Short barreled 357...
Howdy. Those limited edition rifles are pretty nice and some are held as collectors items and some like mine are fired and enjoyed. I have not had a more fun to shoot gun in a great while if ever. While you lose a round or 2 of magazine capacity over a 1894c they handle, I think like a really light dream and in 357 pack a more than adequate wallop. Ammo is cheap, like all Marlins the gun is easy to maintain, while I would not define them as tackdrivers they are plenty accurate even at 100 yards.
I have committed the ultimate sacreledge (sp?) and put a 4x burris mini on mine with warne qd rings. I know, I know I am a hack, but I'm a hack with middle aged eyes that likes to hit what she's aiming at and a sucker for short leverguns in stainless. I reckon I must have been a crow in another life given I go for shiny stuff ;->)
I liked them so much that after I bought the 44 mag ltd ed. on sight, I went back a week later and bought my 357 trading in a nearly new 1894 in 44 mag that I had bought just weeks before.
In a few weeks we will have a reloading setup and things will get even less expensive. Yippee!
The Puma's are pretty nice and around here the new street price is $400. I am tempted at the 454/45lc puma. The magazine tube loading option is great, I wish Marlin had it.
I have a 16" m94 that I like a great deal but the 357 is the first thing I go for to go out and play and a 45-70/457wwg 1895 when I want to flind big thumping wads of lead at something.
Guess that makes 4 16" leverguns for me. Go for it, you won't regret it. If the budget is short get a regular 1984c chop it and hard chrome it, pretty close in looks and effect.
Patty