CCW for my wife. Prefer women to reply.

Status
Not open for further replies.

sheriff-g

Member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
9
So I had my 54 year old wife at the gun range today. Even though she did not grow up around guns, she has her concealed carry license, and is not "afraid" of guns. She loves shooting her .22 pistols and can work them safely and efficiently. The same is true with rifles. However her concealed carry gun is a Ruger LCP in .380. She has long fingernails and not a lot of grip strength. Even though she can accurately hit targets with just about any gun I give her, she has problem manipulating the mechanicals. And before you start saying "training and practice" I think there is more to it than that.

The Ruger LCP is the only gun that she can conceal with her woman's clothing, which is generally much more form fitted than our men's clothes. Also, men get to wear nice thick, wide leather belts which are perfect for holding a holster. Have you men looked at the belts that come with most women's pants? They can barely support a clip on pen! Alternative carry methods from a good waist holster (purse carry, ankle carry, etc.) seem about as useful as fire extinguisher kept at your neighbor's house. That is, not readily accessible in a moment of crisis.

I've had her try the new Glock .380, J frame 2" .38 spl revolvers, etc. She can't conceal the J frames, and the semi-autos that I can work easily, she cannot effectively work, and comes away frustrated. For example, she got her fingers pinched twice today racking slides on micro semi-autos. With her long fingernails, the overhand grip doesn't work, and with her weak hand strength, she has to put too much of her hand on the grip (too far forward and gets pinched) because she can't cycle the slides with just her thumb and side of her index finger.

At this point the only guns I can think to try next are the little .22, .25, and .32 tilt up barrel, semi-autos. They might be small enough for her to conceal, yet, she would not have to rack the slide, to chamber the first round. Not ideal self defense rounds, but better than a gun at home because it can't be concealed, or manipulated.

Does anybody (particularly women in the same situation) have any other suggestions?

Additional Information:

Based on the first replies, it looks like I did not give enough info. ha ha.
I am a Firearms Dealer and my wife works in the store. We sell lots of holsters and we are familiar with the Flash Bang, holster shirts, belly bands, pistol purses, etc. Accessing the gun in a life and death situation takes way too long.

We are familiar with The Cornered Cat and sell the book. My wife is a trained and competent shooter, and yes we have been through all of the modified ways to rack a slide. Suggestions for 4" revolvers are not going to work. Remember she can't even conceal a 2" J frame (5 shot .38spl) or Ruger LCR, because they cylinder and grip really show through her clothes. Much as I have tried to convince her, she refuses to wear potato bag clothing! This is also why she doesn't conceal carry her .22's that she has no problem working: it is hard to conceal a Browning Buck Mark, or Ruger Mark II with 5.5" barrels!

Yes I can, and have been, sending her off with a Ruger LCP .380 with a round already chambered. But this does not let her gain proficiency or confidence with the gun. That is kind of like doing everything for a driver (starting the car, putting it in gear, and running the petals) and only letting the other person steer. This is not good, if I'm not around to assist.

The problem is more one of physical limitations (I forgot the carpal tunnel) not letting her work common Micro guns, AND yet these micro guns are the only guns she can conceal, using a sticky holster, pocket holster, or inside the pants holster.

So I guess I'm looking for suggestions for other guns to try, that are micro in size, yet easy to work... FROM A WOMAN'S PERSPECTIVE, or from somebody with physical limitations like arthritis of the hands.
Are there any women out there?

Thanks again for ALL suggestions. Even professionals can't know everything, so some of you are going to hit on ideas I have not considered.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'm not a woman, but I do have a question.

If she's concerned over racking the slide, is it because she's inclined to carry the gun with an empty chamber? I ask this because, with the chamber loaded, the only slide-racking concern should be in the event of a failure to function of the weapon. In such a scenario, the little tip-up barrel guns (such as the Taurus PT-22) also require a clearing process, one that could be even more problematic. Those guns do not have extractors; to clear a failed round, one has to tip open the breech and pluck or dump the round free, then close the breech and rack the slide. Just try one day racking the slide of those Taurus guns. They are stiff.

If she's carrying with the chamber loaded, the problem is likely already solved as well as it's gonna be.

On a side note, she might enjoy perusing CorneredCat.com, a self-defense site for women shooters by a woman shooter...
 
I'm not female either, and my wife won't answer here. She's 65 so she has 11 years on your wife. She likes this website: http://www.corneredcat.com/article/running-the-gun/rack-the-slide/

She's tried several small guns: snubbie 38 special, Walther PPK/S, Ruger LC9, Ruger LC9s, Glock 42, Ruger SR9c and more.

After shooting all of them several times, she's settled on the LC9s. She shot exactly 25 rounds through the snubbie 38 Special and that was the end of that.

Still for carry, the LC9s.
 
Cornered Cat is a good site for the question. Including ones such as loading magazines without breaking nails. Your best bet is if you can find a woman that does carry conceal that is in a position where she must "dress like a girl." My cousin (an attorney) taught me more in one sitting than three of my male "advisors" in a month. Some things, you just need to have your girlfriends help you with.
 
Last edited:
My wife doesn't care to shoot semi-autos; has trouble racking the slide and just plain doesn't like the way they operate. She does very well with her S&W Model 34 Kit Gun so one possible way for her to go would be a center fire snubby in .327 Mag. or else a .38 Special and starting her out with target wadcutter ammo. A holster is pretty much out given she really doesn't have any pants that use a belt so for now it's probably going to be a purse designed with a built-in holster.
 
O.P.,

This is one of the top three topics on THR. There is a sticky at the top of the forum about choosing a gun for your wife and a search will give you many threads about it.

It is hard for many of the men on THR to understand the differences in strength and how handicaps such as carpel tunnel restricts women's ability to rack the slide on a semi-auto.

Everything in concealed carry is a trade off. We discovered a couple of years ago the perfect revolver for my wife is the Colt Police Positive Special. Since it has a 4" barrel I have been looking for a Detective Special for her (same gun only has 2" barrel).

The P.P.S. and D.S. are long out of production but may well be worth the search.
 
My wife doesn't care to shoot semi-autos; has trouble racking the slide and just plain doesn't like the way they operate. She does very well with her S&W Model 34 Kit Gun so one possible way for her to go would be a center fire snubby in .327 Mag. or else a .38 Special and starting her out with target wadcutter ammo. A holster is pretty much out given she really doesn't have any pants that use a belt so for now it's probably going to be a purse designed with a built-in holster.

Hi Bannock,

I'm curious, has she ever had another woman teach her the method of cycling a semi-auto? Men invariably use the brute force method that very few women can. Your strength is in the upper torso, ours tend to be in the lower torso. Ask her to try holding the handgun with her normal use hand and the slide with the other. Putting the strong side arm firmly against her hip, rotate that hip pushing the handgun and holding the slide stationary. Also grip the slide (in her off hand) firmly on top of the slide just behind the ejector port.

Quite frankly, had my Grandmother not taught me that little trick my Commander would like as not be gathering dust as I couldn't cycle the weapon the way my Dad tried to teach me.
 
http://corneredcat.com
http://www.babeswithbullets.com
http://www.nssf.org/FirstShots/NewShooters/
http://www.nrahq.org/education/index.asp
www.womenandguns.com http://women.nra.org

If she has a basic knowledge about handguns that's a good starting point. If not then let it be recommended that she get a basic NRA or other accredited one on one or women's only course under her belt. Then she can decide what gun and ammo combo fir her and her needs.

The links were provided with that in mind.

She might find this link useful as well.
http://www.taurusarmed.net/forums/bustles-bows-bullets/

This is just another source. There are a lot of women's shooter blogs and sites.

Take her to the LGS in your area and let her handle and try as many types as she can.
 
if she loves her .22's and can handle them why not carry them?
hits and quick followups with a .22 are better than a flinch and a miss with a .38 or .380
 
For the short term, I'll recommend a Flash Bang Holster. Google it.

There are also a few different makers of Belly Band Holsters.

Finally, there is 5.11 Tactical's T-Shirt Holster.

As for Firearms:

S&W 22 magnum snubby. This, or a competitor snubby would be the only rimfire I would recommend for self defense. Load it with the Gold Dot Short Barrel cartridge.

327 Federal Magnum. This one seems to be making a resurgence since it's recent introduction. It might be an acceptable compromise.

Kahr CT380. Just above in size to the micro 380s, this one give the shooter a better grip, better sights, and with a MagGuts upgrade, 8+1 rounds. (MagGuts has an upgrade kit for your lady's LCP).
 
I'm not a woman, but I know a few.
One is content with the Charter Arms Undercover 2" .38 recommended by her cop Dad.

The other was considerately provided with a S&W Airweight .38 by her husband.
It did not suit her, she moved on to a Ruger LCP .380 and is now shopping a Glock 43.

Neither has such long fingernails as to impair her dexterity.

Medwheeler touches on an approach not obvious to the typical man.
If she can shoot but not operate a serviceable pistol, it might come down to you handing her a loaded gun to holster. Stay with her .22s for practice.
 
Again, not a woman. My wife (5', 110lbs) carries and conceals a Sig P238 in normal women's clothing. She also had difficulty shooting and operating the LCP and P3AT and couldn't comfortably conceal a J frame. The 238 is soft shooting and easier to operate the slide other small pistols.
 
http://corneredcat.com
http://www.babeswithbullets.com
http://www.nssf.org/FirstShots/NewShooters/
http://www.nrahq.org/education/index.asp
www.womenandguns.com http://women.nra.org

If she has a basic knowledge about handguns that's a good starting point. If not then let it be recommended that she get a basic NRA or other accredited one on one or women's only course under her belt. Then she can decide what gun and ammo combo fir her and her needs.

The links were provided with that in mind.

She might find this link useful as well.
http://www.taurusarmed.net/forums/bustles-bows-bullets/

This is just another source. There are a lot of women's shooter blogs and sites.

Take her to the LGS in your area and let her handle and try as many types as she can.

All good info in that post. One thing I would to the mention of the LGS and handling - it would be even better if they had a range where she could try several that SHE thinks might work well for her.
 
Yes, The Cornered Cat. Great book for men or women new to concealed carry. Maybe it is time for me to re-read it.
 
if she loves her .22's and can handle them why not carry them?
hits and quick followups with a .22 are better than a flinch and a miss with a .38 or .380
Yes. I agree. If she could conceal her Buck Mark 5.5", that is what she would carry.
 
For the short term, I'll recommend a Flash Bang Holster. Google it.

There are also a few different makers of Belly Band Holsters.

Finally, there is 5.11 Tactical's T-Shirt Holster.

As for Firearms:

S&W 22 magnum snubby. This, or a competitor snubby would be the only rimfire I would recommend for self defense. Load it with the Gold Dot Short Barrel cartridge.

327 Federal Magnum. This one seems to be making a resurgence since it's recent introduction. It might be an acceptable compromise.

Kahr CT380. Just above in size to the micro 380s, this one give the shooter a better grip, better sights, and with a MagGuts upgrade, 8+1 rounds. (MagGuts has an upgrade kit for your lady's LCP).
Thanks for the gun suggestions.
 
Again, not a woman. My wife (5', 110lbs) carries and conceals a Sig P238 in normal women's clothing. She also had difficulty shooting and operating the LCP and P3AT and couldn't comfortably conceal a J frame. The 238 is soft shooting and easier to operate the slide other small pistols.
Thank you. I will definitely have her try this model.
 
Even though I won't currently be able to concealed carry here I spent some time looking around on the web for possible solutions for women. I think a small-size woman with not too big a chest could use one of those stretch shells (for the guys, a shell is sort of a short sleeveless t-shirt, the one I saw was made of compression fabric so the gun will stay put and be quite well concealed) with a built-in pocket for the gun. Also a friend told me they saw a video of a woman drawing in something like 1.4 seconds from one of those holsters that hangs below the bra.
 
I'm a big guy, not a female. I'm 6' and currently 270 lbs. I hope to lose another 50 lbs this year. I carry a High Noon Split Decision IWB holster without accommodation except I notch up one less hole on my belt. My Wrangler jeans are fairly snug. I wear Saddlebred button down shirts from Belk's, a regional chain. They are worn tucked in and at 3:30 position my PM45 does not show. I carried my Ruger P345 in a Split Decision as well but it was a little heavy for EDC. There are several other holster makers that have similar styles. I'm sure one of those makers has one for the G42 or LCP. Draw would certainly be as fast as a belly band or other deep concealment devices. I know there have been a lot of suggestions that don't work for her and I wish lady members would chime in. Try mine if you can and I hope it works for her. I do slightly blouse my shirt tails by lifting my arms over my head.
 
Last edited:
Get the gun that she feels comfortable shooting and functioning, and learn to dress around it. You make it sound as if her wardrobe is rigidly set.

I see no reason why a J frame in a horizontal shoulder holster under a stylish jacket would be out of the question.
 
I just went through the same ordeal with my wife. We ended up going to a shop locally and I turned her over to the owner (who I know well) and made sure she got to handle the glock 42. It's slide is easier to manipulate, and recoil less than most 380s she loves it. It is bigger than a lot of micro 380s, but it is a great gun for her and she is still excited about it. I have no complaints, especially since we got blue label.
 
My mom is 67 and weighs about 105, soaking wet.
She has fired and really likes my wifes Sig P238.
Shes not very fluent in firearms, but had no problems with manipulating the slide either.
So, heres another vote for that one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top