The Ithaca is still a good deal, I would prefer a regular take down model, but I have fond memories of my VN Ithaca, a blue "Deerslayer" still with the engraving of Bambi on the receiver. The Govt. bought huge numbers of them, some literally off the shelf, and sent them to VN.
After lugging many different weapons in my aircraft, I finally settled on that Ithaca, it was light, packed a real punch at close range(and if the range was not close, the BG was not going to hear from me), and were dead bang reliable, never heard of one that failed to go bang. I also liked the manual operation, kind of like the revolvers we were issied, did not depend on some automatic action to function, always worked even when dirty.