Grand jury indicts bird lover in cat's death

Status
Not open for further replies.

gunsmith

member
Joined
May 8, 2003
Messages
5,906
Location
Reno, Nevada
I thawt I saw a puddy cat

http://www.khou.com/news/local/galveston/stories/khou070412_jj_catdeath.7f24f4.html

Grand jury indicts bird lover in cat's death

09:08 AM CDT on Thursday, April 12, 2007

By Scott E. Williams / The Daily News

GALVESTON — A grand jury Wednesday indicted the founder of the Galveston Ornithological Society on a felony charge of cruelty to animals.

Prosecutors accused Jim Stevenson, 53, of loving birds a little too much. He faces a charge of cruelty to animals in the November shooting of a cat. More than once, Stevenson has stated that feral cats on the isle’s West End are a danger to bird populations.

In November, police arrested Stevenson after a report of shots fired near the San Luis Pass toll bridge.

When patrol officers reached the West End, they stopped a van with a Galveston Ornithological Society logo on its side.

One of the toll-bridge workers was following the van and later told police the van’s occupant had shot a cat for which the bridge worker had been caring.

Police later found a .22-caliber rifle in the white van.

Stevenson discussed the hours before his arrest after his release in November. His account appeared on the Texbirds online message board.

He wrote that, the night before his arrest, he saw a feral cat on the West End “creeping up on three snowy and two piping plovers, and several sanderlings.”

Stevenson wrote that he tried unsuccessfully to capture the cat. However, the next morning, he saw it and several other cats in the area, making him concerned for endangered and threatened birds whose habitat lies near the isle’s western tip.

State law offers a variety of definitions of cruelty to animals. One is killing an animal without its owner’s consent.

While Stevenson has never publicly admitted shooting the cat, he told The Daily News last year the charge was not valid because the cat was feral and had no owner.

However, the bridge worker, who testified before grand jurors Wednesday, had told police he and his peers regularly laid out food for the cats and had come to think of them as pets.

The bridge worker had also told investigators nearly a dozen cats had been killed in the area in the months prior to Stevenson’s arrest.

The charge carries a possible jail term of 180 days to two years, as well as a fine of up to $10,000.
 
That's odd. The Piping Plover is on the endangered list. Dammed if you do, damned if you don't in a liberal society...
 
Seems excessive to make that a felony charge.

Wasn't he just protecting the ecosystem?

Personally, I think stray dogs and cats should be caught or eliminated.
 
Feral cats should be shot on sight. If I see a cat in my yard, it may or may not make it out of my yard without a big bruise on its ass, maybe worse. I've had it up to *here* with cat owners who think their animals have a right to damage other people's property.
Like Alice said - "No more Mr. Nice Guy..."

Biker
 
The toll booth workers should be charged for feeding the feral cats in the first place. And bird lovers should learn to use a pellet gun. Or at least subsonic ammo.
 
I don't believe that it is illegal in any way to feed feral cats in Texas. However, I am almost positive that if you feed a feral/stray cat, in the eyes of the law you are now its owner. In other words, that toll booth worker is responsible for the health and wellfare of the cat(s), to include food, shelter, and medical care. Anybody care to guess whether that toll booth worker is paying to have the cat(s) vaccinated? Do they have identification and licenses? Is he picking up after them? What is he doing to ensure that wildlife isn't harmed/killed by his pet?

Now change the scenario a little bit. You are enjoying a sunset at the beach with your dog (licensed, vacciniated and fed, doo-doo bags at the ready) when he suddenly runs up to you with the head off of a black-crowned night heron in his mouth, and all of this is in full view of a newspaper reporter. I am thinking you are now in big trouble for not controlling your pet. But this is OK if it is your cat?

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/4710901.html

Note picture of cat stalking black-crowned night heron.

As far as I am concerned, they should have arrested the toll booth worker for animal neglect.
 
Truth to tell I have ambiguous feelings about this news item as far as the cat vs. the birds. The thing that bothers me about the whole thing is that this is something the judicial system is spending so much time and effort on in the first place. We are often told how overwhelmed our judicial system is and it is no wonder if disputes over the feral cats vs. wild birds takes up the time of judges, lawyers, court time, administrative time, etc. A little perspective would seem to be lacking in this entire affair.
 
I was just at the grocery store. There's a box in the vestibule collecting food for homeless cats. Geez, if you feed wild cats you just get more cats you need to feed. I felt like dropping a box of .22's in the collection...
 
So, the "owners" of the cat(s) knowingly permitted these cats to prey upon endangered species? Why are they not being charged? Why are these same "owners" not charged with negligence for not taking their "pets" home? Furthermore, in Michigan, it is illegal to make a pet of a wild animal. Is such not the same in Texas? Sounds to me like some anti-gun lunatic was seeking to make an example of the man. I guess he should have just taken his dog with him and let it go for a "run". :evil:
 
However, the bridge worker, who testified before grand jurors Wednesday, had told police he and his peers regularly laid out food for the cats and had come to think of them as pets.

There's where the charges should be brought. Feral cats are no good.

Of course, there's a difference between a feral cat and a stray. A stray will come up to warm milk and start purring when you pet it. A feral cat will remove large sections of your forearm if you try to pet it. If you've been around a few it's easy to tell the difference in body language and attitude. I remember a big orange cat in a neighborhood I lived in college. He'd make daily rounds checking on everybody, and would often want to come inside to take get a few pets, then leave. There were also cats that would eat your liver given half a chance.
 
I'm very familiar with this area as I fish there frequently.
What this guy did was (IMO) a blessing for the bird population.
The area is infested with feral cats and they have decimated the native shore birds. :fire:
The guys in the Toll Booth should get HAMMERED by the Feds for allowing "their pets" to run loose and prey upon protected sea birds.:cuss:

FYI: The area is at the far SouthWest tip of the barrier island. The area is mostly flat dunes w/ grasses. No trees. The birds have to nest/live on the ground. Easy pickings for cats.
 
Like Alice said - "No more Mr. Nice Guy..."

Biker, Alice clearly doesn't like cats if you listen to his lyrics. Found in the same song is his reference "my cat clawed my eyes". If you listen to his new Dirty Diamons album this is also supported in the song "You're your own worst enemy" in the line "Your dog ate your cat and that was your good day.".

Death to cats. Long live Alice.
 
we are always hearing about invasive foreign species getting into the ecosystem and messing with the native flora and fauna, be it zebra mussles, purple loostrife, carp, or whatever.

many many many of these items are first introduced because someone thinks they are a cool pet or a cool plant or whatever, and some escape.

I never really thought about feral cats that way, but I guess they are, just as much as snakes massacring the birds of hawaii and guam. Of course, snakes are less cuddly, if you kill one of those on hawaii or guam, you are a hero, but cats? I guess not
 
I never really thought about feral cats that way, but I guess they are

They are.

I understand why the guy would shoot the cats. Fish and Game (or whatever they're called in Texas) obviously did nothing to get rid of the cats.

Plovers and other beach-nesting birds are a serious PITA. We humans give up a lot of good beach/trail access so they can possible come back from endangered status. Then we just let cats kill them?

If we're going to take extraordinary measures to save these birds -- and we do, for better or worse -- at least we can get rid of introduced predators that wipe them out.
 
He should of used a good air rifle to avoid attention. But, regardless, this is ridiculous charging him with a felony for what he did.:fire:
 
I don't believe that it is illegal in any way to feed feral cats in Texas. However, I am almost positive that if you feed a feral/stray cat, in the eyes of the law you are now its owner.

The ownership issue is, possibly, why the guy got a felony charge. The Texas statute on animal cruelty includes
"(5) kills, seriously injures, or administers poison to an animal, other than cattle, horses, sheep, swine, or goats, belonging to another without legal authority or the owner's effective consent;"

and

"(g) An offense under Subsection (a)(1), (5), (6), (7), or is a state jail felony, except that the offense is a felony of the third degree if the person has previously been convicted two times under this section."
 
when i was in highschool my friend's house backed up to a trailer park, hundreds of stray cats, he drove a international scout and left the window down one night, a tom got into it, and peed all over in it, he went to the sheriffs office and asked what he could do, being a small town one of the LEOs said trap them and realease them somewhere else, or trap them and take them out and shoot them, of course we picked the latter, we ended up shooting between 10-15 cats before his mom put the kabash on that. never wounded one we couldnt find and put out of its misery, had a few misses and the cats were never seen again...

oh and just so noone trips out too bad, if the cat looked as if it were well taken care of, or had a collar we would just release and rebait the trap, its pretty easy to tell the difference in strays and pets.
 
Would this have been a non-issue if the guy had a valid small game permit? Varmint hunting?

If the cat wasn't collared it isn't a pet, right? Kind of like the game warden doesn't care if you got close enough to the buck to see it's wigglies, if it doesn't have antlers of at least X" it's legally a doe, right?
 
Feral cats destroy huge numbers of birds and small mammals including rabbits. If the cat belonged to someone, they need to be charged with violations of the Endangered Species Act. If it belonged to no one, even if they were feeding it, then it was feral, and should have been destroyed. A .22 bullet is not cruel.

If I were the defense attorney, I would capture a bunch of these feral cats, bring then to court as evidence, and offer the jury the opportunity to examine them up close and personal.
 
I use CB caps to kill feral cats. No noise.


and stuffed, dead cats make great door stops. For other hints, read the book.

591b.jpg
 
The only thing that has kept me from popping the two mangy cats that hide in the bushes under my bird bath is the fact that there is a nosey biddy across the street who sits in front of her window all day. This doesn't keep me from tossing a rock in their general direction, but I am afraid that a pellet gun or even a slingshot will have her calling the police on me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top