1911 in 9mm

Status
Not open for further replies.
Guess I'll have to be the first naysayer...

If you want a 1911 single stack gun that really runs and isn't just a range toy it's best to stick with .45, 10mm, or .38super, in other words the longer OAL calibers.

As an SO in IDPA I've watched guys struggle with them for years yet still I decided I had to have one, the STI Trojan 9mm seemed by all accounts to be the best of the 9mm 1911's based on pure performance and was indeed a fine gun but I found out quickly that the same kind of reliability that most 1911 shooters are willing to accept is what most Glock or CZ shooters cannot. Long story short, there's so many variables working against 9mm in the 1911 platform that it's a continuing headache if you truly are looking for real performance.

Without meaning to sound overtly condescending, if you're one of the 1911-guys who enjoys their ownership experience in terms of how well they're crafted and other intangibles like how they look and such then by all means they're fun and the nagging issues may not mean much as 9mm is cheap to shoot and great for punching paper, that said, if you really looking to shoot the thing, get it dirty and really use it then I wouldn't recommend one as there are far better choices in 9mm that will fit that role better.
 
I too have the STI Trojan, with a Wilson / Nowlin ramped barrel. So far with around 6500 rounds of hardball and 500+ rounds of various hollowpoint ammunition it has been a flawless shooter. I have watched a number of 1911 shooters in IPSC / USPSA matches struggle, most are caused by faulty and low power reloads. I so far have 2 1911s in 9mm, the STI and an older Colt MK IV series 70, now in the market for a carry 1911 in 9mm. With recoil almost a memory with a 5" 1911, 9mm is an accurate, fast shooting alternative to conventional .45 1911s. I love my .45 1911s but would much rather shoot a 9mm in a match. 1 of 2 pistols that now always make the range trip, STI Trojan 9mm and Glock G34 9mm.
 
DW PM-9

czdwpm9_03.jpg


SA EMP 9MM

saemp_02.jpg
 
I have one after MUCH deliberation! I love it and it has become one of my daily carry guns. It is a Para LTC in 9mm, the sa 1911 clone one. I just picked up a .22 1911 today, NICE! It is a GSG.

f1atgsg1911a.jpg
 
1911, 9mm

This post makes me cry. I had a 9mm Combat Commander, with 4 extra mags. Sold it years ago. Always assumed that they would just be around.
 
Guess I'll have to be the first naysayer...

If you want a 1911 single stack gun that really runs and isn't just a range toy it's best to stick with .45, 10mm, or .38super, in other words the longer OAL calibers.

Maybe its just the "high end" makers haven't figured it out. But I've a Taurus PT-1911 that I've had for about 6 weeks and run over 1300 rounds through it so far with zero failures of any kind. My only gripe is it shoots low, but I've a fiber optic insert front sight on its way from Dawson to fix the issue.

We've also had an RIA "Tactical" 1911 in 9mm for about a year that my wife has claimed for the very low recoil, great sights and trigger. Its over 3000 rounds and while this one had a few failures to go fully into battery in the first couple of hundred rounds, its been fine since.

We use the Checkmate mag that came with the RIA, the two Taurus mags and 32 of the Metalform OM from CDNN with complete interchangeability.

I'd have got a second RIA but I saw the Taurus in stainless and got it instead just to be different.

I really like the price on these as it never made sense to be to spend $900+ on a pistol who's main purpose was to enjoy the 1911 platform while shooting cheaper ammo.

We shoot mostly steel plates in informal competitions and run the guns very hard. The large number of mags is to have 300 rounds ready to go on the firing line as its way too hot to be standing around outside stuffing mags, but this means we run through the ammo as fast as we can pull the cord to reset the plates. Great fun!
 
I've had a couple low end 1911 9mm and I plan on gettin more. In my opinion, if your going to spend a lot of money on a 1911 go with a 45 but if you just want to spend a lot of money on ammo go with a 9mm. Mine have all shot and functioned flawlessly Just my opinion
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top