A semiauto convert.....

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zaydok Allen

Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
13,274
A revolver convert.....

Saturday morning my gal and I headed out to the woods to shoot some guns. I'm working with her to help her develop her fundamental shooting skills. The idea is that she wants to carry concealed at some point.

From the first time firearms came up in conversation, she has taken a stand point of "I don't like revolvers. They seem big and clunky and too old fashioned."

I calmly accepted her opinion for what it was, her opinion. I of course was sobbing like a child who's puppy just got ran over on the inside, but respected that each shooter needs to shoot what interests them. So I did not press the issue at all. Then one evening I was giving her a brief lesson on different operating systems (revolvers vs DA/SA semiautos vs SA only guns vs striker guns), when she spied my 3" Ruger SP101 in the case. Suddenly, she told me "See that looks like a gun I'd like to shoot. Not that one (pointing at one of my L frames)."

As it turns out, the mass, and frame size was what she was centering on. The L frame looks huge to her, intimidating, and unwieldy.

So Saturday rolled around, and I showed her the basics of revolver shooting, demonstrated the long DA trigger pull, talked about safety, and explained the sight picture to her on the SP101 (She has a natural logical understanding of sight picture which is great.).

She did well. I started her out on some really mild 130 gr American Eagle full metal jackets, and she enjoyed it a great deal. I had her shoot some Hornady Critical Defense 110 gr +p ammo also that I had sitting around. While loaded hotter, the lighter bullet only generated about 10-15% more noise and recoil than the 130 grain plinkers.

Then I loaded some 158 gr American Eagle jacketed soft point 357 magnums, and had her watch me shoot them. Those rounds are fairly warm and do kick alright in a small gun. That's where she drew the line, and she said she didn't want to shoot them. I did not pressure her to shoot them at all, as I don't believe in pushing someone to shoot something they don't want to. It's a good way to ruin a range trip.

By the 4th and 5th cylinder she was starting to hit the pie plate sized target pretty consistently at 10 yards. She even took some shots at a target that was about 15 yards away and managed to hit it.

Afterwards, we shot my Wilson/Beretta 92 Brig Tac (which she loved and was really shooting well) and my VP9. By the time we got to my VP9 her arms were tired, so she started missing a lot. So I unloaded another 75 rounds or so myself and we called it a day.

So the staunch revolver rejecter now has an interest in a revolver............ Hmmmmmm........... There may be hope for this relationship yet. ;):) Too bad I already bought her a Ruger LC9S for her birthday present next weekend. It's the one she really liked, but that was prior to her shooting a revolver. :D I told her that nobody ever said she couldn't own more than one gun.

Oh well, I knew this would get expensive, but having a shoot'in girl around is definitely worth the expense.

Have you ever converted someone who didn't care for revolvers originally?
 
Last edited:
My girlfriend was the opposite.
She was only interested in revolvers! She handles my N-Frame 625 pretty well. The small-ish combat grips certainly help though.
She decidedly did not like shooting the same mild 200gr SWC loads out of a full size 1911. Made it halfway through the first magazine and put it down and went happily right back to the 625.
 
I had a similar experience with my wife. She pretty much only cares for revolvers these days.

As a side note, the LC9s is IMHO one of the best pocket type pistols ever made. I was very leery at first. Having owned an LCP and later had a chance to test out the LC9, I was pretty disgruntled with the triggers. The LC9s is a HUGE step up.

Back to your original post though, well done! I am a revolver lover myself. I own more semis than revolvers but I enjoy shooting the revolvers far more.
 
Yeah, I have found that my taste has balanced out, and I tend to alternate my purchases. Lately I've been on a 9mm kick, but no matter what happens, I find myself just looking at my revolvers with more affection.

Yes, I am impressed with the feel and trigger on the LC9S. I think she will really like it for her first carry gun. I am a bit concerned about the recoil though, but I figured it would be good to just get the one she wants, with the understanding that it may get traded away. I'm fine with that. I want her to have a gun that's going to keep her safe.
 
My wife doesn't like long trigger pulls and cannot stand revolvers because of that. She likes striker fired pistols only. I have never met someone who was as trigger sensitive as her, it's very strange.
 
I bought one for my 18 year old daughter as a graduation gift. She is really recoil sensitive and doesn't seem to have issues with it. She actually had her heart set on an LCR in .38. I already own one of those so I bought the LC9s and had her shoot both guns side by side. She chose the LC9s hands down.

I was glad too. To stay in keeping with this thread, while I really love the LC9s, I was ill prepared to give up my LCR in its place:)
 
460Kodiak

Shouldn't it be your girlfriend is a revolver convert? I bought my girlfriend a S&W Model 34 with a 4" barrel mainly because she was a little leery of how a semi-auto works. She loves the relative simplicity of the revolver though for now she has no interest in moving up to centerfire guns. All in good time!

002_zpswv4thxmc.gif
 
460Kodiak

Shouldn't it be your girlfriend is a revolver convert? I bought my girlfriend a S&W Model 34 with a 4" barrel mainly because she was a little leery of how a semi-auto works. She loves the relative simplicity of the revolver though for now she has no interest in moving up to centerfire guns. All in good time!

Oh, yeah, I suppose so. Hey that's a nice looking 34. I'm curious, does she like shooting L frames also?
 
460Kodiak

I'm curious, does she like shooting L frames also?

No, not really. I have a Model 686 but she's not into the larger caliber (and heavier), revolvers. For now she's quite content with her Model 34 and that's just fine with me.
 
My wife started out with a Taurus PT 22. After a year or so she went to a LCP and now uses a LC9s. She jumps back and forth depending on which pocketbook she has with her.
 
My wife brought two guns into our marriage, a S&W 66 and Taurus 38 Special. And she loves my old S&W Model 19-3. I prefer semiautos but understand they are not right for her. She's not mechanically inclined and has a hard time racking the slide. To each your own. Just know the guns you use!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top