I came very close to shooting a young man the other night...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tropical Buzz

Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
201
Location
St. Lucia, West Indies
This actually happened in July and though I was initially reluctant to post about it here, I brought it up in a current thread in the legal forum and I've decided to relate it here for critique and comment.
This is a actually a copy of a post I made elsewhere shortly after the incident occurred.

It's carnival season down here so a buddy and I decided to rent a corporate box at the local stadium and invite a bunch of friends to party it up while watching big steel band competition. The show was supposed to end around 11pm and the plan was for most of us to head back and finish off the night at my restaurant.

Well, after a few rain delays at the stadium, it was almost 2am by the time a small group of us got back to the lounge and staked out a corner of the balcony. I had borrowed two of my waitresses to serve drinks and eats at the show so they were tired, as was the chef, the manager and the rest of the staff after a long, busy night. I told them to wrap it up and head home and I would hang out with my group and lock up when we were done.

Close to 4am, we finally called it a night and I headed for home - normally a quick 10 minute drive on the quiet late night roads. Not this time though - I soon ran smack into a big traffic jam as hundreds of young people were just leaving a big dance party at a warehouse type joint in the middle of a nearby industrial park. Parked cars lined both sides of the road and traffic was at a standstill as crowds of people headed for their vehicles and drivers were doing u-turns and 3 pointers and generally snarling things up.

I was the only vehicle heading north - everyone else was either heading south or trying to get turned around. As I sat there watching the rowdy, excited kids - mostly teens and early 20's - stream by, I silently hoped I would pass through without incident and I made a conscious promise to myself not to allow my temper to get out of hand if faced with any minor provocation like a slap on my windshield or some other BS that is likely to happen in a crowd of liquored up young people at four in the morning.

I was able to ease along another hundred yards or so and I came up behind an older blacked-out 3 series BMW that seemed to be stopped for no reason. I beeped my horn and a guy got out of the back seat and walked over to a roadside group shouting at me to relax and take my effin' time. I ignored him and was just happy to see the car start moving as it wouldn't be much further until I was home free. The BMW driver began backing up a bit to pull a u-turn, which was fine - there was plenty of room between us. Plenty wasn't enough, though, and before I could blow the horn the bimmer's rear light crunched against my front bumper.

I expected the driver to stop and get out to see the damage, but no - the car just kept trying to finish the turn, hampered by traffic in the opposite lane. After an attempted robbery incident a few years ago, I always drive home with my pistol in my lap, positioned for a quick, easy presentation. Aware of the potential volatility of the situation, I took a deep breath to check my rising anger, holstered the gun (OWB strong side, covered by a loose untucked shirt), got out and walked up to the driver's window.

The tinted window came down and I was taken aback to see a pretty young woman behind the wheel. There was no damage to the heavy brush guard on my vehicle and I was about to ask her if she needed some help, but before I could say anything she rasped "What's your f-----g problem?!"

Mistake #1: My blood went instantly to simmer and I said "You hit my vehicle - that's my friggin' problem!" At that point, everything went south.

When I got out of the vehicle, I'd kept an eye on the crowd as they were naturally drawn by the accident. I wasn't too worried about that, but my eyes were scanning for the guy who had exited the car. Not to disappoint, he exploded forward, staggering drunk, cursing and shouting that I have no right to speak that way to his friend. I told him to calm down and keep his distance, this is between me and the driver of the vehicle that hit me. He had a bunch of support though, as two other guys joined him and a serious looking character got out of a fancy black SUV and joined in the chorus of curses and threats. He was a largish fellow, wearing a bomber jacket and a few pounds of gold around his neck. "Drug dealer", I remember thinking to myself.

Fortified now with courage, the drunk guy strode towards me, one hand raised saying he was going to slap my face. I had my vehicle at my back , cars and increasingly hostile kids everywhere else. I told him to stay back but I already knew he would keep coming. I lunged forward and hit him hard with a two handed thrust high on his chest. He fell back on his butt, slamming into the wheel of the BMW. He stayed down, holding the back of his head and started retching like he was going to puke. The dealer type pulled a long shank - a home made "ice pick" - out of his jacket and started towards me saying he was going to "open up my belly" and at that point I drew the gun and pointed it at his chest.

He stopped advancing but continued waving the shank and threatening, shouting to the crowd that I would never have the guts to pull the trigger. He was wrong. My finger was on the trigger and he was about 12 feet away. I was fully committed to firing if he advanced another step.

The situation was out of hand, the crowd was into it and I knew there was at least one other hostile guy in the group. Sure enough, the guy I was facing glanced to my right and I noticed another fellow edging up behind me along the side of my vehicle. I whipped the gun around one handed and pointed at his face, keeping my left hand pointed forward at the other guy. He stumbled back and I whipped it back towards the first guy with the shank. My finger was tightened past the trigger safety and I was on the verge of firing. If he had moved I would have fired. He didn't and I quickly shifted aim back towards the second guy but he ducked into the crowd and people around him, anticipating a shot, scattered.

I swung back to the armed man and shouted "F----g drop it! Now!" He cursed back and continued to hold the shank up high and shouted towards the crowd "Lets kill that man! He'll never shoot that gun!" It was decision time for me - I knew he was too close to me with that weapon, I was aiming squarely at his sternum and my finger was tight on the trigger.

Just then another man - a Rasta in a long robe-type garment addressed the guy by name and told him to stop being a fool - put the weapon down before he gets killed. He pointed to me and said "I know that man, he's a righteous fella, boy, but he's going to shoot your ass!"

I had not a clue who he was, but he kept saying he knows me, I'm a good man and that the guy better back down if he doesn't want to die. It worked. He lowered the shank but continued making a case that I had abused his female friend. The girl chimed in shouting that I'd just walked up to her car and started cussing her off and now I'm looking to shoot somebody. Others in the crowd started berating me that us "bourgeoise" (local slang for "rich" or upper class) guys with our licensed guns think we can do whatever we want.

I had lowered the gun to my side and said "Listen! She hit my vehicle and continued driving. She started with the verbal abuse when I approached her and I only drew the gun when this guy threatened me with a weapon." The rasta told the guy he was wrong, they spoke for a second and he hugged him and said "Go home. Go home my boy."

The fellow helped his fallen drunk friend into his vehicle, they started off and the crowd began to move on. Buzzing with adrenaline, I made a mental note of his name and license plate, holstered my pistol, climbed in and breathed a long sigh of relief. There were no more cars in front of me, only people, and I was happy to be getting out of there and finally heading home. But it wasn't over yet.

Just as I was about to start moving, four SSU (Special Services Unit) men in vests and full camo gear surrounded my vehicle, pointing M16's and ordered me to exit. I eased into park and slowly stepped out, hands high. I heard a female voice say "Yes that's him! He's the one with the gun!"

Rifles pointed, they ordered me to place my hands on the vehicle. I often train and shoot with SSU guys and I'm quite close to a couple of the officers but I didn't recognize any of these guys. I complied and told them I'm licensed. The one in charge demanded to see the license and I said "Wallet. Left front pocket."

They retrieved the wallet and asked where the gun was. I told them it was in the holster on my right side and one guy lifted my shirt and started tugging on the grip. The holster is a retention type with a thumb release and even though I tried to explain, he was having no success freeing it and just kept tugging.

I said "Look, I just got away from a guy who wanted to cut me open and now I feel like I'm about to be shot in the leg with my own gun. It's a Glock - no safety - and it's chambered - please be careful!" They gave up and told me to take it out and hand it over. I turned around and said not a flippin' chance while rifles are pointed at me. I kept my hands up.

They looked at each other and the one in charge asked to see the license. My family name is fairly well known but if he recognized it, it didn't show at all as he read the particulars aloud. A fellow in the crowd said "That's Buzz (my nickname), You guys don't know Buzz?" He looked up and said "You're Buzz?" I nodded and he seemed to relax and signalled the others to lower the rifles.

He asked me to hand over the gun and I complied, carefully holding it by the end of the grip between thumb and index finger. They immediately removed the magazine and cleared the chamber. I asked them if I needed to call my lawyer. He half smiled and said "Just tell us what happened." I did, and stressed that IMO, I exercised commendable restraint - someone else in my shoes would have shot that guy, and justifiably so as well. He jotted some notes and said "Sir we are returning your firearm and magazine, but please don't load and chamber it until you are clear of the area."

Just then someone ran up and shouted "Fight!" and the officer smiled and nodded at me as they took off in the direction of another commotion further up the road. As I slowly drove by a couple of minutes later, I saw one of the SSU guys manhandling a huge fellow with a torn shirt and a bloody head. Another one gave a broad grin and saluted me when I passed. I nodded wearily, got to open road and finally, finally headed for home.

My heart rate gradually returned to normal as I played with the dogs in the yard. The sun was not quite risen yet, but birds were chirping already and I reflected on how differently things could have turned out, particularly if I had not been armed and, perhaps more importantly, practiced and trained.

A couple of days later, I ran into the sargeant of the local SSU detachment at my bar. When I told him what had happened, he laughed and said he was the one who dispatched the squad after a young woman came up and told them a man up the road was threatening to shoot people. They were anticipating trouble that night and were out in force. One of the squad members told him it was his buddy (me) when they returned. They all agreed that I would have been fully justified if I had actually shot the guy. Personally, I am very happy it didn't end that way.

I have had many conversations about the incident with many different people and I welcome your comments and feedback here.
 
Great story, Buzz. I'm glad you got through, and I'm happy you didn't have to follow through with defending yourself. It's a pet peeve of mine when there is miscommunication and innocent (you) are wrongfully accused. How on earth could that female driver not recognize that she had hit you in the first place?

I had to look up St. Lucia to learn where it is in the Caribbean. Says you guys recognize Queen Elizabeth II as Head of State but there's other Governors and authorities. I'm not too familiar. What are the gun laws like? You say you have a "gun license" -- can anyone get one?

Glad you're OK.
 
The dealer type pulled a long shank - a home made "ice pick" - out of his jacket and started towards me saying he was going to "open up my belly" and at that point I drew the gun and pointed it at his chest.

He stopped advancing but continued waving the shank and threatening, shouting to the crowd that I would never have the guts to pull the trigger. He was wrong. My finger was on the trigger and he was about 12 feet away. I was fully committed to firing if he advanced another step.

You showed way too much restraint for your own good. 12 feet away with a blade and the imminent threat to use it is more than enough reason to fire. If he had committed to an attack, esp. when you were distracted by his friend, you may not have survived.

My opinion is you should have shot him. The crowd is always a coward, and would have scattered. His old friends would have disclaimed even knowing him. You would have had a defunct threat with a blade in his hand or nearby for the police to see.
 
Thats a wild scene you are in down there. you showed grest restraint cant belive it all worked out so well. I am curious about your gun laws also.
 
In the states you can't have a concealed weapon in a bar much less be drinking and have one.

I would say you performed very well. Thank God you didn't have to hurt anyone and didn't get hurt! If that crowd had rioted on you it wouldn't have been good even with a weapon.

Thanks for the story!
 
Sam, the girl was either drunk or simply didn't care. Since there was no damage to my vehicle, I should have just let it go but at the time I was concerned that she would get home and tell her boyfriend or father (or whoever the car belonged to) that I was the one who rear ended her. By allowing her to just leave the scene, she might have had a believable case. Turns out that was the least of my problems.

The Queen Elizabeth thing is a mostly symbolic and represented here by a token governor general. We are an independent country that remains a member of the British Commonwealth. We have a democratic parlimentary system with a prime minister as actual head of state. Hardly anyone one here really cares much about royalty or the English monarchy.

This is from the current thread in the LEGAL forum about gun policies in other countries:
Here in St. Lucia, all firearms require a permit and ALL handgun permits are for concealed carry except for special permits for sporting firearms which allow you to transport that gun to a firing range and require you to be a member of a recognised shooting association. With a regular handgun permit you are required to keep the gun concealed on your person and in your control at all times otherwise it must be securely stored. You are warned not to leave your gun in a vehicle because of the risk of it being stolen. If you own land greater than an acre in size, you can obtain an "estate license" for a rifle or shotgun. Licences are not easy to obtain as you must demonstrate you have a valid reason for needing a gun before a permit will be granted.

Generally, business people and professionals who own homes and/or property are a shoe-in for approval, but it is nowhere close to being a "shall issue" system and the whole process is quite subjective. Penalties for being in posession of an unlicensed firearm are stiff - first offense will net you an automatic $20k fine and a possible one year jail term.

All (legal) guns are registered by serial number and person to person transfers are not permitted. All sales and transfers must go through a designated and licensed dealer.

Of course, as with all gun laws, this only applies to those who abide by the law and the non law-abiding simply buy their guns on the black market.

Cosmoline, you are right, and I was literally on the verge of firing when the other guy intervened. As it turned out though, I am glad that I didn't.
 
It takes 1.8 seconds from 21 feet, for a person with a knife or whatever to travel to you. I would have fired. Glad you survived and no one was hurt.
 
In the states you can't have a concealed weapon in a bar much less be drinking and have one.

I would say you performed very well. Thank God you didn't have to hurt anyone and didn't get hurt! If that crowd had rioted on you it wouldn't have been good even with a weapon.

Thanks for the story!
JCisHe, while there are liquor laws on the books, enforcement is non-existant and I don't think a breathalyzer exists on the island. We are taught in training to avoid being intoxicated while armed, but they stop short of telling us not to carry in bars or anywhere else for that matter. This is because the major focus is on keeping guns out of the hands of criminals and we are warned to keep our handguns with us at all times. Being careless and allowing your gun to be stolen while locked in your car is seriously frowned upon.

The whole situation was ugly and almost surreal. It all happened quite quickly, but some things oddly stood out in my mind: I had an urge to double check the loaded chamber indicator even though I knew a round was chambered, but I couldn't take my finger off the trigger. I was very conscious of the night sights and I recall being surprised that, contrary to what I had been taught would happen, tunnel vision had not set in and I could still see peripherally. The voices of the crowd were crystal clear but somehow they seemed like they were coming from far away.
 
Rightside - Since I had already drawn and had the sights centered on his chest, I am sure I would have put multiple rounds into him if he even looked like he was begining to move forward. I had decided I would sidestep to my right while firing if he continued to advance while taking hits.

When it got really dicey for me was after I had to warn the other guy off. When he did not comply with my command to stand down at that point, I was about to shoot whether he advanced or not.
 
After an attempted robbery incident a few years ago, I always drive home with my pistol in my lap, positioned for a quick, easy presentation. Aware of the potential volatility of the situation,

I understand your reasoning here for doing this, but I advise having the pistol in a holster, glove compartment, or some other way to secure it, for a couple of reasons.

1) In a crash, that pistol becomes a projectile in the cabin.

2) If you are rammed or whatever, or are forced to stop very suddenly, then the pistol can go flying off and you may not be able to get to it easily in case of a robbery or carjacking attempt.

I think you did well, and handled the situation well otherwise.
 
Thanks for the well-wishes guys.

Avenger, good points about lap-carry in the vehicle. I only do this on the very short drive home from the restaurant late at night, because that is the time I am at greatest risk of a robbery attempt. Once I leave the main road, the drive through the neighborhood to my house is a slow, not so well lit drive along narrow,tree-shaded roads.

Balrog - good policy my friend. If I had any idea that crowd was going to be there, I certainly would have avoided it. We now have a capable manager running the show at the restaurant so now most of my evenings are spent at home or relaxing in the company of friends.
 
Last edited:
JCisHe said:
In the states you can't have a concealed weapon in a bar much less be drinking and have one.

Not ALL states, mind you.

Amazing restraint though... it'd be hard not to shoot the shank wielding guy to eliminate that threat as soon as you became aware of the second guy approaching.
 
Well, I personally am glad that you didn't shoot the guy. Your training kept you focused and that you definitely were. Shooting a guy, killing a guy, taking a life is one thing you most probbaly won't get over in your life time. If it was me, I would have done the same as you did. If my kid or wife was with me, then I would have definitely shot the **stard to protect them.

Buzz, you can be my wingman anytime.
 
In the states you can't have a concealed weapon in a bar much less be drinking and have one.

In Oregon you can.

Also I'm glad it turned out ok. last thing you want to do is shoot somebody but you would have been justified if you had to.
 
It seems like many confrontations involve alcohol in one way or another, such as bar fights, parties, whatever. This seems to be the common thread on many of these stories. I think if you want to be safe, it is best to just avoid any place where people are drinking excessively.

Clearly, you did the right thing. My statement was more of an observation than a critique. If we all get the mindset that 'drunk people = likely trouble' that might help keep a lot of us safer. Of course, nobody wants to be in the situation that you were in.

Glad it worked out OK for you.
 
Great story and I think you handled it very well. I dont want to play armchair quarterback because I would likely have left the vehicle to confront the hit and run driver too, but with the crowd around and heated up, call your cop friend with the license plate number.
 
SalchaketJoe, that is the critique I have received more than any other - I probably should have stayed in the vehicle or at least, once I saw that mine was undamaged, I should have just returned to my vehicle and called the police so the details of the accident would be on record. It galls me to allow people to walk/drive away unchalllenged when things like that (the accident) happen, but in retrospect, that would have been the more prudent course of action.
 
Scary story... I would hope to have as much composure as you....

It takes 1.8 seconds from 21 feet

FYI... I just watched Troy Palamalu (Spelling...sorry....) go 42 feet in 1.5 seconds... I know, he is a pro athlete but a lot of young men are in that condition.
 
Scary story. I read it and was on the edge of my seat the entire time. A few points, both good and bad.

Nice job being situationally aware. One thing I've oftentimes been told is to avoid "tunnel vision"; you did just that. You were aware of your target and others around you to realize that someone might be coming up from behind or the side of you.

You made up your mind when you were going to fire the gun. If the guy with the knife or whatever it was took one step towards you, you were going to fire. I feel that's a decision that you have to make beforehand, just like you did. This way you don't second guess yourself and don't allow him to keep taking steps.

A couple things that worry me. I think you should have stayed in your car, even though she did hit you...the situation wasn't in your favor to begin with for having something go wrong. Perhaps next time my best recommendation would to call the police or whoever you call right away and just try to find a spot that was close-by but not surrounded by potentially hostile people. As long as you get the phone call in right away, I would think (I'm no expert so don't quote me or anything) that you would be fine.

In the end, you are alive, and that is what matters most. You're safe, everyone went home (for the most part) safe, and you didn't have to shoot anyone.


As a side note, how is your anxiety level, depression, and anxiety level now after some time has passed after an incident? Everything okay or are you still having some problems? The only reason I ask is because being a healthcare professional, I've seen people in these types of situations and some have long lasting emotional problems after the incident. You don't have to say them on here, but just something you may want to think about and see counseling for or something like that if you need it.


Nice job.
 
If I were in you shoes, I would have shot that guy when he pulled out that ice pick and walked towards me. I wouldn't know if he was going to charge at me or throw it at me. Either way would have ended bad.
 
You were lucky that guy intervened. I'm glad everything turned out OK.
 
As a side note, how is your anxiety level, depression, and anxiety level now after some time has passed after an incident? Everything okay or are you still having some problems? The only reason I ask is because being a healthcare professional, I've seen people in these types of situations and some have long lasting emotional problems after the incident. You don't have to say them on here, but just something you may want to think about and see counseling for or something like that if you need it

Thanks for asking Xyas. I have no problem discussing this aspect openly. Initially of course, for a few days I'd feel a rush of adrenaline every time I thought about the incident. As time went by and I played the scenario over and over in my mind I found myself getting more and more angry.

I was angry at the girl for her actions and attitude, I was angry at the punks for their violent hostility, and I was extremely angry at the crowd in general for their coliseum mentality - egging the violence on instead of standing up for what is right. I felt a sense of outrage that with no ill-intentions or malice on my part, a group of people had seemingly condemned me to death (or at least grevious bodily harm). At times, I even found myself angry with me for not shooting the bastard.

With more time, the anger subsides (though it has never completely gone away) and rationality begins to take over. I realize that I need to focus on the aspects of the incident that were under my control. I took a more introspective approach, discussed it with people and I actually found it therapeutic to see myself gradually becoming less angry and outraged about it than most of the people I discuss it with.

I am happy with my response to the threat in the sense that I acted as I had been trained and conditioned to do - there was no feeling of panic or confusion - I was quite clear and deliberate in everything I said and did. I am especially happy now that I don't have to deal with the aftermath of killing the guy. I also realise however, that by not checking my automatic reactions to what other people did, I allowed myself to get into a deadly situation that may have been avoided completely if I had been more thoughtful. So some work is still required.

All in all, what bit of faith I had in the basic humanity of the general populace has been tested and is now tempered with a greater measure of watchful scepticism. Other than that, I remain fundamentally unchanged and continue to enjoy life, love and the pursuit of happiness, much as I did before this crap happened.:)
 
conwict, yes - we were both lucky.

netav8or, that rig looks like just what I need. Thanks.

An interesting aside: since our vehicles here are right hand drive, I would be drawing and shooting with my left (weak side) hand while driving and I have had to practice accordingly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top