Greywolf123
Member
What are your opinions on these. Are they good or great or whatever?
I had the same experience with some X-treme jacketed bullets. Like you, I wasn't happy with the “undersized” bullets, but they did meet SAAMI spec of .3525-.3555”. That’s the only ones I’ve had a “problem” with. All of their 9mm plated bullets that I’ve used have been .355-.3555” and +/- less than a grain from their nominal weight, dating back to well before their bankruptcy and sale to LAX. I only load about 6000 rounds a year, so my sampling is probably smaller than yours, but with the exception of Precision Delta, no other brand of plated bullets that I’ve used has been as consistent in size and weight as X-treme. My only problem with them lately is their high shipping costs makes them significantly pricier than others. But, if I needed bullets and X-treme was all that was available, I'd buy them without hesitation. ymmvI noticed that there was often a variance in bullet weight and diameter. I wrote it off to my inexperience until other reloaders I knew noticed it also. I became disenchanted with their when they brushed off a fellow reloader who complained about undersized bullets (.353-.354" 9mm slugs) with: "those are within spec"
Not to derail this thread, but you may want to consider a universal expander to prevent shaving.i like them. they used to be what i primarily shoot. now i use coated bullets from s&s and mbc. i like the 38 sp/ 357 147 gr dewc, 158 gr swc, 9 mm 147 gr RN , 45 acp 230 gr RN and 200 gr SWCS. the weights are consistent, more so than MBC. i don't get shaved off bullets unlike what happens occasionally with coated bulletswhile seating.
Once again I would buy them at Cabela's when they would have regular sales on them before the BPS buy-out.