X42 vs M&P 340
I have both a 642 and M&P 340.
See multiple comments on the 340 discussion thread.
http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?t=282173
There are numerous photos there as-well.
The 642 is presently wearing Crimson Trace 405 laser grips. These are the smaller of the two comparable grips the slightly larger being the model 305.
There are other versions for J frames as well.
I ordered the 340 with CT 405s also as it was less expensive to purchase them together than seperately later.
My wife has adopted the 642 for hd purposes.
I have a set of Hogue Monogrips on the 340 presently.
Regardless of the .357 factor, both will handle +P well. I prefer the Buffalo Bore 158 gr 20C soft points. A good alternative is the 135 gr Speer Gold Dot. Both these are .38 and plus P rated.
If you are going to carry IWB or OWB the 13.3 ounce vs 15 won't make much difference in percieved comfort. If you plan on pocket carrying it makes a significance difference.
I also like the following in the 340:
XS sights with dot in notch and Tritium Night Sights larger dot vs blade
Lanyard post in butt (for what its worth)
Ion Bond BLACK Diamond Finish
Full underlug "look".
I am not recoil sensitive and regularly carry with the .38 +P BB. I like the option to carry .357 under certain circumstances. Speer makes the .357 round in a 135 gr short barrel version. Neither of these handguns are designed for range fun like a Buckmark .22. It's a concealed carry revolver for self defense.
I certainly don't have any problem hanging in with either with .38+P for a box of 50 and a few .357 in the mix aren't the Frankengun Monster they are made out to be. Noticeably different yes.
If the price difference doesn't overwhelm I recommend the 340 just for the light weight and versatility. I think if you purchase a 442 or 642 and find it to your liking, you will then really wish you would have broken the bank and got it right the first time.
I'm glad I have both though as the 642 is just right for my wife.
I just really like this combination and it carries nicely in most all pants and shorts in a Mika pocket holster.
See you at the 642 or 340 clubs, the nice thing is either way you go, you win.
My Pocket Carry Collection and I have a couple others in mind too.
Ammunition is COR BON DPX JHP 110 gr .38 plus P. Choice 3 of 3.