AVIAN FLU: PREVENTING A PANDEMIC
Avian Virus Caused
The 1918 Pandemic,
New Studies Show
By BETSY MCKAY
Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
October 6, 2005; Page B1
There is a new reason to worry that the avian-flu virus could erupt with
little notice into a global pandemic that kills millions of people: It
happened already.
After nearly a decade of research, teams of scientists said yesterday
that they had re-created the historic influenza virus that by some
estimates killed 50 million people world-wide in 1918 and 1919. The
scientists concluded that the virus originated as an avian bug and then
adapted and spread in humans by undergoing much simpler changes than
many experts had previously thought were needed for a pandemic.
Some mutations of the 1918 virus have been detected in the current
avian-flu virus, suggesting the bug "might be going down a similar path
that led to 1918," says Jeffery Taubenberger, chief of molecular
pathology at the U.S. Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, who led one
of two studies.
The studies, published yesterday in the journals Nature and Science by
researchers from the Armed Forces institute, the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, and Mount Sinai School of Medicine, suggest that
a bird-flu pandemic could erupt in more ways than previously thought --
and could be as lethal as its predecessor. Unlocking the mysteries of
the 1918 bug "has taken on new urgency," says Dr. Taubenberger.
The findings could also help researchers hone their efforts to develop
vaccines and treatments for avian flu by pinpointing which pieces of the
virus made it so virulent. CDC researchers narrowed in on a gene in the
re-created 1918 virus that allows the bug to attach itself to cells and
multiply. With the gene, the virus was highly lethal; it lost its
virulence when researchers removed it. Those findings and the genetic
makeup of the virus will now be publicly available. The U.S. National
Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity endorsed making the genetic
information public to promote development of tests, treatments and
preventive measures, the CDC said.
Deciphering clues from the bug has never been so urgent. Avian flu
continues to spread in poultry flocks and is jumping to humans with
increasing frequency. The lethal strain has claimed 60 lives in
Indonesia, Vietnam, Thailand and Cambodia since late 2003.
Most of those cases occurred in people who had direct contact with
infected poultry. But health officials are concerned that the virus
could mutate and begin spreading between humans, and that when it does,
it will rapidly sweep the globe. On Tuesday, President Bush unexpectedly
announced he would consider using the military to enforce quarantines in
the event of an outbreak in the U.S.
"If 1918 happened like this, why couldn't or shouldn't 2005 happen like
this?" says Michael Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious
Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota, who has
warned in several papers that the H5N1 virus could morph into a
1918-like pandemic. "These viruses are kissing cousins."
Precisely why and how the 1918 virus killed so many people has been
considered one of the greatest remaining secrets of virology, and the
team led by Dr. Taubenberger has spent the past nine years trying to
decipher it. According to historical accounts, suffocating victims
turned deep shades of blue; many hemorrhaged, bleeding even from their
eyes and ears. More people died during the pandemic than in World War I.
Unlike with most flu epidemics, most of the casualties were
otherwise-healthy people ranging in age from 15 to 34.
But studying the virus was nearly impossible until recently because
virus samples weren't preserved at the time. In February 2004, Dr.
Taubenberger and his team published sequences for five of the 1918
virus's eight genes, using material preserved from the lungs of U.S.
soldiers killed by the flu, as well as the body of an Inuit woman
exhumed in 1997 from the Alaskan permafrost. The team completed
sequencing the remaining three genes, and their work is published this
week in Nature.
They concluded that the pandemic was caused by an avian virus. The
scientists also discovered 10 changes in amino acids that distinguish
the 1918 virus from avian bugs, suggesting that the virus mutated on its
own, without mixing with another virus, to become transmissible in
humans, they say. The current avian bug has made five of the 10 changes
found in the 1918 virus. (Emphasis added by DM.)
In the study in Science, researchers from the CDC, Mount Sinai, and
others then re-created the virus using a process known as reverse
genetics to determine which of its features made it so lethal. The virus
was then injected into embryonated chicken eggs and mice and was found
to be "exceptionally virulent," says Terrence Tumpey, a senior scientist
at the CDC who led the effort. The team also found that the bug had an
unusual ability to penetrate cells that flu viruses don't usually reach
deep in the lungs, providing some clues as to why the disease's symptoms
were so severe.
While the research advances scientists' understanding of the avian-flu
threat, it raises questions about how to keep the virus from escaping
from a laboratory or falling into the hands of bioterrorists. Not only
has the virus now been created in a CDC lab, but its genetic information
will be published in GenBank, a public genetic-sequence database
maintained by the National Institutes of Health.
Dr. Tumpey says the experiments were approved by two CDC committees with
internal and external experts, and were conducted under strict safety
and security standards inside a CDC lab.
The 1918 flu virus would be unlikely to cause a pandemic today, Dr.
Tumpey says. This virus is in the same family as the seasonal influenza
viruses that have been circulating for several years. Many people today
have some immune protection from these types of viruses because they
have been exposed to the seasonal flu viruses either through natural
infection or vaccination.
The researchers say they are pushing ahead with their work. Dr. Tumpey
says he and his colleagues plan to analyze the remaining four of the
eight genes whose virulence they didn't study, with the hope of
identifying more virus proteins. Dr. Taubenberger of the Armed Forces
Institute says his team's goal is to create a "checklist" that would
help researchers tracking viruses determine which mutations are
important and which are minor.
"We hope to work out in the future the rules of how this happens, how a
bird virus becomes a human virus," he says.