Assuming starting from scratch….
The target guns.
S&W K17-3 triple target. This would replace grandads.
S&W K17-3 triple target. This one would be scoped. 617 may do.
The carry guns.
S&W 649, 357mag. I have one, would want a second.
S&W 649, 357mag.
I would be tempted to try a 3 inch, 6 shooter, 357mag, but honestly, I like the little 649.
Then it gets tricky.
I would want a woods, general carry gun.
I would want to shoot a 329, 4inch, light weight 44mag. IF I can shoot it well…
If not, 629, 4 inch, 44mag. If I can shoot it well, it would be my
If not, I am back to my 629, 6.5 inch.
Then a dedicated hunter.
S&W460, 7.5inch with rails, RD one, Scope a second one.
Then there is the old west...
Merwin in 44-40, never seen one for sale so…
Peacemaker set in 44-40, probably clone since I will shoot them.
Peacemaker set in 45C, probably clones since I will shoot them.