HOLSTER - PADDLE OR BELT SLIDE

[johnny blaze]

I am going to start carrying with a hip holster. I normally use the in the waist band holster, but want to try something else.
I am not looking for any particular brand, just some information on the following two types of holsters. These will be for either a revolver or an auto.
On the paddle holster, I kind of like the idea of being able to remove it easily when I do not need it. My question on a paddle holster is - is it possible for the holster to work it's way up and possible fall off. It appears to me that this may be a possibility. My IWB holsters ride up once in awhile.
And also. are they fairly comfortable?
On the belt slide holster - which is the best one. I see that they come in a higher rise holster that rides higher on the hip, and the standard models.
I know the belt slide holster cannot fall off, but are there any other things to be considered?
I know the belt slide has to be used with a pretty decent belt.
Any information would be appreciated.

 

[Kevinch]

I had a Galco Paddle Holster for a 4516-1 I used to own. It was OK as far as staying put, but it didn't conceal as well as a good belt holster. Sold it when I sold the gun, never missed it.

 

[Pistol Toter]

Johnny I prefer a pancake style and use the Bianchi model 7. I think they call it the "Shadow". Anyway it is very comfortable and quite concealable under a loose fitting shirt, hold the gun high and tight. Even my Glock 21 hides good with it and the little snubnose Ruger SP just flat disappears. P.T.

 

[ugaarguy]

Johnny I also like paddle holsters for areas where I need to take the holster off and put it back on several times in a day. The Galcos I've used have never ridden up and popped off. They can ride up a little but they have reverse notch in the paddle that holds them on. A good belt is just as important on a paddle holster as it is on a belt holster. I find the Galco paddles I've used to be quite comfortable as well.

 

[jfernett119]

I also like the paddle holster. I have never had a problem with my holster coming off.

 

[nwilliams]

I've never found that my paddle holsters feel like they will come loose while walking. However I do find that when driving or sitting with one on I tend to shift it around a bit to make it more comfortable. This has on occasion made allowed it to slip up and I often have push it back down a bit when I stand up. Its never been a real problem and I like being able to easily take the holster off.

 

[Jkwas]

The only paddle holsters I have are Fobus, one for a snub and one for a P89. Both allow the gun to ride too low for concealment and they shift around too much. I have found that a belt holster with an open bottom, like a Bianchi Black widow or similar type, works well. If you need to remove the weapon, you can either slide the holster off, or just leave it on. Without a gun in it it's practically invisible. Provided you have a cover garment on of course.

 

[2cam2go]

Ditto to all previous negative comments regarding paddle holsters.
My personal choice........A well made OWB leather belt holster, correctly sized belt slots and double thickness belt made to support firearms is the way to go. Comfortable to carry all day, conceals well and will last a long time.
The down side is you will need to wear a shirt out or jacket for CCW.

 

[rbernie]

I have a CompTac slide and a CompTac paddle for a number of pistols that I own. I prefer the CompTac paddle design above all else; it's very comfortable and very stable. It is rock solid and will not ride up until YOU want it off. It also does a very good job with retention without resorting to straps and such.

 

[KINGMAX]

slide

slide. jomho

 

[Brigrat]

I love paddle holsters...I have a little insulation on the sides that ensures that they stay in place lol

 

[cheaptrick]

CompTac paddle for a G17 for me.
I have had both, but prefer the paddle holster.

 

[glockman19]

My question on a paddle holster is - is it possible for the holster to work it's way up and possible fall off.

Anything is possible but doubtful.

are they fairly comfortable?

YES

On the belt slide holster - which is the best one.

The one that fits and feels the best.

 

[SniperStraz]

All I can say is that for open carry you deffinately want the belt slide for its retention.