Liking revolvers more than semi auto's?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Slimjim

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
751
Location
Maryland.
I have a springfield operator which ive been thinking of trading for a nice revolver because lately..I just like the revolver alot more than the semi auto. I dont know what it is about them, the fact that there are so many "TACTICAL" Auto loaders and everything has to be tactical now, i just want to get back to basics. I mean, im considering a 627 which is a pretty high tech revolver, being 8 shots of 357 magnum. I know i should probly keep the 1911, but i believe a revolver could fulfill the same roles, as long as you consider the rule of threes of a normal gunfight. Who else feels this way that they're liking revolvers more nowadays?

Also, are moonclips as fast to reload as magazines?
 
My second handgun was a revolver and it's still my favorite after buying another semi.
Here's my reasons:
1. Operation is simple. If gun is loaded, pull trigger and gun goes bang, if it doesn't pull trigger again.
You don't ever have to think about what state the pistol is in. (well assuming it's loaded of course)
2. They are generally more accurate then semis.
3. They can handle some pretty heavy loads and the .357 may be one of the more versatile
cartridges around.
4. I find they point more naturally then most semis I've handled.
5. Less prone to jam. Could happen, maybe a bad primer or something, but in general
they are by design more likely to succeed at sending lead down range.
6. You don't have to worry about buying a bunch of expensive magazines. Although,
you probably do need some speedloaders.

I don't know if you can ever get as fast as loading a semi as a revolver (on average) but, especially
with moon clips, you can get fast enough.
 
i like revolvers and autos i really like 9mm revovlvers i have two in 9mm and one 357 one in 45 and 5 38 specials
 
I really like revolvers more than semis. Being 25 most of my friends dont agree with me. But they do say I have very nice tastes in firearms. I think a nice revolver just has more "class" than a semi. Really, I think only a few semis have any "class" at all.
 
I owned well over 40 different centerfire semi auto pistols before I finally concluded they just don't make one I'm going to really like. A Smith 1006 came closest I guess. The only one that never jammed with anyreasonable load I fed it was a SIG P230 in pipsqueak .380 caliber.
I have found several revolvers I really like.
 
I'm quite the revolver fan myself,I own 4 of them,(5 really,though I've retired it)but I also own 4 autos as well. Depending on what kind of mood I'm in I either carry a revolver or an auto and a BUG. I love the power and how simple and reliable my revolvers are,but I also love the HC mags and lightning fast reloads of my autos. Most days I carry one of each.
If I were you I'd hold on to your auto,and just buy the revolver too;theres something to be said for havin' the best of both worlds.
 
....but i believe a revolver could fulfill the same roles, as long as you consider the rule of threes of a normal gunfight.....

This sort of indicates to me that you're using these firearms for protection at least to some extent. As I read the first part of your post I thought "here's another sport shooter enjoying the hardware and looking for a new shooting experience" until I got to the quoted part.

As a sport shooter by all means buy more or ONLY IF YOU MUST trade one for another. But for defense fashion and trends should not be a factor in selecting your tool of choice. However if it's a blend of both and you're just looking for a new direction to take your sport shooting while still having an effective protection tool then by all means fill your boots.

But if you enjoyed the Springfield a lot in the past I'd strongly suggest keep it and buy the revolver option as an additional gun. Tacticool Trends be damned, a 1911 is great fun to have and shoot. Besides, it's the one that MADE the movement before anyone knew there WAS a Tacticool movement. The revolver option has you in it's grasp for now but the 1911 will lure you back to some equal time luvin' soon enough.... :D

And yes, I have both and enjoy them equally. If *GULP* I ever had to give up all my handguns but for one I'm really not sure if it would be a semi or a revolver. Likely my grey cell would go into thermal meltdown and I'd turn to a statue with the last semi locked in one hand and the last revolver locked in the other unable to let go of either... :D
 
I shot Sigs for years (have a 226 and 239 both in .40 S&W) and love them. However, I recently bought a S&W .44 mag 629 classic in an attempt to "get back to basics." It's clearly a fun and exciting gun to shoot but I quickly rekindled my relationship with the Sigs. They are two totally different types of weapons and I wouldn't give up one for the other. I guess if you absolutely had to have only one gun, then I would go with the revolver (357, 41 or 44) just because of the reliability factor, however small that difference is these days.
 
I've gone 100% revolver. To me they have the advantage in every area except "combat", whatever that is. When I started loading all of my ammo, my last 1911 had to go. I got tired of shagging brass all over the range. I do have several moonclipped revolvers that reload as fast as any semi.
 
I could never part with my 1911s but I also could never part with my wheel guns. .357 Magnums rule! Although I think I really need to try a .44 Mag. :)
 
i have been debating on whether or not to sell off my autos and go strictly to revolvers as well. however, it is hard for me to let go of any firearm that has proven to be accurate and reliable. so i think i will keep what i got, and just let my future purchases be for revovlers.

i started off with autos as my ccw and hd guns. now i use revolvers for ccw and for my main hd. so i definitly have a preference for em.
 
I love revolvers, own many, and my very first CCW was a revolver many moons ago... but I learned early on in my shooting "career" that I simply shoot semi-autos better.

Were that not the case, I'd still be carrying a revolver daily all these years later...
 
I love the feel and look of revolvers and own several, but SD is not about looks, it's about pragmatism....that's why I carry a Glock.
 
Can't say why but I've always enjoyed my revolvers over the semi autos. Just feel better, easier to reload and no chasing spent brass.
 
I've probably owned more guns than most and less than some; and I still like revolvers more than semis. There are times, though, that I like semi autos more than the revolvers and there's a lot to be said for the .45 Auto especially. Recoil's easy on the wrist and that big ol' round makes nice holes in the target.

Right now, my semi-auto of choice is the 9mm Sig P-226. The ammo's cheap and relatively plentiful. I can also reload for it and never, ever, throw any of my centerfire brass away after a shootin' session.

For some weird reason, I only own two revolvers (living in an Rv van has a lot to do with it), one's a two-and-a-half-inch S&W 686+. That lil' smacker spits 158 grainers with such accuracy, I wonder how good I'd be with it if I was still 23 and didn't need glasses... the other one is as old school as it gets, a 6"Colt Trooper MkIII with walnut Colt target stocks and so accurate it brings joy to me whenever I'm at the range. "Trooper" is fed a steady diet of hand loaded lead semi wadcutters or hollow base wadcutters using mild target loads of Bullseye powder.

Lately, I've had this irresistible urge to get me a new revolver, a 4 inch Smith in .357 persuasion with fixed sights and no full underlug. Saw a stainless K-Frame in a pawn shop last week, all holster worn and scratched, and thought, "hmmm...that might be the perfect all 'round oldschool gun..." I still might get it as a project gun for shooting fun and as a BUG gun in the rig; Maybe buff it up into a shiny pimp gun just for fun, or alternately, have S&W refinish and slick up the action.

But there I go fantasizing again, just can't help it with revolvers and god help me, tomorrow's payday!
 
Last edited:
I don't necessarily like one over the other, but I will say that my carry gun is a revolver as is my bedside gun. It's not so much that I like revolvers better, it's more a matter of caliber. I happen to feel that the .357 is the bees knees, and so I now own three .357 revolvers.

Past that, I am about equally split. I enjoy shooting both about equally, though I will say that I am much more open to trying different Autos than I am revolvers. By that I mean that a new Auto might spark my interest whereas a new revolver? Eh. I know what I like in a revolver, and I don't have any particular urge to experiment past that.
 
I own both, and I Have a great Semi-auto (BHP), but the rest of my guns are revolvers, there is something nice about a revolver, they look better (Personal View of course) easier to train with, more fun to shoot (as again, both in my view), and I do like the "true metal" guns.

As for self-defense, the best thing about a revolver is that if I get in a point where I would have to defend myself (I hope I am NEVER in that place) I trust myself to remember how to use a revolver, and any problems with a revolver, then a semi-auto.

That and you can put some powerful rounds in a wheelgun.
 
I've always preferred shooting revolvers, but I kinda prefer carrying autos. I would live happy with only my .38 for carry, though. I like revolvers PRECISELY because they are NOT as "high tech". Put a rail on one and pimp it out and I suddenly don't like it. I guess I'm old.

Never cared much for moon clips, either, no way to do a "tac reload". I'd rather carry a speedloader and a speed strip or just a couple of speed strips. If I find myself reloading in a gun fight, something went WAY wrong. I really don't miss that often. And, if I have to make a reload, it will be behind cover. I do have a NY reload in my left pocket to keep their heads down if necessary.
 
I like both, each has its applications. Whatever you use THE most important factor is that it fits you and functions as an extension of your finger. If it doesn't, make it so. If you can't make it so, get something different. Lot's of firepower doesn't help you if you miss with all of them, or forget which lever does what when you need it to go bang. THE MOST IMPORTANT accessory to improve your shooting ability is ammo. Whatever platform you choose-Practice Practice Practice.
 
I love the feel and look of revolvers and own several, but SD is not about looks, it's about pragmatism....that's why I carry a Glock.

Sorry, I should have said "usually."

There are times that I am not totally pragmatic and also times when pragmatism may mean carrying a revolver.

I like those times best.

:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top