For me rapid fire is faster and more accurate with a Glock 17 vs an XD 9. There are little difference in felt recoil but 5 shot groups in under 2 seconds are better with the G17 (at least for me). Cost and availability of magazines and accessories, is also another concern, again Glock over the XD. Competitive shooters in IDPA and USPSA shoot Glock, S&W M&P, and CZs with few if any XDs ( at my local club ). People whine about grip angle on the Glock, the problem ain't the pistol. I can shoot a 1911 and then pick up a Glock and not miss a beat, or vice versa. I have shot more models of XDs and XDm than I have Glocks, I cannot say I will ever own any Springfield except a 1911 A1. If you want to skip the 2 hour round trip, get a Glock G19 or G17, you won't be disapointed, with an XD you might not be, maybe.