Bell as bear defense?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 13, 2008
Messages
262
Maybe this is the wrong forum for this question. Hunting = Outdoors?

I have heard from several people that the best defense against bears is to wear a noisy bell while hiking. I don't plan on hunting, so personal protection is the only priority. Does anyone here recommend a bell?
 
And away we go . . . "What caliber bell is best for bears?" I'll carry something a bit more potent than a "bell" if encountering a bruin is a possibility.
 
The wording wold be a bit poor here, methinks. Bells aren't intended as defense. Defense would imply the bear is attacking at the moment. Bells are intended to prevent the attack in the first place by alerting bears before you arrive, so they won't be surprised and can leave if desired.
Whether they work as intended is another story, but it's an easier discussion to approach if you know the intent in the first place.
 
I believe any noise would work. A bell ringing constantly would be exceptionally annoying to me. I just yell, "hey bear" every couple of minutes, when in bear country.
 
I'd suggest something the size of the Liberty Bell. You could hide under it. Could work....
 
Undoubtedly!

Lost their hearing from so many folks trying to shoot them with less then a .460 Weatherby.

Course, it didn't kill them, just made them go def from the muzzle blast of those pipsqueak little mouse-gun 30-06's and such.

rcmodel
 
The wording wold be a bit poor here, methinks. Bells aren't intended as defense. Defense would imply the bear is attacking at the moment. Bells are intended to prevent the attack in the first place by alerting bears before you arrive, so they won't be surprised and can leave if desired.
Whether they work as intended is another story, but it's an easier discussion to approach if you know the intent in the first place.
I thought it was obvious that i wasn't planning to use a jingly bell to persuade the bear to remove its jaws from my cranium. I should have worded it better anyways though i guess.
Assuming you were travelling through bear country armed with a RPG or jesse ventura's anti-predator minigun for bear defense... would you use a noisy bell to save ammo?
 
No; I would, however hike in other than stealth mode. I was raised in Griz country & have been fortunate to have seen many. On the trail, I ensured I made sufficient noise . . . whistled, sang (likely scared the bejeezuz out of other critters), talked, made sure there was something on my pack that clunked or rattled (added plus: establishes a hiking cadence). Had no problems. On the other hand, I DID have cause to shoot a black bear once . . . used a .44 mag & switched to 12-gauge shottie at that point. Suffice to say, I was less-than-impressed by the results with the handgun, time-wise (and all but one of five were lethal hits).
 
Make sure it's the correct type of bell!

You want a bear repellant bell and not a dinner bell-what's the difference you ask?
HellifIknow-wadda I look like-a bear?
Guess you'll haff to ask the bear! :what:
 
The bells are kinda silly. Bears can smell a person from a mile away and know you're in the area. They are surprised that YOU can't smell THEM and come barging right into their turf. That's the "surprise." You are better off using your noodle and your ears. Every time I've run into bears or other large wildlife I've heard them first. Noisy bells keep you from using your own senses.
 
shoot your friend in the leg and run

Mike,

I just found out that I won't be able to go hiking with you this weekend . . .

:what:
 
Where will you be hiking? Is it bear country if so what species of bears are around, are they likely to have encountered humans before? Chances of bear encounter in the lower 48 are much lower than in Alaska. There have been some nasty attacks in Yellowstone in the back country too.

I've spent quite a bit of time in the woods in Alaska, bells, horns, for prevention anything that makes an unnatural noise works very well, it doesn't have to be loud enough to be annoying. Yelling works but can get old after a while. The only trouble we've had with bears was during hunting with scent block when neither party knew the other was there :).

Fish and Game did a study with salmon researchers, the researchers were having trouble with bears. After they started blowing portable compressed air horns before retrieving salmon encounters with bears were almost eliminated.

Bears typically want to avoid humans, but they sometimes need help identifying us. Stay alert to terrain and plant life, for example before going over a hill or anywhere visibility is limited make some noise. Humans like berries, so do bears, it is just something you learn to keep in the back of your head.

Reading up on bear behavior is important too, they have body language and vocalizations just like humans and dogs.
 
The bells are kinda silly. Bears can smell a person from a mile away and know you're in the area. They are surprised that YOU can't smell THEM and come barging right into their turf. That's the "surprise." You are better off using your noodle and your ears. Every time I've run into bears or other large wildlife I've heard them first. Noisy bells keep you from using your own senses.

I was hunting in the UP last fall for Ruffed Grouse and I got into a Elder grove and I smelled something that reminded me of a stinky men's locker room. I grabbed my revolver thinking that my dog was going to tangle with a Black Bear. When I exited the the grove I told my buddy about the smell, he figured bear also.

The next day when we went to town for gas and food I asked the locals about the smell and they said I should have been more concerned about my dog bumping a porcupine when you smell that then a bear.

I googled that up when I returned to Iowa and the locals were right.

I've been with in 50 yards of a momma bear and cubs (unsurprised) out West fishing and I didn't smell anything other than the pines.
 
Went fishing in April in the White Mountains of Arizona. On the west branch of the Black River a young bear decided he wanted my trout more than I did. I agreed and got the hell out of there. I doubt that my ringing a bell or even firing my Makarov would have much bothered him.
 
That sounds stupid I would carry a 500 magnum. S&W should start making 500 magnums with 15+ cylinders just for bear season :)
 
I've been with in 50 yards of a momma bear and cubs (unsurprised) out West fishing and I didn't smell anything other than the pines.

Rest assured they smelled you, though. Their sense of smell is legendary.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top