Springfield to ask what the weight of the spring is. They told me they "don't have a poundage on the spring at this time". Further, they do not have any extra springs to buy (not that I was looking for one). This was pretty shocking to me as I thought they must have engineered that in there somewhere, but I guess not. The gun does put empties in flight, but since I was shooting at an indoor range they ended up bouncing around the stall. According to my friend, they were hitting the right wall at about head height, then richocheting over to the left wall and bouncing from there back to the floor behind me. Based on that I would say this gun would throw empties pretty far without a barrier to knock them down. The silver lining to me is the low angle of ejection - my 1006 and Javelina both toss brass on a high angle arc to the right that typically clears the barriers at indoor ranges and ends up several lanes away if they are found at all.
View attachment 809053 View attachment 809054 View attachment 809055 View attachment 809056 View attachment 809057
Sounds very promising!
 
I got to the range the other day and intended to do accuracy testing with the gun but there were competing interests in play. Normally I bring a bunch of guns, but this time I only brought the XD. I have a bunch of ammo as previously mentioned which won't work in some of my other 10mms guns (it's easier to shoot it off), so I brought the whole ammo can. This turned out to be a mistake as I left my UpLula behind - which had some un-fun consequences.

I had some other things to do later in the day so I limited myself to 1 hour which resulted in a bit of a scramble later on.

My first target looked like crap, so I kept trying. I should have stuck with that target; due to me not having my UpLula, I ended up trying to fight the rounds into the magazines. This caused me to quickly develop a large and painful blister on my trigger finger, which in turn caused my groups to open up substantially. I did finally manage the below group at 10 yards. Shots were approximately 1-2 per second. A total of 60 rounds (4 mags) were fired in this string (and yes, I'm aware it's not terribly impressive). Hopefully I will be able to get a true test in once my finger heals.
20181029_133541.jpg
 
I would assume the G20 and XDm10 are about equal in felt recoil being that they are the same approximate size. Even if one has an edge I'm sure things could be evened up with a change of springs.

The 1006 with its steel frame keeps recoil to a minimum. I can't see a polymer gun of any type matching it.
 
He said it recoils more sharply than 1006 meaning it's worse than Gen 4 G20.
The 1006 with its steel frame keeps recoil to a minimum. I can't see a polymer gun of any type matching it.
I've only shot my P220 in 10mm, not either poly gun. But none the less, I agree. I don't see how any poly gun could mitigate recoil better than an all steel gun. The weight difference alone would do it. Though maybe the G20 slide is considerably lighter.

Would be interesting to do a side by side.
 
Last edited:
I've shot G20's (and a G29) and several steel 10mm's. One can feel the frame flex in the G20, and, depending on your hands and grip, some people find that flexing reduces the feeling of a "smack" against the hand. But the overall movement of the gun is more with the Glock... there's simply no way around the math.
 
I had a 1006 and currently have a P220, Glock 20 and the XDM. The recoil I felt with the 1006 and P220 were comparable, and were much less than the 20 or XDM. I'm assuming the weight of the guns have something to do with it. To me the XDM has slightly more felt recoil than the 20, but the difference is not significant enough to make that the deciding factor of picking one over the other. The 20 is up for sale on Armslist, as I shoot the XDM so much better due to the larger grip of the 20 not working for me.
 
I had a 1006 and currently have a P220, Glock 20 and the XDM. The recoil I felt with the 1006 and P220 were comparable, and were much less than the 20 or XDM. I'm assuming the weight of the guns have something to do with it. To me the XDM has slightly more felt recoil than the 20, but the difference is not significant enough to make that the deciding factor of picking one over the other. The 20 is up for sale on Armslist, as I shoot the XDM so much better due to the larger grip of the 20 not working for me.
Ignoring capacity, of all the 10mms you've shot, which do you like best?
I've shot G20's (and a G29) and several steel 10mm's. One can feel the frame flex in the G20, and, depending on your hands and grip, some people find that flexing reduces the feeling of a "smack" against the hand. But the overall movement of the gun is more with the Glock... there's simply no way around the math.
dod you shoot any hot loads out of that G29? Was it pretty controllable?

I've been thinking about a G29 but I'm curious if SA will release a 3.8" 10mm. If so, I'd really prefer that over s Glock. They just feel better in the hand to me.
 
Ignoring capacity, of all the 10mms you've shot, which do you like best?

The Tanfoglios. That's why those are the ones I own!

did you shoot any hot loads out of that G29? Was it pretty controllable?

I'm not a Glock fan in general, but I was straight-up shocked at how tolerable it was. We were shooting stuff that wasn't at the top of the range, but pretty spicy. The kind of ammo that definitely feels like "real" 10mm ammo, not just 40 in a longer case. I expected it to be as unpleasant as shooting .357 magnum ammo in a J-frame. It wasn't. I wasn't doing any kind of timed drills, and I wasn't trying to run the gun hard, so I couldn't confidently say how it was really performing, but it sucked far less than I expected.

Compact 10mm's are of minimal interest to me, so I haven't really explored this further, and couldn't compare to any other cut-down 10's. If I'm carrying a 10, I'm going to carry something I can shoot pretty well... after all, the reason is usually that I'm in the woods/mountains and want to be able to deal with a black bear or the like... and I want a good sight radius.
 
Ignoring capacity, of all the 10mms you've shot, which do you like best?

dod you shoot any hot loads out of that G29? Was it pretty controllable?

I've been thinking about a G29 but I'm curious if SA will release a 3.8" 10mm. If so, I'd really prefer that over s Glock. They just feel better in the hand to me.

For me the P220 is the best shooter out of the group. The felt recoil with full power loads is no worse than a 1911 chambered in 45. The 1006 in SA is a close second, followed by the XDM and the 20. I had a 29 for a while but couldn't shoot it well for the same reason the 20 isn't a fit for me.
 
The Tanfoglios. That's why those are the ones I own!
Thanks ATLDave. I keep looking for one to try on but they just never show up in my area. Not wild about ordering blind though I can resell it I guess if I'm not a fan.

I've handled 5.25" XDms several times now and they fit me decently. Glocks, meh. But I play in the woods a lot so a higher cap 10 is appealing.

A compact sounds very appealing also. I hike quite a bit but live in a tourist area. So concealment saves me headaches, and a little more power in a concealable package is desireable.
 
Thanks ATLDave. I keep looking for one to try on but they just never show up in my area. Not wild about ordering blind though I can resell it I guess if I'm not a fan.

I've handled 5.25" XDms several times now and they fit me decently. Glocks, meh. But I play in the woods a lot so a higher cap 10 is appealing.

A compact sounds very appealing also. I hike quite a bit but live in a tourist area. So concealment saves me headaches, and a little more power in a concealable package is desireable.
If you blind order an EAA Witness Compact in 10mm and don't like it, I'm sure we can work something out! They have had them on and off in my area but I haven't bought one yet. They hold 13 rounds with a 3.5 inch barrel - seems like a good package to me!
 
If you blind order an EAA Witness Compact in 10mm and don't like it, I'm sure we can work something out! They have had them on and off in my area but I haven't bought one yet. They hold 13 rounds with a 3.5 inch barrel - seems like a good package to me!
Yep I've wondered about those for some time. I'm actually really interested in the full size Witness with wood grips and blued, DA/SA trigger. They have a full length dust cover and look like the Hunters but chopped down and not SAO.

None the less, I'll keep your words in mind on the compact.
 
I have a full size Witness in .45 and .22 as well as an IMI Baby Eagle in .45 and they are both easy to shoot. I looked into the 10mm conversion for the Witness more than a few times, but since I already own several guns in 10mm and with the XD getting announced last year I held off.
 
If you blind order an EAA Witness Compact in 10mm and don't like it, I'm sure we can work something out! They have had them on and off in my area but I haven't bought one yet. They hold 13 rounds with a 3.5 inch barrel - seems like a good package to me!

I tried the polymer Witness Compact in 10mm but am having problems with the factory magazines. It came with 1 magazine and I ordered 2 more with the gun. They're supposed to be 12 round magazines, but I can only fit 11 rounds at most in them. They sometimes work if I only put 10 rounds in them, but not reliably. It seems like the follows get hung up with 10 or more rounds in them and the top round is so loose it'll fall out. The gun works great with Mec Gar 14 round magazines. I spoke to EAA and am sending the magazines back.
 
I have trouble with my Witness mags as well. In fact (and returning to the original discussion) I'm having almost the same exact problem with my XD mags. It seems as though the springs for both mag types are too long. I don't dare cut them though.

I think if I got a Witness Compact it would have to be a metal frame. Not that it would likely fix the mag spring issues.
 
I have trouble with my Witness mags as well. In fact (and returning to the original discussion) I'm having almost the same exact problem with my XD mags. It seems as though the springs for both mag types are too long. I don't dare cut them though.

I think if I got a Witness Compact it would have to be a metal frame. Not that it would likely fix the mag spring issues.
That's disappointing. I assume the mag springs are quite stiff to compensate for the stiff recoil spring?
 
I have trouble with my Witness mags as well. In fact (and returning to the original discussion) I'm having almost the same exact problem with my XD mags. It seems as though the springs for both mag types are too long. I don't dare cut them though.

I think if I got a Witness Compact it would have to be a metal frame. Not that it would likely fix the mag spring issues.

I loaded 15 rounds in my XDM mags and let them sit for a few days before shooting it and they're fine. Have you tried this? It hasn't helped the Witness.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top