Care to share any of your experiences in more detail?
I was always confident in the accuracy of my .357 handloads, and that's what I used for deer hunting. Illinois first handgun seasons were "doe only", so 100-150lb d. oes were the norm back then.
1 made a good shot but the deer ran out of the woods into an open meadow and laid down, and took forever the expire. I was afraid to approach with range for fear it would get away.
2. shot a doe almost point blank through the chest, had to track it down and shoot it again.
3,shot one as it stepped over the log I was sitting on. I managed to shoot her three or four times. Very little blood, almost gave up finding her.
4. Made a good shot on a big doe. She ran directly to the only house for a couple of miles and dutifully died in the yard.
5. and the best one....I shot a big doe about 75 yds away(yea, pretty far for open sights). She bucked and disappeared over a hill. After 20min or so I began to look for blood. None. There was snow on so I tracked footprints as far as I could. No blood. I gave it up as a miss. Later I was able to make a shot on a smaller doe. She cut a long arcing trail across the woods. While following her trail....I found the first doe that I shot earlier lying dead not too far from the second doe...also dead.
After writing these stories, I remember a few othwer .357 deer that were clean kills.
Along about this time, Illinois allowed handguns during regular gun season. Since I know first hand how hard those big bucks are to kill, I went ahead and bought a .45Colt and have been more satisfied.
I enjoy handgun hunting because of the challenge and the freedom.
On a side note, my deer hunting experiences with the .357 also led me to switch to a .45acp as a ccw instead of a .357. I went from a SP101 to a compact 1911.
Oh yea, I forgot to mention the ear-splitting blast from the .357. Two of my guns are ported, so.....wow. Earplugs.