I like revolvers. I don't particularly like semi-autos. I have more than my fair share of both, and my Beretta 92 Steel I is a functional work of art, but I reload and therefore don't like chasing my brass hither and yon at the range.
That being said, I needed a semi-auto to go to Front Sight. Interestingly, Front Site gives away XDs, but they rent Glock 17s... So I decided to purchase a Glock 17 Gen3 and a S&W M&P to compare before heading to formal training. (I didn't consider the XD because of its grip safety. Ironically, most of the people in my shooting class who experienced malfunctions were shooting XDs.)
The M&P feels great in my hand, and is a relatively handsome beast (sorta). The Glock 17 is... well... a Glock. Before I took them to the range for show and tell, I was CERTAIN the Glock would be history.
Then a surprising thing happened. The Glock 17 went bang every time I pulled the trigger, and the bullets all hit remarkably close to where I was aiming. The M&P also functioned flawlessly, but was not as accurate as the Glock. I also really liked the short, definite, trigger reset on the Glock, while the M&P's trigger reset was longer and kinda mushy. So they both went to Front Sight, but the Glock 17 was all I used.
The end of the story is that the S&W M&P will be going to the local gunshow in a week or so (and not coming home), while the Glock 17 will soon have a twin in the gun safe. No, I don't really like semi-autos. But in certain situations, they're the only rational choice.
Hey, maybe Glocks are for people who don't really like semi-autos...