I decided I wanted my first C&B revolver, and thought I would get a 1858 Remington, but found a Pietta 1851 "Marshal" at a small shop in middle Georgia. Got it at a good price, and couldn't turn it down. I haven't had a chance to shoot it yet (killing me), but I already want the next one. This will be a 1858 New Army. Now for the question I know will get various responses, is the Uberti worth the premium over the Pietta? The cost difference isn't enough to bother me if the Uberti better.