H&R replacement barrel in 35 Whelen

Status
Not open for further replies.

ldlfh7

Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2013
Messages
743
I have a H&R 20 ga single shot I am looking to get a rifle barrel to have a more versatile gun without spending an arm and a leg. I have my eye on the 35 whelen at this point. I would only be using it on deer where I live but larger game hunts may be in the future, hence why I am looking at the 35 whelen. Does anyone have any experience with this cartridge? If I were to use this for deer would it be overkill or not? Any information is appreciated.

Thanks
 
H&R won't put rifle barrels on the shotgun receivers.

The receivers look identical to the naked eye, but the shotgun/.357/.44 receivers are cast, while the rifle receivers are forged. (I believe that's the difference--the rifle ones are stronger, anyway.) So H&R will only put rifle barrels under their barrel program on rifle receivers.

Sorry I don't have any input on the cartridge itself, but you'll basically have to just buy a new H&R rifle in whatever rifle cartridge you choose.

Aaron
 
Thanks for the info. Guess I have to buy a new receiver... Oh well.
 
What do ya'll think about a 44 mag rifle barrel on the SB1 frame? Will this cleanly take deer within 75 yards or would it be smarter to just get the rifled slug barrel?
 
I have no direct experience, but a little quick internet research seems to suggest that .44 magnum is flat shooting enough to 150 yards and would be fine for deer. I'd personally choose that over a rifled slug, but that's just my opinion.

Aaron
 
No experience with the single shots, but I used to own a 35 Whelen and have had 338/06 as well. They are both fun, interesting rounds that will work. With the right loads they are not too big for whitetail and both shoot a lot flatter at longer ranges than most folks realize. Perfectly adequate for distances most of us shoot, and suitable for any North American game.

On the other hand neither offer any real advantage over a 30-06 when loaded properly. The older 06 will shoot flatter with lighter bullets, has much less recoil, and is every bit as effective on larger game when loaded with heavier 200+ gr bullets.

The 35 Whelen recoils at 300 magnum levels, (probably much worse in a lightweight single shot) ammo is harder to find, selections are few, and much more expensive. While factory ammo is available, it should really be considered a handloaders round.

In short, it is a good round that will get the job done. If you want one then go for it. Just keep in mind a 30-06 does the same job with a lot less drama and expense. Depends on why you want the round.
 
When it comes to ammo, reload. I have a custom '03 Springfield in .35 Brown-Whelen (the most radical form of the Whelen) and I simply prime a .30-06 case, drop in a few grains of Bullseye, add a quarter of a sheet of toilet paper to keep the powder down on the primer and fire. The case that pops out is ready for reloading -- all taper gone, shoulder sharpened and pushed forward, and the neck expanded.
 
.35 Whelan is a great deer cartridge and the .44mag will do a great job at 75 yds. and beyond.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top